Olde World Bakery & Cafe

Great food. Great value. Sweet service. Highly suggest!

Great place to eat with hours more accommodating than most eateries in the area. Fantastic breads, salads, and good service.

My husband and I had dinner here tonight. We both order the soup and ½ salad. The soup was hot, I had ham & bean, he had cheeseburger, and the salads were fresh and wonderful. First time we’ve eaten here, and would we come back again. The only thing we could say we wish they had was a more extensive menu for dinner, but that isn’t something to really complain about!

Great Service, made from scratch soup, breads & pastries! Better coffee drinks than Starb***s. It’s hard to find a yummy sandwich & burger place in Amish country, but I did.

Love this place! Me and my husband come here at least once a week! The best food and service in town!

Stopped in for lunch after a day trip to Sugarcreek and saw that this place had great reviews online. We were definitely not disappointed with the meal we received!
The prices were decent and the food was fantastic. I got the grilled chicken sandwich and it was the best sandwich I have ever had! Perfectly seasoned and just and all around awesome sandwich. I also ordered a side of the onion rings and they were fantastic. Not typical onion rings that you would expect. We went to leave and pay the bill when we noticed they had some baked goods. So we stopped and bought a loaf of cinnamon bread. The bread was very good. Tasted just like homemade (although it was a little lacking with the cinnamon).
Would definitely recommend this to a friend and will be returning when we make another trip to the area.

Excellent! All the food is made to order and couldn’t be any better. Italian soda is the best I ever had.

Excellent service, great all homemade menu items and coffee bar.
My husband and I decided to stop here for a late lunch. We started with a very generous order (10) of fried cheese sticks. They were served with a side of marinara like no other we’ve had! It was fabulous! For our meals my husband chose the Sticky BBQ burger. It was served on a homemade pretzel bun with pepper jack cheese, BBQ sauce and a homemade onion ring. He loved it! For my meal I had the soup and salad combo. The baked potato cheese soup was very good, and reminded me of a potato casserole! My salad had a very generous portion of lettuce, mandarin oranges, goat cheese and cranberrys for a half salad!
We would highly recommend eating here! From the initial greet at the door and until we left, everything was way above par!

What nice little place! Seems like a open space house turned into an eatery. The waitress was pleasant and prompt. She was quick to get our drinks and put our order in fast too. A few simple burgers and sides with the quaint ambiance led to a nice meal. Reasonable prices and delicious food!

Excellent meal! Had a burger and husband had a grilled chicken sandwich. Everything is local and fresh, grass fed local beef– best burger I’ve ever had!

Awesome place. Perfect for locals and tourists. The people are great here. The bakery is amazing. The cheesecake was perfect, light, and not too overwhelming. Servers are friendly and happy. You can tell they are passionate about making good food. Authentic Holmes county place. Get the farm burger!

20 minutes for a cold bowl of soup and a chicken salad sandwich? Not worth it. The soup did have good flavor. Just needed to be heated but the chicken salad was not that great. Too many other great Amish restaurants that you would be better off trying.

Good atmosphere, great food.
Service is a bit slower normally but food is quality.
Great pastries and cookies.
Lattes are good as we’ll.

Love this place. Complete departure from other local fair with a farm to table approach.