Marcella’s Pizzeria

Best slice in Mt Kisco, no contest. Simple, authentic NY pizza thats remained consistent for 30+ years. And God bless them for always delivering out to Bedford Village.
Like any long standing slice joint, they have their rules and I honor them. So bring cash for orders under $ 10 and if you don’t, try not to be a baby when Grace & crew put you in line! Geez…

Probably the rudest counter persons I’ve ever had the opportunity to deal with — a middle aged woman who looks like she’s partied quite a bit and a 50 something chubby guy who over attempts a «Bronx» attitude — serving customers.
Anyway, had a slice and a chicken parm roll– mediocre at best. The kicker is– I had such horrible heartburn (I would assume from the sauce which they add parm cheese to) a few hours later. Funny thing is that there was a sign in the window– «best pizza in my kisco». If that’s the best pizza I feel bad for the residents of that town.

Ordered once again large pie half sausage half plain along with 2 pepperoni slices on the side, unquestionably the best pizza in NYS, in my opinion, anyone that post a bad review of this gem needs to be rushed to the Hospital because they are either experiencing a psychotic episode or they may be having a stroke
This pizza is SOOO Good that I detoured 20 minutes from Elmsford can’t add much more than that

This is probably my favorite pizzeria ever. I had the chicken parm pizza. Wow just wow

Best pizza in town!
I read the comments and I have to say these people have never been rude, yes the man and lady have a mean face but they are very pleasant and twice i have received free garlic roll. I have tried a few places around town and only mediocre pizza. Marcella has yummy cheese good sauce and a perfect thin slice.

To say this place is the absolute worst is a complete understatement. How does a pizza place screw up heating up two slices and some garlic knots? They made my three year old daughter’s slice scalding hot yet mine was barely lukewarm and the garlic knots were room temperature if that. Oh, then the attitude I got when i asked them to rehear the knots. You’d have thought i asked for the guys first born. Aside from the horrible attitude, the pizza and garlic knots were disgusting and tasteless. I wish i could give zero stars.

I’m a local truck driver. I’ve had pizza all over the hudson valley. This place is one of my favorites. They are consistent. Never made me bad food.

This pizza joint has been around as long as I can remember. Fantastic plain slice. Def. worth checking out if you’re in the mood for a solid slice. Can’t speak to the dinner options (chicken parm/​ect). Why bother when you have a good plain slice to chow down on?

I stayed in town for work yesterday and ordered delivery from here to my hotel. We had hot wings, garlic knots and chicken tenders with buffalo sauce. The wings have a coating on them and not the naked kind. These wings were extremely tasty and fairly spicy but not obnoxious. The garlic knots were the best I’ve ever had and the tenders were also very good. No doubt I will do this again when I’m back in town.

These people care about one thing and one thing only… MONEY. they don’t care about customers, or anything else. The crazy lady who thinks she’s from Mob wives won’t swipe a credit card for less than $ 10 if you were dying. You can just tell they are disgusting… always smoking in the back. It stinks like cigarettes. The tall skinny pizza man «Bobby» is loud and rude to customers. The in front basically yelled at me when I requested a slice and tried to pay with a credit card. I nor my children will never go back to that filthy, ginzo, wannabe italian poor excuse for a pizzeria again. How they lasted 33 years is beyond me because they reuse the slices for more than one day if they don’t sell them. GROSS

I was riding with some of their royal customers and they were right. The pizza was very tasty, but the dark hair lady has a sense of aggressive tone when she talk; however she was friendly to me, just hard to get used to that. I will visit there again if I drive up that way.

I work in Mt Kisco sometimes and whenever I do, I order a meatball wedge from Marcellas– they are fantastic! Their sauce is the best! The staff is always really nice too.

It was day three of 100 degree weather when I found myself walking up the giant hill that is Main Street. I was dying of thirst, dripping in sweat, and I felt like I was going to pass out. I popped into Marcella’s (I’ve ordered delivery from them countless times) and grabbed a bottle of water. I realized I only had my debt card on me, and I was greeted by a psychotic witch of a woman with black hair who borderline yelled at me that she didn’t have to accept my card for anything under ten dollars. I was clearly in distress, but she was more concerned about that 25 cent charge using a card would cause. These people put money above all else. Needless to say, they lost an extremely loyal customer that day.

Incredible pizza! Best chicken parm pizza in New York state! They’re always very friendly. Good quality ingredients (including cheese *cough* unlike some other local places *cough* Gianfrancos *cough*). Would fit in with any NYC pizza shop.

I, and everyone else in my family, loves their pizza. I think it’s the best in Mt Kisco and probably really up there northern westchester wide. Plus, it’s a family owned place run by really nice people! I’ve noticed they do some sort of… buns? I don’t know how to describe them but if anyone’s had a taste would love to hear about it

By far my favorite pizza in Northern Westchester and i’ve been to them all. This place makes some NY Pizza joints look like a joke. The focaccia slice and the chicken parm slice are forces to be reckoned with.

I thought I was going crazy… I just moved from here from the city and this pizza totally confused me. The crust was perfectly cooked, nice hard dry crunch with a soft doughy interior. The tomato sauce silenced me with its perfect balance of sweet and tangy tomato goodness. Both of these essentials were topped with delicious combination of fresh Mozzarella, basil and ham. Over 30 years of experience is very present in the taste of this pie and it effortlessly rivals Grimaldi’s or any other pizza joint.

The pizza here is nothing short of magical. Every bite is filled with the explosive flavor and unparalleled comfort of the freshest ingredients, combined with the most delectable flavors, and orchestrated by the hands of humble and noble pie architects, with over 20 years of experience. You can taste the love!!!
That’s what I’m talking about!
We had a simple combination of fresh Mozzerella, fresh Basil, and ham. It was divine! Love the pizza, love the people, many reasons to return.