Pie Five Pizza Co.

I love you Pie Five! I don’t know why I don’t come more often. Quick and tasty every time. Very nice staff. I used to just bring the kids here when we couldn’t decide on one kind of pizza, but I have found myself coming more for lunch just for me! The rewards program is pretty cool too. Got my pie for free today! Winning!

Slightly overpriced in my opinion, but much better quality than if you order Dominos, Papa Johns, or anything of that tier.
However, the food is really good. The first time my boyfriend and I went here I remember looking at my pizza and thinking «this is so small I am going to need a second dinner later.» But I couldn’t even finish it!!! So filling and yummy.
I’ve tried the carbonara and BBQ pizza. Both were excellent and I’m currently dreaming about a double cooked BBQ pizza.
While we don’t go here that often, it’s a nice change of pace and you get to pretend you’re having a make your own pizza night because you can choose all the toppings you want!
I wish they had better side or dessert options but I understand that their main focus is the pizza.

Very interesting concept– fresh ingredients. I ordered the Tucson chicken pizza and it was great! I honestly have never seen anything like it so I was interested when a group from church asked us to join them. Individualized pizza — what? No bickering with your significant other on pizza sauce and toppings — yes please! I took off a star bc it was oddly smoky and I smelled like I had worked there for 12 hrs for the rest of the day.

Love the concept of this! It’s like subway but with pizza instead. Lines can sometimes be long but it’s worth it. I went with my friend and her 4 year old nephew and they were very accommodating to her nephew. Restaurant is clean and lots of parking. Pizza was delicious and I love how I can watch what toppings they put on there as well as how much sauce. Food didn’t take long. Salads are also good. I would definitely come back.

I give this place 3 stars on the fact that the restaurant itself is pretty neat and tidy. The food on the other hand is average at best. The cheese is low tier, the dough is okay, the pepperoni is average. It’s a standard pizza place, except there are better pizza joints in town.

It was ok at the best. Salad was no worth it. The bread bowl was hard as a rock. It hasn’t been someplace I’ve returned to.

Horrible. Almost inedible pizza. We ordered six pizzas. The crust was like cardboard and the toppings were incredibly sparse on my families pizzas. We would have rather have spent the money on a legitimate pizza restaurant.

My daughter loves this place. Like that they have a gluten free option for my wife, but a really good option for quick and fun pizza.

Hands down best pizza in Indian Trail/​Matthews area. We come here once a week! So many different options, fun environment and friendly staff!

Not great, but not awful. Only one of the young ladies was friendly and seemed to care about being there. Notice the workers who were kneadinfg the dough were gloveless. Think I prefer the thin crust to the traditional here. Allows to cook the toppings bette. Nice they have a rewards program and would go again, just no more special trips.

My 7 year old loved the kids cheese pizza, but I thought the gluten free crust was good but not enough cheese and tasted like it was put through a microwave oven. Overall great price but you always get what you pay for. Service as not great either. Not many working seemed excited to be there.

Pie five is the most delicious and genius idea in the world! Every time I go I make sure to get the buffalo chicken pizza and sometimes add either bacon or more tomato ! I absolutely love making and creating my own delicious pizza. The service is always attentive and helpful and the food is alway amazing. I love bringing friends and letting them experience Pie Five!

Not only is the pizza amazing, the service is impeccable and second to none. Its my pleasure to pay for this product

Love this place. It’s like a subway, but with pizza instead of subs. Our family loves it so much, we have been here 4 times in 2 months!!!

Love it! So hard to find great gluten-​free pizza! It’s was delicious, the seating area was clean and the staff was very friendly. I’ll definitely be coming back!

I’m in search of the perfect pineapple pizza. Pie Five’s pineapple and ham pizza was absolutely scrumptious. The classic pan crust was so fluffy and the sauce and cheese blended beautifully. The pineapple was pretty fresh and the ham was tasty. The Magic Dust was the perfect touch and it helped make the pizza truly unique. I thoroughly enjoyed eating the pizza. The ambiance was casual even though I grabbed the pizza to go.
I used a coupon which made the pizza a few dollars cheaper.

New concept, great taste! It’s sorta like a better alternative to going to a local pizza joint to pick up slices, except getting a whole personal pizza with all the topping you’d want. The pizza was $ 6.79, and I will be back soon. With Chipotle in the next plaza over, this is the area to grab a quick, personalized bite to eat.
I had the Athenian pizza with traditional pan crust and ranch sauce, and added bacon. So delicious, and it is more than enough for one hungry person. I also got a slice of chocolate chip cookie pie which I will skip next time.

What a good find! Think subway meets pizza and voila, you have Pie Five! The pizzas are made to order, right in front of you. You choose the crust, the sauce and as many toppings as your heart desires. Then they pop in the oven and about 7 minutes later, fresh yummy pizza! They also have a menu of speciality pizzas so you don’t have to do much of the heavy lifting. Best part? All of this ends up to be around $ 5-​$ 6! My ABSOLUTE favorite combo is the BBQ Chicken pizza with a pan crust and of course, I add pineapples. Talk about a foodgasm! I guess you can have yours without pineapples, but I mean, that would just be silly.

So we have visited Pie 5 twice now, love the concept and the prices can’t be beat $ 7 for a pizza LOADED with good toppings of your choice. Today I had the «High Five» but added mushrooms and red onions, my wife got the Athenian, we got a side salad, a dessert and 2 drinks for $ 18.
The concept is simple, you can order from their suggested toppings and crust or build your own… not as complicated as some make it to be. The side salads are good, we had the Italian today and it was really good. The desserts are ok, we got the turtle brownie and my wife and I both agreed it had a cinnamon taste which we didn’t care for.
The menu boast «craft beer»…was VERY disappointed at the beer selection… from memory Bud, Bud Light, Miller Light, Mick Ultra, and Stella (that was the one considered craft). Spoke with who I assume was the owner, suggested they work on getting some better local beers… in case they read this review NoDa Brewing Co starts canning their beers this month, also Foothills, Highland etc are some other real craft beers you could have on the shelf easily.
If your in the area and like pizza I’d check it out.

Pie Five is a perfectly OK fast food alternative, I’m convinced this new franchise will do well but rating it on par with say … Pure? I mean come on, that’s simply preposterous!
I found a coupon in my mail box, my first thought was «great, one more pizza franchise, just what Matthews needed!» –Not. The concept looked intriguing: any pizza, any combination of toppings, one price (under $ 7) so I decided to check it out.
There was a small rush when I got there maybe 20 people ahead of me including kids. The help was hustling as fast as it could, particularly a kid in a black tee who seemingly was hammering down and garnishing everyone’s pizza single handed –and feeling the pain. The order process was rushed, customers seemed overwhelmed and tended to say ‘that’s all’ after only a couple of toppings.
Not yours truly, I asked for: classic pan crust, Tuscan marinara, minced garlic (turned out to be prepared garlic in oil), Mozzarella/​Provolone blend, spinach, Italian sausage and bacon (both crumbled), red onions and artichoke hearts, sprinkled with parmesan and herbs mix on top. And a Stella with that.
Honestly what I got LOOKED great and was tasty — so it should be considering the toppings I picked. Why only 3 stars? Because quality-​wise the toppings were middle of the road — not the worst but not gourmet either — but most of all because of the crust.
I’m not sold on the taste and consistency of this dough formulated to bake in 2 minutes or less — which this was.