Scott’s Pastry Shoppe

I tried their kringle today. Good frosting but not much filling. Really, about 25% the filling of other kringle I’ve had. Also, overall more of a puffy consistency rather than the flat and dense type kringle. Perhaps they’re going for a different style of kringle but I think I’ll stick to the more conventional bakes.

This review could be as short as saying «good product, but high prices», but I’ll go on…
The donuts are good — their bismarks are the best in town. Driving by every day, I notice that once in a while they will hang a sign out by the road advertising apple cider donuts (or pumpkin spice, or blueberry even, though not often). They sounded good, so I stopped in for a dozen a while back. Those simple little cake donuts were over $ 1 each ($ 1.20/ea, I believe), which I thought was too high, but I was already committed, so I bit the bullet. Yeah, they were good, but not enough to buy them again for that price.
I won’t bother with their other baked goods — the large danishes, coffee cakes and pies are just too expensive for my taste. For less than half the money, I can snag a $ 5 apple fritter from Greenbush that is amazing. I’m sure Scott’s stuff is good, but personally, I have a limit to what I’ll spend on that sort of thing.
For the freakish treat, the $ 1.90/ea for a maple & bacon long john is worth the novelty. At least once. They’re surprisingly good.

Happy Fat Tuesday! My coworker brought in a delicious king cake with cream cheese frosting and chocolate chips from Scott’s. I didn’t find the baby so I don’t have to buy the next one, which is good because I heard that they are on the expensive side.

I recently had a birthday and as part of the celebration my partner ordered a cake from Scot’s. The cake was beautifully decorated and tasted delicious. I would highly recommend them for any of your dessert needs! I should also mention we split a cookie and it was fantastic as well!

We just picked up a custom cake for a colleague’s going away. Holy crap, it’s crap looking. At least the maker is interested in helping to satisfy, but I can’t see how they were proud to sell us this cake… seriously.

A little pricey for what you get. I got 3 dozen donuts, and it was $ 40! Yikes! Maybe they deserve 2.5 stars.
I do like the NAME of the place, of course.

I haven’t tried anything here besides the donuts, but the donuts are delicious. I just wish they were open on Sunday mornings.

Very happy with Scott’s Pastry Shoppe. I had a speciality — gag cake made up and they were terrific. I have only had doughnuts and such and thought they were terrific.

Delicious donuts. Especially the ones with caramel frosting. I would stay away from the «elephant ears». They look better than they taste.

Baked items are disappointing, especially for the price. Scott’s needs to get with the program and go natural. I don’t like high fructose corn syrup in my apple fritter. Besides that the ladies that work here are always mean to me for no reason :(Their cookies are hard, I go to the real bakery: La Brioche

I drove past Scott’s while looking for a place to purchase propane… Go figure. Decided to stop in and sample their sweet treats.
Cookies: definitely crunchy. I’m not a fan of a crunchy cookie — I prefer a chewier cookie, so Scott’s cookies weren’t quite what I had hoped they would be.
I decided to try a doughnut and selected a cream-​filled chocolate iced doughnut. It was decent, but as someone else mentioned, about what you’d expect to find at a decent grocery store.
All things considered, I would probably go back for another doughnut, but I’d pass on the cookies. If you like a crunchy cookie, give ‘em a try.
Oh; inside? Nice. Open, bright, clean, and the staff was very friendly.

One of the best bakeries in town! Try the German Cholate cake for a real treat.

If someone cared about me, they would bring me a cherry turnover for lunch.

I wanted to like this bakery, but I really couldn’t because of the low quality of their bakery products (can’t speak for the doughnuts because I haven’t had them). They do have a wide selection of pastries, but you can get better cookies, muffins, cupcakes, pastries, etc at the grocery store.

The best donuts in Madison, bar none. The location downtown is alright, but I live close to this one. And it’s hard to resist temptation and not swing by for a donut everyday on the way to work. They’re still only $ 1.25.