Colonial Pantry

It’s a small shop with big flavors. I just ate the Lobster Salad Sandwich and my mouth wants me to order another one even though my stomach is full.
The man who runs it is wonderfully nice and even the patrons that I talked to are fantastic. I may need to eat there at least once a week.

Love at first bite — this place looks like a hole in the wall but has the best coslaw I’ve ever had! I ordered a simple turkey sandwich and it was the best I’ve ever had and I’m very picky! However, it is a little pricey.

Best sloppy Joe I have ever had! This place is fantastic. I loved the stories and the history behind this hidden gem. ;)

Nice, homey, friendly unpretentious place for breakfast or lunch. Has the feel of a fifties coffee shop.

Went here for the first time this past weekend, and I am definitely coming back! The place smelled amazing when I walked in. It is a small deli, but everything is visible, and there was a wide variety of choices. My sandwich was delicious. It was fresh, tasted amazing, and handmade right in front of me. I am very picky about sandwiches, and this place is definitely a gem. The service was fast, and everyone was super nice. They also had fresh peaches for sale, which is something I have not seen before at a deli. I highly recommend anyone go here if they are looking for high-​quality, fresh ingredients. The only negative is that the storefront is not very visible from the road. I didn’t even know this place existed until a friend mentioned we should get lunch here. Had I known, I would’ve tried it out much sooner!

I live in California and we make Colonial Pantry’s Sloppy Joes one of the «must haves» everytime we visit.
They just have the right ratio of turkey, French dressing, and Cole slaw on every sandwich. We’ve had other
Slopy Joe’s from other delis and this is the best we have found.

I love this tiny little place. It’s takeout only, but the atmosphere is great. Take a gander at the oak meat locker and sundries on the shelves, and you feel like you stepped back in time. They make the best Italian sub around. The owner feels strongly about the quality of the food he sells and always has a small selection of homemade salads, fresh vegetables, and prime cuts of meat. My only complaint is that it seems a little pricey for a deli.