That Pretty Place

Extremely let down. My wife & myself checked in to the Honeymoon Suite, only to find that it was way too cold, and our first thought for warming ourselves up – the jacuzzi — was «temporarily out of order.» I called to see what could be done about making the room’s temperature warmer (the thermostat also seemed to be temporarily out of order), but the extremely unhelpful gentleman who answered the office phone did nothing to solve the problem. He identified himself as «Wes!», but seemed to be expecting a personal call, and had little interest in answering my questions or providing help of any kind. He even turned up the techno music he was listening to louder during our phone call, told me to «get some poppers and relax, baby!», and hung up on me! It was unlike anything my wife and myself have ever experienced in our years of enjoying various fine American bed & breakfasts. We will not be returning. Not recommended.

Great little bed and breakfast for a romantic getaway or even a big family get-​together!

What a wonderful treasure! That Pretty Place Bed & Breakfast is tucked away back in the woods in beautiful Middleburry, IN. They have two different lodges, the main lodge has your basic simple rooms with one Honeymoon Suite. Each room has its own private bath and small TV. The Honeymoon Suite has its own bath plus an amazing two person jacuzzi tub.
The common room in the main lodge has a fridge stocked with soda and water. There is also a fireplace, however it was not working during our stay. We stayed in the Honeymoon Suite in the main lodge and truly enjoyed it.
The dining area was simple but nice. It was a bit chilly, we were there in the winter and the dining room is difficult to heat. The innkeepers were fantastic and prepared a great breakfast each morning. We had stuffed French toast one morning and biscuits and gravy the other. The innkeepers truly cared about their guests and did everything that they could to make your stay enjoyable, however they were not constantly talking your ear off.
The other lodge on the property is very new and very modern. It has suites instead of rooms. It is absolutely gorgeous, and had the whole lodge not been booked by an entire family for Christmas we would have stayed there.
One of the things that sets That Pretty Place apart from other bed & breakfasts is their grounds. They have a pond and lots of trails to walk. It is truly beautiful and so relaxing to just stroll through the woods.
I would highly recommend this Bed & Breakfast to anyone looking for a nice place to stay for an unbeatable price. In my opinion it is one of the BEST bed & breakfasts in northern Indiana.