The Square

I’m a local and come here often. Tried the chicken schnitzel tonight and loved it! And the suggested wine paring was perfect! Love the Square and highly recommend.

We are in town for the AG Expo and wanted to try some local fare. After seeing the 10 – 5 star reviews, we figured it would be worth a try!
Let me tell you, as someone who has eaten at some of the finest steak houses in Philly and New York City, I can honestly say that the NY strip was THE BEST steak I have ever eaten.
The staff was friendly and welcoming and made us feel at home!
This restaurant would give any place in Philly or New York a definite run for their money! Worth the trip!

I’ve been coming to this town for 20 years now to visit with family. The one major drawback about spending time in Moultrie is the lack of any decent places for dining out. So I’m very happy to get out the word about The Square, located right across the street from Moultrie’s historic Courthouse.
Important to me is that they have a full bar, with a nice selection of fresh Georgia micro-​brews. Not only that, they also offer high quality Georgia sourced cheeses and seem to have other locally sourced products. All of which adds up to a great dining experience, in which you get a proper taste of the local flavor. At my table we had pork, chicken, shrimp and a really nice lean version of meatloaf that used fresh vegetables instead of bread as an additive. Everything tasted fresh and delicious.
The service is friendly and warm, and this may sound weird, but the air-​conditioning level is just right. There are too many places down here where you feel like you are walking into an icebox.
Which brings me to the décor. The building appears to be a 19^th century storefront type structure, that has been totally renovated with exposed brick walls and would not look out of place back home in Philly or New York.
One other thing I should add is that for the quality of the food, I would also consider the prices very reasonable.
Moultrie has a true gem here. I highly recommend The Square.

It’s rare you get the opportunity to find this kind of food and atmosphere in a small town, and I am honored we have it in my old home town! The food is ALWAYS amazing! But the atmosphere is even better. Whether it’s dinner, a wine night or taste testing… we have never left without a full belly and a night full of laughs and great memories.

The Square is one of the best restaurants I’ve ever been to. Truly a diamond in the rough. BY FAR the best pork dishes and crème brûlée I’ve ever had! Sit at the bar and hang out with Sarge, the owner. He is a great guy and very talented restaurateur! I hope to travel back to GA soon just to eat there again!

Outstanding food! Inexpensive as well. Décor is a bit too minimalist but an interesting history. Had the Cuban sammy plus the meatloaf, extremely well executed.

While my review is a bit biased because of my long-​time familiarity to the operator, I would suggest The Square as a must-​visit when you’re in South GA.
I would recommend starting your meal with fried green tomatoes; nothing says «old south» like tangy green tomatoes lightly-​fried in house-​made savory cornbread. The flavor combination is excellent.
I had the flat iron steak; my guests had a special Philly Steak sandwich made of the same steak. The steak (served at a perfect medium pink) was tender and flavorful; nothing extra needed. Simple, but flavorful baby red potatoes accompanied the meal.
The bar played an amazing supporting role during dinner with a tasty Old Fashioned (actually, two). I finished with a tasty Pineapple Upside Cake shot — Jeffrey made a tasty dessert.
The Square is definitely the best way to escape the lazy South GA heat.

Had dinner there on my birthday. The food was great; the Mocha Martini was pretty darn tasty; and the fried green tomatoes were my favorite. I’ll be going back.

I just have to gush that The Square consistently serves up the best food in town. The Square’s kitchen makes most everything from scratch, using as much fresh, local, seasonal ingredients as possible.

I had lunch here with a bus tour group this week and it was excellent! The black angus burger was one of the best burgers I’ve ever had, and the seafood chowder was wonderful. I wish I could have ordered a gallon of the chowder to take home with me. I will definitely visit The Square again!

Can’t believe that The Square is not on Unilocal so I’ll add it so fellow travelers don’t miss this gem. The food is great and the staff is friendly. Unilocal would not accept the address which is 25 1^st St SE in Moultrie but you can’t miss it. As the name implies it is on the east side of The Courthouse Square in Downtown Moultrie. The menu changes seasonally so there’s always a new favorite to discover.