The Tinder Box get 3 stars for selection, which was somewhat lacking. It gets 4 stars for being one of the few cigar shops around. The Tinder Box has moved around Mashpee Commons a few times — I hadn’t been to the recent location for a few years. Overall, for a medium sized shop I would have expected move selection and stuffed humidors, but didn’t find that. I was able to find some nice cigars though. Prices are very reasonable.