Gordy’s Citgo Service

I brought the Jeep here for an oil change after seeing so many fantastic reviews on Unilocal.Unfortunately, I think I may have hit them on an off day?
I made an appointment the day before for 2:00pm, and specified I would be waiting (I never understand the drop off, how am I supposed to go anywhere else while you have my car?!). When I showed up they said it’d be about an hour, okay I can deal with that, but again I specified I would be waiting. The friendly kid (the only reason for a second star is that he was nice…) told me that there was a coffee shop on the corner that may be more comfortable. I appreciated the gesture and gave him keys and a phone number to let me know when it was done.
I moved my way down to Stone Creek Coffee (5 stars!) and got comfortable with a hot tea and my kindle. After one hour (and half a book) my phone rang — yay! But alas, he just wanted to double check if I wanted the synthetic oil. This told me that they hadn’t started… yes, I want synthetic oil. Then I waited… and waited… and waited…
I finished an entire book in the 2.5 hours I sat at the coffee shop and watched others come and go without a phone call. Finally, quite peeved I went over there myself to raise some hell. I see the Jeep just casually parked out front. What? I went in and asked how long it’d be done and they said about 20 minutes (still ridiculous that with an appointment it would take over 2 hours to change the damn oil) but no one had called me. Then he told me that it was $ 80!!! I couldn’t believe it. I understand that synthetic oil is more expensive, but I have never paid over $ 60 (and usually its $ 50) for a synthetic oil change. My bad for not asking ahead of time, however I have no hope they would have been any more helpful with that request. I paid an left, quite pissed off having wasted most of my afternoon here. I would not recommend to anyone else, nor will I ever be returning.

I came here to get gasoline with only 10% ethanol or less for my snowblower. It’s hard to find a station that sells that type of gasoline. However this place does. It’s a bit old-​fashioned-​they don’t have pay at the pump, so you have to go in and pay before you buy the gasoline.

These guys were really helpful. Went in for an oil change, which was pretty speedy. I also had questions around why my car was so loud on the highway. They correctly identified that the tires were scalloped and replacing them first was a cheaper option than just jumping to new shocks/​struts.
If i’m in the neighborhood again and have car trouble, definitely coming back here.

Unbelievably nice and honest workers who aren’t looking for the money. You can really tell they take pride in what they do and I would recommend and do recommend them to anyone looking for a good repair job.

I had a flat tire and needed it fixed immediately as i had some errands to run. Although Gordy’s was all booked for the day, they had my tire fixed after hours acknowledging my situation and all these for just 15 bucks! Great Guys, Highly Recommended!

I do business with these guys. Some exceptional guys that like what they do and take pride in their work. They poses the traits of a technician that’s few and far between.

Realized I had a flat tire. As expected, it happened after normal business hours. However, Gordy’s was open and they saw us immediately. They fixed the tire in about 15 minutes and the price was extremely reasonable. The technicians were friendly, knowledgeable, and didn’t give us the «run around» that you may expect from a shop.
I’m very satisfied with their work and would recommend them to anyone in a situation similar to mine.

I just moved to Milwaukee and on my drive from California to Wisconsin, my air conditioning broke :(I had no idea where to get this fixed since I was brand new to the area, but luckily my roommate recommended Gordy’s. I had definitely done my research, found out what was wrong from another mechanic, and checked out quotes from other places, so I wanted to get a quote from Gordy’s before deciding to get my repairs done there.
I called and made an appointment just to get a quote. The people at Gordy’s were incredibly friendly and explained and showed me exactly what was going on with my car, as well as the break down for the price estimate (for parts/​labor). I also got some good advice about driving in Milwaukee in the winter for free :) Regardless, this place was quoting over 150 dollars less than everywhere else. I also was able to make an appointment a couple days later no problem.
I can happily say that my car is all fixed now. It was an expensive repair, but I would have had to pay significantly more at any other place. Also, everyone here, especially Brett, is REALLY nice and they seem incredibly genuine, not like most mechanics I’ve run into in the past.
Overall, I highly recommend! I would definitely come back if I needed something else fixed. Don’t be scared by the fact that it’s connected to a gas station, it’s a great place to get your car fixed.

I am new to the neighborhood as of last April, and have been to Gordy’s twice this summer for car trouble. Once was urgent (car wouldn’t start and I had to have it towed there) and once I made the appointment in advance. Both times they were able to diagnose and repair the problem quickly and effectively! Fair prices, very professional and polite staff, a pleasure to do business with. Very happy to have them nearby!

These guys are great! I was recommended Gordy’s by my wife. She had much of her auto repairs done at the shop and was very satisfied with their work.
The staff is knowledgable, friendly and honest. They will go above and beyond to ensure that they do quality repair work while doing it for a reasonable price. Any auto emergency (and I have had a lot lately) I have, the guys are able to get me in quickly and my car is repaired just as quick.
These days it can be a daunting experience to choose a repair shop and actually trust the guys doing your work. Not at Gordy’s. These guys are awesome!

Gordy’s is great! The staff is always friendly and honest. We just got a tire repaired and reinstalled there today. 24.95 for everything. The service is fast and reliable. Wednesdays are called Wacky Wednesdays for a good reason — mid-​grade gas is priced at regular unleaded prices. How awesome is that?!