Michelli’s Pizzeria

Love this place! We try to get delivery every 1 – 2 weeks. Greek salad, garlic knots, mozzarella cheese sticks and single slice pizza is what we order. The garlic cheese bread is also phenomenal. Looking forward to our next order!

Fabulous pizza. Order early as they are busy but the food is worth the wait. Best pizza I’ve had in the Melbourne area.

Very good. Had the Meat Fest pizza and mozzarella sticks. Everyone at the table enjoyed the pizza; service was friendly & efficient.

Best pizza in the Melbourne/​Palm Bay area.

We ordered the family meal that came with the 16″ pizza, wings and garlic knots. The service was very quick, however, the food could use have used more flavor. The garlic knots were doused in butter — there was so much butter that there was a small pool at the bottom of the dish. It lacked in the taste of garlic. The dough was OK. Dense. The wings were supposed to have a garlic flavor but we couldn’t taste it. Same situation with the oil at the bottom of the dish. The pizza fared the best out of the 3 dishes we tried. Loved the atmosphere but the food could use stronger flavor to get this restaurant 5 stars from us.

Stopped by here tonight to share a pizza with my family. This is a very nice pizzeria and the staff here is friendly and great at making sure your drink cup is full.
Ordered their meat lovers pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots were fresh, with a soft center, and a light crispy crust. The knotd were covered with oil, butter, garlic, and cheese Tasty!
The pizza was a nice size and covered with a generous amount of meat toppings. Combined with a good sauce and quality cheese made for a tasty combination.
We will be back.

My husband is from New York and well — Iam not. He really likes a good NY style pie. I on the other hand, cannot eat dairy. I need everything that isn’t pizza to be good! This is our middle ground. We have gone to other local places and the quality does not match Michelli’s. I will say they are VERY busy, but it is worth the wait. On top of the great food, they have great service. The woman at the counter is very nice. They don’t keep you guessing on your wait time and they are constantly informing you that it has X amount of wait time left. I am by no means a regular either! I have seen regulars come in and everyone is treated like a friend. I highly recommend this. I get the Greek salad!

2 hours and 20 min delivery. Very unprofessional, food horrible and cold.
Never again!

We LOVE Michelli’s. The food is great, the owners are even better, and the service has always been incredible. The ONLY reason we stopped eating at Michelli’s is because of the delivery wait times. I’d expect 30 – 45 minutes unless it’s a holiday or normally busy dinner time. But no matter when I call, the wait is ALWAYS well over an hour. I would hope they would either invest into a new oven or new delivery person. If they would improve on the delivery times we would be back as it used to be our go-​to treat when friends and family would visit from out of town.

Last night my husband and I had pizza from Michelle’s and to tell you the truth I like their pizza because they make the crust the way I like it thin. The pizza good my only problem is by the time it gets here it’s not hot enough so I can only give it 4 ½ stars. Sorry Diana Bellizzi delivery it hot and you’ll get 5 stars.

So good! Took a little bit of time for them to take my order but they were crazy busy. I got garlic knots which were excellent and a small pizza. Looked greasy but it actually wasn’t! It was fantastic! Loved the fact they had regulars come in and they were talking to the owner catching up like old friends. :) I will definitely go back next time I drive thru this area.

Garlic knots are very yummy! Pizza great! Stuffed shells great! Delivery people are on time!

Excellent food. Probably the best pizza in the Melbourne/​Palm Bay area. Also has the best buffalo chicken sandwich (Ed’s Favorite) I’ve ever had. The only reason I can’t give it 5 stars is because the delivery wait time is typically 1 hour to 1:30 hours. They tell you this over the phone so it’s not unexpected, but I’d order so much more often if it was 30 – 45 minutes like other places.

This place not only has the best Italian in Palm Bay/​Melbourne, they also have the best service. After my boyfriend and I were told by friends to check this place out, we’ve been back once a week ever since. Their dinner special for two (ziti or stuffed shells) is our usual, but their pizza is out of this world too. They have the best tomato sauce I’ve ever had, and their portions are very generous. They treat you like family and are always friendly and up beat. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for delicious Italian food.

I was recently in Florida vacationing and spent a day on the coast before heading back toward Orlando. I found this place via Unilocal and thought I’d give it a try. The staff was so kind and helpful. I ordered the mediterranean pizza and it was ready in about 25 minutes. I thought I’d take it in my car back to Orlando and eat it there… but the pizza smelled so good I couldn’t wait. I dove into a slice or two on the drive and OH MY GOSH. DELICIOUS!!! I’m not even a fan of onions and artichokes, but I just wolfed it all down and it was fabulous! Not too greasy or anything. Great thin crust and intense flavor! I brought the pizza home for my sister – I anticipated her picking off the veggies and all, but she thought it was perfect and delicious too! (And she’s a picky eater…)
Wish this place was in Austin, TX! It was delicious!

Excellent pizza and great garlic teriyaki wings. The hardest part is waiting for time to past after you have placed the order.

I live in Ocala, but I am in Melbourne every week. I make sure to order from Michelli’s every Sunday when I am in town. I waited to post a review so that I could try a few different menu items. As far as the pizza goes, it’s a tie between The New Yorker and The Michelli’s. I have also had the jumbo wings which are amazing, nice and crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Bottom line everything in Michelli’s is fantastic, you just have to figure out what you’re in the mood for.
If you choose to have it delivered (as I do) expect about an hour to an hour and a half wait time. This should be viewed as a positive thing, Michelli’s is always very busy which should be an indicator of just how good the food is. When my food arrives to my home it is still hot, every single time!
My personal favorites which are always a part of my weekly order include: a house salad, an order of the garlic cheese bread and a side of the made to order Alfredo sauce, which is only around 2.50 for a 2 oz cup, and don’t forget an order of the jumbo wings 10 – 20 depending on apatite, I like the mild garlic sauce.
Try Michelli’s for yourself and don’t forget to tip your drivers if you order delivery and if you dine in or pick up, make sure you tip in house as well.

Love this place! It’s family owned and they have great pizza. We love their pizzas, calzones, and garlic knots. My only warning is that they do a ton if business on the weekends, so it may take 45min –1hr 15 to pick up. Other than that, try it! :)

I’m from new you’re so to have found this place I’m really happy atmosphere is nice and food is great deff would recommend this place

For palm bay, the best. Friendly owners. I remember when they first opened and I would walk over every day for a slice of pizza. I would tell all my friends to give it a try and now this is the only place we will all go! I used them for my daughters 2cd bday. the eggplant pizza was good! If you are just having friends or family over… perfect place to order from. If you are having it delivered .have cash. The stuffed shells are yummy! And pretty decent salads too. Just all around a nice place and great food. Priced fairly also.