Jim’s Pizza Box

Stopped in by chance while driving through town. Very glad I did. Very friendly nice people work here. Had the smity sub and loved it.

We were staying overnight after a day of cedar point. We ordered from here fifteen minutes before they closed, and the staff was very understanding and friendly. The pizza was amazing and so was the chocolate cream pie! We will definitely be back on our next visit to Cedar Point!

Best place to have pizza and visit with friends and family. A little pricey compared to other pizza places, but worth it. Wednesday Spaghetti Night is an all-​time must do!

The pizza was delicious. We ordered a large regular crust sausage pizza and a small (personal size) anchovy pie, both were very tasty. Everyone loved the crust. My youngest daughter, who doesn’t like pizza ordered a cheese quesadilla, she loved it. Great find in a very cute village square, would definitely recommend.

We’re staying overnight and headed to Cedar Point in the morning. We were looking for a quick meal and found this place online. I called and ordered a pizza and cheese fries and the was a breeze. The pizza arrived quickly and fresh and the best part is, it was DELICIOUS!!! My kids loved it and so did my husband and I! Probably one of the best plain cheese pizzas we’ve ever had! We’ll definitely order from here again!

Found this place on Unilocal and stopped here for dinner on the drive from Chicago to Pittsburgh. Thankful for the the Unilocal app, otherwise we would have never stopped in Milan (birthplace of Thomas Edison!)! The restaurant is located in a nice town square area, and the food and employees were all great. Game room was a nice distraction for the kids. Bathroom was clean. Glad we came — definitely better than settling for some chain fast food somewhere off the highway!

Awesome pizza, Very nice people on the phone. I ordered from Super 8 motel and they were Very accommodating. Got it here fast and Hot.
Good job guys. Thanks again.

Very tasty place in the middle of a historic town. The pizza had lots of cheese and lite sauce. The ores of garlic bread was a bit small but it came with a good amount of sauce on the side (save the sauce to add more to the pizza if desired). Well we ate was saw very caring employees who were really friendly. One customer picking up a to go order didn’t feel well and the employe gave them the pizza, later after the customer left the employe paid for the pizza out of her own pocket. My wife say the bathroom gets 5 stars for cleanliness.

I love this place! Every time I visit family in Norwalk, we always get pizza from Jim’s. In my opinion it’s the best pizza in the area. Their calzones and cheesy garlic bread are also to die for!

Based on the reviews I thought it would be better than it was. Sorry to say, from the moment the phone was picked up until after I ate it was not worth it.
I called and the person answering the phone did not have a clue of the menu. I would ask a question and she would ask it to the person next to her. I wish she would have given him the phone. My sister and I laughed so hard after I hung up. Then she called back because she forgot to ask what type of salad dressing I wanted. She even had to ask what dressing they had, remember she called me.
My order was wrong when I received it, the pizza was OK (I’ve had better) the wings were boneless and dry (I ordered tradition) the salad… well I should have went to McDonald’s because it would have been better.
I will not be back — sorry pizza is not rocket science. From what I understand it is secondary for them.

Love Jim’s. best calzone on the planet. But they had a fire last night! Please rebuild!
Edit: grand reopening Monday July 21^st at 5!

Excellent pizza. EXCELLENT! Great, homemade ranch dressing. Fast, friendly service and a great price. Can’t recommend this highly enough!
I called from the Hampton Inn right off of the turnpike. A friendly and professional driver arrived not too long thereafter and my deep dish with pepperoni was fantastic!

We had personal pan pizza and I thought it was made by a 5 star chef. Delivered to our hotel room at the Hampton Inn promptly without any issues.
Thanks again

My heart regarding pizza will always be with Jim’s. I grew up on it and it was always «the spot» to hang out after Edison football and basketball games. That’s just what you did. You went to the game, and then everyone came to Jim’s, ate, hung out, and then decided what mischief we were to get in. Just kidding mom! :)
The edges of the pizza are crispy and the cheese is bountiful. My favorites are their pepperoni and mushroom pie, as well as their BLT pie. They never skimp on ingredients and the crust is the perfect thickness… not thin crust, but thinner than a commercial companies «hand tossed». (lower carb people, who can complain there?)
Their garlic bread is fabulous as well and I could it all day if calories were blatantly disregarded.
Every time I’m home, I’m sure to order their famous taco salad as well. I don’t know what they do to it, but the meat is seasoned perfectly, the ranch tastes scratch made, and the taco sauce is tangy and melds well with the ranch.
I wish they would open up a satellite location in Tampa. They’d give my favorite pie joints down here a run for their money, no question about it!
Eat local, and if you’re an out of towner (mainly tourists coming in for Cedar Point), definitely make this a pit stop. It’s only a mile or two from the Ohio Turnpike in my small hometown of Milan, Ohio.

What a gem tucked away in a small quaint town! Had the meat lovers and loved it! Thanks for the recommendation from Chad at the Red Roof Inn.

I grew up on this pizza. I miss it. I live in California now but always stop in and get some when I return.
Thanks for never calling Jim Ward on us when we snuck out of school to have lunch here.

Calzones here are fantastic. The Smitty Sub is one of the best sandwiches I have ever had. They also have great unique pizzas like the taco pizza with Doritos on it.