Coneheads Homemade Ice Cream

My family and I went in and the service was horrible. The guy didn’t want to pay attention to us when it was our turn. He was busy on his phone. And the ice cream was frozen ice milk. It was not creamy and had ice crystals in it. We will never go back. I will drive far to get real ice cream.

Excellent place, one of the best ice cream spots in all of NJ. Homemade, great and friendly service, nostalgic restaurant with old photos on the walls, trivia pursuit game, lots of fun and excitement. Would recommend it to anybody who loves ice cream and good service.

love this place. ice cream is freshly made and delicious. super nice people. always happy when we stop in there.

Love this place! Friendly staff and quality ice cream! They have Trivia Pursuit questions on the tables too!!! Our family enjoys getting ice cream and answering some questions. Chocolate shake is rich and delicious. The water ice is good too. Sundaes are amazing and it’s a fun place. When we went they only accepted checks and cash, No debit or credit card. They were understanding about us not having cash and said, «Finish your ice cream and come back with it.» Great small town establishment that cares about the neighbors. Love this place!

Coneheads is a nice local independent ice cream shop. The service is usually very friendly and you can’t beat the Trivial Pursuit cards ont he tables.
We stopped in late one night right before closing and the owner was happy to help us. He even made a fresh batch of their delicious homemade whipped cream.
The portions are large and the products are fresh. I recommend this place over any chains in the area. It’s a little pricey for ice cream; we got 3 smalls for about $ 15 but worth it.

This place is extremely nostalgic for me. This was one of my favorite ice cream shops as a kid growing up in NJ.
Coneheads does it right. They have a variety of homemade flavors, unlimited pretzel sticks and trival pursuit!
I went last night for dessert and it looks exactly the same as I remembered it to be. I got a cone of cookie dough and had a smile on my face the whole way home.

As good as the ice cream is, they have probably the best wooder ice I’ve ever had. It’s beyond addiction. I bought three quarts for the family and ate about two myself. I was up all night taking a leak. It’s that good. All the flavors I’ve had are excellent.

Wow this hotspot has it ALL! The best ice cream I have ever had. I don’t want any other types of ice cream after trying this place. hell whenever I’m in the Medford area, I gotta stop by here… The owners are really nice as well and they are super friendly and offer great service. They definitely need more places like this… ⁵⁄₅

I came to visit my friend all the way in NJ and he took me to his favorite spot to get ice cream. This place owns all. Nothing like the chains around here in SoCal like Cold Stones or Dairy Queen. It actually has a nice, family-​like, authentic feeling when you walk in, and you can tell every unique flavor has been well thought out and formulated. If you want to try something different and good, go hit this place up. Shout out to the seasonal flavors.

I’ve been coming to Coneheads since I was little, and it is one of my favorite ice cream places ever. I’m sure that’s partly because I grew up on it, but it’s also because it’s just delicious. It’s made on site and tastes rich and fresh. My favorite is coffee oreo, but they only have that from time to time. The cookie dough, oreo, and plain coffee are also solid. They more adventurous flavors, too, but I tend to go for the more traditional. The hot fudge is also killer and the home-​made whipped cream is incredible. The sizes are huge. I usually get a kid’s size and it’s more than enough.
I’ll always remember nights with friends eating the free pretzels they have on the tables and quizzing each other on the trivial pursuit cards they keep handy.
It makes me sad how every time I go in now when I’m home there’s no one in there. There used to be huge crowds on summer nights and a decent showing during the winter. I’m not sure why there’s been such a change — probably because there’s more competition now (Cold Stone, etc.). But I will always be loyal to Coneheads!