Jimmy’s Ice Cream

An awesome place for ice cream. Great local find.

I’m a local and I love Jimmy’s. Even if the line is long, just wait because it goes by really fast and the ice cream is worth it. They make some of the best sundaes!
Employees are always sweet and willing to help you with your order. I highly recommend stopping at this ice cream joint if you’re around.

best. place. ever. !! growing up this was the place to be and I’m super happy it’s still up and running. I love that they have updated things but still have the classics

Have been coming here since I was a kid, and now bring my own. The place has not changed except for a fresh coat of paint. Service is great, even when the line is 20 deep.
Prefect drive in fair, love their burgers, fries and shakes. Ice cream is huge and tasty.
Mini golf could use some attention, but the kids always have fun.
Hope this place stays open for a long time to come.

My kids love this place. Local ice cream stand with mini golf and a creek to play in.
The soft serve ice cream is really good. Very large portions.
The food is better than what I would have expected from an ice cream stand. We have had burgers, hot dogs, chicken cheese steaks, fries, and onion rings here. All were good.
The mini golf course is run down but gets the job done.
Staff is always friendly. There are plenty of picnic tables and benches on the property to always find a seat.

Excellent ice cream, and a throwback to ice cream stands of old. Picnic tables next to a babbling brook. Try the pumpkin ice cream!

Jimmy’s is an old school ice cream stand. The ice cream is great and the hot food is good. Is it the best I’ve had of either… No (the soft serve ice cream is pretty close tho!). But you go for the experience which just make’s everything taste better.
As you sit on the benches next to the stream, enjoying their homemade flavor of the week, watching classic cars pull into the parking lot… It transports you back to being a kid and you just forget about all your stresses and just enjoy the ice cream.

I must be missing something… Having read the other reviews, one would think this is the greatest place in NJ to get ice cream. I doubt it. The ice cream is good, service is so so, hot food is awful. Place seems to attract a strange crowd that is less than friendly. I will go back since the ice cream is good. Maybe I hit it on a bad day crowd wise.

I have been coming here since I was a little girl and am glad to see that things haven’t changed much.
I LOVE their ice cream. Some of the best in NJ, in my opinion. Their prices are fair and they give you more than a decent-​sized serving.
Other things worth mentioning:
–Cash only!
–They also serve hot food.
–Jimmy’s has three windows. You place your order in the center window, then pick up from either the left window (if it’s hot food) or the right window (if it’s ice cream).
–There is a mini-​golf place next door.
–Plenty of parking.
–There are benches set up on one side of Jimmy’s (near the creek) where you can sit down and enjoy your food.
–This place gets packed most summer nights, although the line moves quickly.

Great memories restored… love it!

I go camping right by this place and it’s awesome. Everything is priced fair and the ice cream is stacked high. I love the classic feel of this place and wish my town had something like it. The bench’s on the side of the place face a little creek you can relax by while enjoying your food. Last time I came by tons of parents with their kids were coming by for food after their little league games. Next time I go camping I’ll be sure to stop by Jimmy’s again and maybe play a round at Holey Moley the mini golf place attached.

grew up going to this place as a kid, had my first job at the holey moley golf course! hah. now at 25, at least once a summer I have to make it over there. killer ice cream, delicious milkshakes and a great hang out.
The new owners are incredible and dealt with a lot of crap from haters and the town. kudos to you guys for standing strong and making it one of the best places in the holland/​milford area.

Vanilla/​chocolate twist, cup, chocolate sprinkles. We buy them by the dozen, have at least 6 in the freezer so we don’t go into total withdrawal until the reopen in April.

This place is excellent!
They serve hot food, tons of original ice cream flavors and even make ice creak cakes!
Cash-​Only, and they are NOT nut-​free.

Great ice cream.(with original and specialty flavors).even better food… with ALL that AND miniature golf… ya can’t beat this place!