Pie Five Pizza Co

As a gluten free family we have a hard time eating out. We love Pie Five though. Great price, decent pizza, and great service. I would love it if they had GF dessert options but for just pizza they are a great choice.

PieFive is my absolute favorite pizza place! It’s setup Subway style, so you get to pick your crust, sauce, and all of your toppings and there are plenty of toppings to choose from. I usually get the thin crust and then load it up to the max. Don’t worry if you think they are skimping out on toppings, just tell them to add more and they will gladly oblige. The price is very reasonable for what you get and the fact that you can put on as many toppings as you want, makes it 10x better than any other pizza place that will charge you extra for additional toppings. The pizza comes out super fast; usually after you have finished paying and getting your drinks. Also, there’s military discount and if you sign up for their «Circle of Crust» to accrue points, you will be pleasantly surprised by how quickly you can get rewards. I’m not there that often, but it seems after every 4 – 5 visits, I get a free pizza.

It’s been said these pizzas are doughy… But intelligence would point to the fact you should probably go with something along the line of a thin crust and not pan… This is not a difficult decision to make, if you get greasy items when cooked… It’s going to be GREASY!!!
Pros: quick pizza… From the time you order to the time you get to the register your pizza is done!!!
Staff: Friendly and helpful, very cheery and will talk while they’re making your food
Deco: Modern
Space: There’s plenty
Menu: well put together with all the ingredients you could want on a pizza…
Cons: it’s ONLY a pizza, salad and desert place… Music is a bit loud in the bathroom
Personal suggestion: LOVED the Athenian, add magic dust… Not sure what it is but it’s good!!! I think it’s Parmesan and Oregano mixed together!
Overall a great place if you’re looking for a quick bite!

Did not plan to come here for dinner, but did not regret coming. This place served individual pizzas. Went with family so we had the chance of ordering many different pies. We liked them all. The pizza were made quickly and the taste was great.

I thoroughly enjoyed Pie Five. They have it set up so that you order the type of pizza you want (their signatures or create your own) and then they add all the toppings in front of you. Further down the line as the pizza is cooking you can choose to add a salad or a dessert. Then the pizza comes out, they add a few extra stuff (like magic dust, if you so choose) and then it’s ready. You pay and take your pizza to a table to enjoy.
I’ve noticed that there are complaints about the price but I thought it was relatively cheap. It’s $ 6.99 for a 6 slice pizza and you can literally put anything and everything on it. My husband and I share so it ends up being $ 3.50 a person.
Their staff was friendly and so polite. I really enjoyed eating here.
PS– their Apple Pie is seriously AMAZING!!! Try it.

Yummy! Loved I could order a pizza I like w/​o complaints from the boys. Also, Loved the thin crust, spicy marinara was good too!

I had the small pepperoni and sausage pizza. It was a little greasy but overall I was pleased! The crust was thin and the sauce was tasty. I also ordered the dessert pie which was a big brownie pizza dish and it was amazing!

Yummy and a great concept. I was introduced to it in Dallas and was excited to find out we had one here. Hubby had a great time and enjoyed his pizza, as did I and our son. I only gave 4 stars because there’s another company that I like better for fresher tasting ingredients. But this place is definitely great, with good service!

We walked into what walk was essentially a more prestigious version of subway for pizzas! It was very nice and clean, the menu was up on the wall as well as Menus at the door. Each specialty pizza has its suggested crust type.
Reviews I have read on Unilocal people have thought the price was a little high, I however strongly disagree. I ordered the Pesto Chicken Alfredo with the suggested artisan thin crust as a Pizza Bundle with a side Italian salad, this also came with a drink, my entire bundle was just $ 9.99.
The salad was simple but delightful, an itallian dressing with a balsamic vinegar reduction drizzled over the top, fresh with what I will call their version of a croûton. A very thin pizza crust with toasted parmigian cheese, it was the small and the perfect size.
Okay so I’ll be super honest, I am not the biggest fan of chicken on a pizza, I am not sure exactly why, but I am not, it’s just not my thing, maybe too may bites with chicken fat and then I am done. However this was not the case. The pizza is put together right in front of you with all fresh ingredients. All Pizzas are personal sized and as usual I ordered it just the way that it came, you know since it was my first go round at Pie Five Pizza! The ingredients complimented each other in a symphony of perfection, after thoroughly enjoying the first piece, I had an Ah-​Ha moment… you know what would make it better? That balsamic dressing, drizzle, reduction stuff that was on my salad, THAT made it perfect. The chicken was cut very thin and was very lean, the grape tomatoes were fresh and the carmalized onions added to the perfect symphony, The Alfredo sauce and the pesto brought it all together.
The boyfriend got the High Five — Tuscan Marinara — Cheddar Pepperoni– Italian Sausage — Bacon — Canadian Bacon and Beef it’s suggested crust is Classic Pan and The boyfriend of course opted for the thin crust and the spicy Marinara and since he is used to me, he made a trade offer. One piece of his for one piece of mine. He had mentioned it was a little spicy! OH MY I couldn’t even finish the piece of pizza I gave it back Immediatly! Sinuses officially open, mouth on fire! Two full glasses of ginger ale later we are finally good to go. He said he loved the pizza, however he did mention that he would be getting the regular sauce next time. Lol.
We loved Pie Five Pizza Co.

Great pizza really fast. You can customize your order the way you want. You can pick wheat or white crust. Thick or think. I haven’t tried the salads but they look good too. Oh and they have the fancy new drink machines that let you pick any combination or sodas.

Pretty delish. this is my second time coming here. So far I have had the chicken bbq pizza and the shrimp scampi pizza, as well as chocolate chip pizza slice for dessert.
The employees are young, seem nice. The manager is really sweet too. My daughter loves to come here so she can watch how her pizza is being made. I love that they have gluten free crust! I thought the price was good for what you get, I don’t see why others would complain about that.
The only complaint would be BOTH times we came and got the chocolate chip cookie pizza, they were really cold. First time I asked them to warm it up they looked at me crazy but did it. Our second visit the young girl told me warming up the cookie was against code. The manager warmed it up, but he mentioned to me they were cold because they come from the freezer.
All in all we will return and be loyal customers and we signed up for the points loyalty program too!

Pie Five is cool, and not too expensive.
On a Friday night after soccer practice, too late to drive home and cook up a big meal, we decided on fast casual pizza. The basics are simple– they make your pie to order after you tell them what you want. Like Chipotle, Pie Five lets you see and pick your custom order, then pops it into a quick little oven. Pie comes out the other side while you’re ordering salad, dessert, and paying, and you take your food to whatever table you like.
The pizza isn’t spectacular, but it’s great for the price (standard no matter how many toppings you choose). Salads are huge. I ate half for dinner and the remaining half for lunch the next day.
Pie Five is a good option for fast, custom pizzas in Moore. We’ll be back!

Not great. This place was hyped up by my coworkers and they said the only complaint was the price so we figured we try it out.
The place has a modern feel, generally pretty clean and the menu items had the normal good ingredients. The staff were busy but friendly, no complaints there. They were pretty generous with their toppings too.
Holy hell these pizzas were greasy, and the dough was really mushy, the pizza was sort of warm when it came out of oven, not blazing hot like it should be.
Maybe pie five should switch to those super hot ovens that most other pizzas places have switched to, the little heater track doesn’t seem to be doing the job well. And calm down on the oil for the dough, a dry crust adds texture and solidity to the already wet ingredients/​sauce. These things just flop over when you pick them up. If that’s what you want then this place will be great but I like my pizzas to still look like pizzas when I pick them up.

No need for overpriced (but well loved) Hideaway anymore. Now we can each make our own Hideaway favorite for way less $$. Ingredients are great, and you can customize even to the degree that you specify how much of each topping you want as they are making it in front of you. Really nice staff. We’ve been about 5 times now and never had a bad experience. Love the big drink machine so I can have my diet Barq’s Root Beer with my pizza :)

For a good price, you can have as many toppings as your heart desires. And it comes out pretty quick. Please open some in the Tulsa area. Tulsa would love Pie Five.

I’m not sure why people are complaining about the price. It isn’t as though the price is hidden. Before you even order you get to see what others pizza’s look like. There’s no surprises here. Anyway, we bought two pizzas. The One with Alfredo sauce was definitely the favorite! We will be back here for sure. The staff were all polite and engaging. Thanks guys!

@piefivepizza We are trying out the new pie five here in Moore The pizza was good But way over price

Fantastic business idea and great tasting food. Individual pizzas, made to order, are prepared and cooked right in front of your face. On my first visit, I tried a traditional pan pizza with pepperoni and sausage. Tonight I ventured out of my comfort zone and tried the BBQ chicken pizza. Both were fantastic! This is one of the few places that my entire family all finds something they like! Highly recommend!

Two words: barbecue sauce. Options ranged from suggested favorites to build your own. I built my own classic pan crust pizza. Set up like a Subway line… lots of great meats to choose from and a great variety of extra vegetable toppings. My pizza was ready in less than five minutes as advertised. Tasted great, staff was friendly, and I left impressed.

Good pizza, great service!
Brand-​new to the 19^th street restaurant row, Pie Five just opened to a packed house. The establishment handled the crowd with ease, and I was surprised that you actually receive your pizza before you pay standing in line! (They’re that fast — making this perfect for lunch hours!) The staff was all smiles and the menu was extensive. I had my usual pepperoni pizza, and found it a little bland. But there’s plenty of other flavors to try! They offer four types of crust (thin, whole wheat thin, pan and gluten-​free) and seven sauces, but only one size pizza (excluding a 6″ kid’s pizza). Every pizza is eligible for a coating of «magic dust» which adds a nice kick and texture. Salads and sweets are also on the menu and they have a Coca-​Cola Freestyle giving you nearly unlimited soda choices. If you like your pizza with lots of options, a trip to Moore is much closer than a trip to Italy.