Falbos Bros Pizza

super nice! love the cheese

Madison’s best pizza. I have never had it delivered, which seems to be a complaint reading some reviews here, but the quality of the PIZZA is top notch and they always take care of me and do a good job with my order. I pick up for my family of six at least a couple times a month.

They came in to my office about 15 min before my lunch break to drop off some free samples. I had one slice and ordered the BBQ Chicken Thin Crust Pizza for my lunch now.

Not impressed. I’m traveling and it’s snowing in Madison. I want delivery to the hotel. First off… the guy who answered was an ass. The fryer was off so no wings at 9pm. Oh well… I ordered a thin crust pizza and got a regular. I ordered a bottle water and got a can of Sprite. WTF? How hard is this shit? Listen to my words, write it down, make it and deliver it. Pretty simple. Try another place… don’t waste your time.

One of my favorite places to get some classic slices. You don’t go to this place for the service or dine it (I mean really is a place for pizza and a bunch of guys making it) It’s a simple place to get some delicious pizza or go grab a few slices. Take out is the best way to go or the slices. I’ve been going to this place since high school. Dash some oregano and enjoy. Also their Arizona ranch is a nice choice.

Great pizza, inconsistent service. Have ordered here several times for delivery to Waunakee and it has been a coin flip as to whether they’re willing to drive it out or not on a given night. Probably dependent on the intoxication level of the person attending the phone and/​or driver. Regardless, consistency would be nice in that regard. The pizza is great, but local competitors are better during regular pizza shop hours.

i’d do zero stars if possible — they fscked up my grubhub order, delivery guy called and blamed me for him not being able to find me, then i had to talk to 3 people to get someone to tell me they would cancel and refund my CC. a complete waste of time

Wow… just ordered from here and the guy on the phone seriously needs to learn how to take an order properly. Never asked my name or confirmed my address. I even had to prompt him to ask what I wanted! I understand that they can pull it up by phone number from caller id… but you always confirm! People move, numbers are reassigned, etc., etc., etc. Get it together man… its not a hard job. I worked in a much busier full service Italian restaurant with delivery when I was in high school. I managed to expedite and take orders and did a million times better then this guy. Get your act together. He also got part of my order wrong… so good thing I made him repeat it back. Hopefully its right when it gets here!

Falbos Pizza is a great at what they do. Making pizza. If I asked them to make an alternator work on a 2008 pontiac G6, they most likely couldn’t do that. They do pizza as advertised, and not to mention they’re just about 6 blocks away from me, which makes delivery quick and painless! I’ve also picked up the pizza and found the gentleman behind the counter to be nice and helpful. It seems working there is his second job, yet he acts like it’s just as important as his first job.
If I was a badger, or even a wolverine there is no way I could be writing this review. I assure you I am a real live human being. Just ask my girlfriend! She likes the pizza too. I’ll let you come down here and snap my suspenders!*
*DON’T TOUCH MY SUSPENDERS!

I have been there 2 times for Lunch and got a slice of Peperoni and a slice of Sausage it was good but could have used a little more pizza sauce but I will go back as it as fast in & out and good pizza.

I was a little concerned about ordering pizza from a place that is attached to a gas station, but I have to give credit where credit is due, the pizza is GREAT! They also make pretty good salads and wings. We struggled to find a go-​to pizza delivery place in Madison for 3 years, but now we always turn to Falbo Bros.

Ordered a pizza, came later than projected by about 15 minutes, pizza was cold and thin crust was mostly burned on bottom. One and only time ordering from Falbo.

Pretty good pizza. This place was one of the only businesses open during the blizzard last week. Our order for 3 pizzas, cheesy bread and salad was only missing the salad. No biggie. Any driver that can get through 19″ of snow and bring the group decent food is ok in my book. Thanks for keeping our stomachs full during the crazy weather.

I’ve been ordering from this Falbo Bros for several years. 95% of the time the food is great. Their thin crust pizza with the traditional sauce are great, even with only veggies. Most of their cold sandwiches aren’t much to look at, but are really good. Reliable delivery service. If you love pizza, you should try one of their pies.

My delivery order was placed over the phone, but I got their menu via
. I called at 3:12pm, and was immediately asked if I could hold. I agreed, and then they set the phone down on the counter, and I could hear everything! Three minutes later (not too long), he came back and I ordered our pizza, along with cheese sticks. I was given my total, and told it would be there in 45 minutes because I got stuffed pizza, and it takes a bit longer to cook.
One hour and 15 minutes later, my fiancé’ asks me again how long they said it would take, and that is generally my cue to call them back and see what’s up. I call back, am immediately again asked to hold, I said «well, it’s just about the order I just placed, I’m wondering where it is». Their response was «Let me get a manager». Five minutes later the manager gets on the phone, and I let him know that they’re 30 mins late. He apologizes, doesn’t offer to comp anything, and tells me he should be there any minute.
10 minutes later, a knock at the door. The driver asks me if I have a pen (that doesn’t happen very often — very disorganized), I sign, and let him go.
I open up the cheese sticks, and it’s a hoagie roll, split in half, with cheese and herbs on it. It wasn’t cut up at all, and SO not worth the $ 7 paid for it.
The pizza was a buffalo chicken pizza. I enjoy buffalo wings A LOT, and we generally enjoy buffalo chicken pizzas as well. The buffalo sauce on this was SO spicy that my fiancé’ couldn’t handle it. Honestly, if you go to a place like Buffalo Wild Wings, I’d rank the sauce near their spiciest. If you’re going to use a sauce that spicy on a pizza, there should be a warning, or do something to cool it off by adding ranch dressing to the pizza as well (Glass Nickel does this, and it’s wonderful).
In fact, we promptly ordered 1 pizza from Glass Nickel, and the pizza was here and hot in under 20 mins.

I ordered two pizza and a salad through All Menus from Falbo Brothers. This was one of my favorite places to order pizza from. The last time we ordered a taco pizza we got bbq sauce with it instead of taco sauce. This time after an hour had past I called to make sure they had recieved my order. The guy who answered the phone set the phone on the counter (no hold button) and left it laying there for five minutes. Upon his return I inquired about my order, he told me it was just coming out of the oven. I live maybe 5 minutes away from the restaurant. My pizza arrived 45 minute later cold and burned all over the top and crust of the pizzas. With All Menus I included the tip in the original purchase price. I paid $ 45 for two burnt pizzas and tipped 15% for HORRIBLE service Time from order placed (5:20pm), to pizza arrival (7:10pm) 1 hour and 40 minutes! EXCELLENT!

Friendly service good thon crust pep n sausage

Best damn pizza attached to a gas station I’ve ever had! Go Falbo Bros!

Delish! We tried the deep dish pepperoni. I am usually a thin crust fan, but I really enjoyed this deep dish because you could taste more than just the crust and it wasn’t dry. It could’ve used a tad more sauce, and it was a bit on the greasy side for me (hello — it’s cheese and meat, of course it’ll be greasy). All in all though, very good pizza! I plan to go back often.

My Saturday went like this: woke up early (like 6am early) and went for a long bike ride (like 55 miles long). Went for a quick run (like 45 minutes quick) and then spent a good portion of my day at Art Fair on the Square with a ton of people (like 30,000).
After a full day of battling people and not having ate much, my tummy was rumblin’ something fierce (like 7.6 on the Richter scale fierce). But, it was late… I’d gotten wrapped up watching an Entourage marathon on HBO…
I vaguely recalled seeing a Falbo Brothers earlier in the day, so I jumped in the car and headed west. Sure enough, I quickly spotted that familiar neon green and orange sign for Falbo’s.
I walked in to the store and almost squealed when I saw a whole display case worth of pizzas ready for the taking. $ 4 later, I walked out with two slices: one pepperoni and one sausage.
I scarfed down the fantastic slices; the crust slightly chewy, the cheese low on moisture. My only complaints: light on the sauce, and the ‘roni was really greasy.
Service was excellent, the pizza hit the spot, and the price was right. It’s not going to be the best pizza you’ll ever have, but when it’s late night and you’re starving (like eat your own shoe starving) Falbo’s is pretty tough to beat.