Tabor Pizzeria

My personal favorite in the area. Lady behind the counter was friendly and nice enough to take a slice out of my order and let me eat it while watching the NFL playoffs even when I had originally placed an order for take out. Very clean dining area and seems to have more than enough sitting area.

So I ordered takeout tonight… penne vodka (9.95) and a house salad. iceberg lettuce, two chunks of tomato and a sprinkle of mozzarella.(4.95). I thought when I ordered that those prices are pretty good. Well… I quickly realized when picking up my order that I know why! The portion size of the penne vodka was extremely small. Some pasta and sauce. Tasted good, nothing special though. Had I not had the small salad with it, I might have still been hungry. The side salad was packaged in the same sized container as the pasta. Rip off. I will not return. Advice: You may have to order two entrees here if you’re hungry.

Just got 3 slices and there was a piece of glass one of the veggie slices. Stopped there last week and the food was good. Not returning after tonight’s surprise.

It was a great experience, with fast service very patient with our huge group of 24 and the pizza was delicious and reasonably priced!

No complaints here. We came here the other night with a very large group and the staff was very friendly and helpful. The bill was so low for such a big group that we actually thought maybe there was a mistake. Pizzas were very tasty and fresh, not to mention came out in like 10 – 15 min. Would go back anytime.

I can not emphasize enough how horrible this Sicilian pizza was. Ordered it on a Friday night at 6:00. Arrived at 7:25. Had it been remotely close to worth the wait, I’d have let this slide. But no lie, this was one of the WORST pizzas I’ve ever had, and I’ve experienced some of the very worst in PA, WV, etc. The cheese-​to-​dough ratio was a disgrace. Way, way too doughy. The only thing that will get this skanky taste out of my mouth is posting this review, in hopes of warning others. This is what I get for deviating from Annabella’s. If only my lazy ass felt like driving to pick it up (as they don’t deliver). I’d have been better off putting all my leftover old food in the fridge in a blender, spread on a week old piece of uncut wonder bread, and dumped ketchup on it. Terrible job tabor road. Shame!

Very good pizza. We live in Denville and have chosen Tabor as our pizza place of choice.
However, they have very frequently forgotten our order when we arrive to pick up our call ahead pizza. I typically do not write negative reviews on Unilocal.However, this has happened to us 50% of the time over the past 4 – 5 months.
Excellent pizza, best in the area. Lack of attention to detail somehow leads to inaccurate orders or (most frequently) missed orders entirely.
Please fix this Tabor Pizza.

This is the second time I ordered from here, first time I had pizza. Not a bad Sicilian pie except there was very little sauce and my fiancée hated it but it definitely was bad.
I just ordered a Philly cheese steak sandwich, it was below average, but the worst part is that it had barely any meat on it. I wish I took a picture of it, too much bread and very few onions, peppers, and MEAT!
My wife, no longer fiancée, got chicken parmesan, and the sauce isn’t very good and I agree.
Add in that it was $ 26 for the two things plus a $ 5 tip, I feel like I’m back in Hoboken, except the food isn’t very good…
I hope this review helps!

We heard good things about Tabor Pizza so we gave it a try. The shop is bright and clean with serve yourself tables and a side room with waitress service. Nice…
They offer a wide variety of pizza from your basic Neopolitan pie to Buffalo chicken. I like their regular slice and the pepperoni. My wife likes the regular too and enjoys the spicy Buffalo chicken pie.
They have fountain sodas and bottled so you can get your pies to go along with a beverage.
Service is quick, efficient and friendly. After a couple of visits, you are greeted as a welcome regular. I like that.
We have only had the pizza and recommend it. The side dining room is usually busy and they offer a full Italian restaurant menu but you will have to look to other Unilocalers to get a fix on their offerings.
Clean place. Consistent quality. Friendly staff, easy parking.
Recommended.

We are regular customers with Tabor. They probably recognize the voices of my screaming children in the background before I am able to get a word in.
Anyway, great food options at Tabor. Our standard is pizza but we’ve had other great dishes too, especially their wraps which they are happy to customize for you.
I recently decided to try a soup, which prompted my review. The minestrone: out of this world! Ok, you’re looking for a filling, delightful soup that is the opposite of Olive Garden — get this soup! You can tell it is fresh. Good amounts of veggies (potato squash celery carrott zucchini onion kidney beans), NO pasta, and a wonderful broth that doesnt make u feel like you ate a salt lick. I now order it regularly, and it is great every time.
Why four stars? No one’s perfect. While their pizza is always delicious, it is slightly inconsistent with style — lots of sauce vs lots of cheese vs is that a hint of rosemary? Two plain pies in the same order and each clearly different from the other in taste. They both were great, but they’ll keep you guessing. We had only a couple very late (ie long wait) deliveries; however, they called to let us know they were very busy. Generally they tell us 45 minutes but show up in a half hour, and they’ve always been friendly.

Reasonable prices and great food! The personal hawaiian pizza was perfect– the dough had a perfect crisp and was not at all soggy. It was the perfect size for me. My husband really enjoyed his chicken parm sandwich (he said the sauce was really good). The dining area is actually really nice. I think it’s byob and a lot of people were there on dates. Pretty popular place on a Saturday night! Service was quick and friendly.

My first time here tonight and in Jersey and it was wonderful. My team has told me great things and I’m glad it was just as good as they hyped it to be!
The place is big and the staff is really helpful with the description of the diffrent pizzas and options.
The reason why I’m giving it a 5 star and not a 4 is because our cashier was very helpful. His name was Mike and he helped my friends and I with the change split and was very kind and patient. Great manners and nice smile! Keep it up buddy I’ll see you during our next event in Jersey!

I’m in town visiting family so I wanted to try different places while I am here.
The first day we came here for lunch and got pizza by the slice and garlic knots. I ordered the chicken pizza and pepperoni — it was awesome. The garlic knots were on point.
I really enjoyed the pizza and the service was good.
The next day i got a meat lovers pizza from them and it was stellar.
I could eat their pizza everyday!