High Street Eatery

Wonderful local fresh friendly fun.
Recommend to everyone. We have taken all our out of town guest for lunch and always get great reviews. Can’t wait for summer on the patio. Keep up the quality and atmosphere and we will keep coming back.

Smashing rehearsal dinner ! We recently held our son’s wedding rehearsal dinner here, and the guests had a fantastic time. The owner suggested we serve 4 of the gourmet sandwich selections with amazing bread from Crust in Fenton cut in quarters, Caesar salad, and Mac and cheese buffet style. We had small cuts of bruchetta for hors d’oeuvres, and bottles of wine, and pitchers of red and white sangria with fruit. The pitchers were kept filled and our guests could order beer and soft drinks from our servers or the bar. We used the private upstairs room nicely set for 37. It was a bit tight, but our guests were able to mingle and visit comfortably. Downsides were that we had only 2 servers, who had to run up the stairs with the food and beverages, but they worked very very hard. The main dinner was later than we had asked, so I would recommend you visit first, check out the space, and ask about how many staff will be available for your event. We served bread pudding with heavy cream or rum sauce for dessert. The tab was very very low and we were absolutely delighted with our affair in the lovely little town of Metamora.

What a wonderfully unique dining experience. Their menu is mostly sandwiches but unique, unusual sandwiches. Friendly servers, great choice in adult beverages. Will definitely return.

Delicious food! I had the pulled pork sandwich on sourdough… yummmmmmy! Normally I’m not a coleslaw fan, but it’s a perfect topper for this sandwich! We were seated outside, and it was lovely despite the mosquitoes (that’s Michigan summer for you)! My only complaint is that it seemed to be a long wait for a few sandwiches… but you can’t rush perfection! I would definitely go back.

So glad we came out here, we loved this place. My husband and I shared some Mac & Cheese, a Caprese Artichoke sandwich, and a Baja Chicken sandwich (yes, we were hungry!) and enjoyed them all. Looking forward to our next visit and we’ll save room for dessert. The service was great and the owner, Nikki, was a great hostess.

This place has great food and services. You can tell heart and soul is put into everything. Salmon patties are amazing! The desert was great too!

Sandwiches are all amazing, starting with the fresh sourdough bread, grilled to a nice crisp! (My favorite part) I tried the «goat» with chicken, goat cheese with pesto, and bacon. Ate a bite of my mothers artichoke caprese sandwich, equally as good. Will definitely return for a bowl of my own potato soup with smoked ham. French press coffee is great. Service and the owner were super attentive. Prices are very reasonable for the high quality ingredients and homemade dishes.

Came here for lunch with my wife and daughter, we started with potato soup that was out of this world, we each ordered different sandwiches and traded with each other, we all agreed that the sandwiches were top notch! I will definitely put this on my regular list of restaurants to visit!

We drove seven miles to find out that they are «closed for remodeling». They seem to be permanently closed because they been closed for at least a year now.
When a business does this unexpectedly it usually means that they have given up and closed the doors for good.
Time has spoken, this place is dead.

Perfect place for sandwiches, whether for lunch of dinner. Went out to eat with my family, 7 people as every single person loved their meal.

We came from Rochester to check out a new place. It was worth the drive. I had a burger and my wife had ‘The Cow’. Both were great. I also the Jamaican Me Crazy coffee which was also good. The place has a casual relaxing feel. It seems they do good business yet it was quiet and not trendy and loud like many other places.

Went to lunch today and ordered the Mac and cheese, it was AMAZING! My mom had the Michigan salad and it was really great too! We both had leftovers and it was under $ 15 total!

Wow. The breads from Crust In Fenton are top notch. Service friendly! Atmosphere nice, they were swamped while we were there but the server kept up very nicely. Nice selection of gourmet grilled cheese!

French press coffee, very nice grilled veggie sandwich, fresh local made breads. Simple, fresh, elegant but not snobby. Great for lunches — dine in/​carry out. Seating also outside on front deck. Friendly & accommodating owners.

My gram introduced me to this place with high praise. I was not disappointed. I’ve had The Goat & The Pig and have been blown away by both. Plus the place as the Metamora charm you could only hope for! Love it! I’ll be back each time I’m among the hills!

Heard about this place through a friend, so had to give it a try. Their sandwiches and burgers were amazing. We ordered «The Cow» sandwich and a bacon cheeseburger. The burger was comparable to Red Coat of Royal Oak or Luxe of Birmingham without the long wait. Also, If available, don’t pass up on the pumpkin bread pudding. Cozy atmosphere, friendly owners, well worth the drive.