McAlister’s Deli

Great place to eat. I had the Potato stuffed with Roast Beef and Sandy had the Chef Salad. Both was great. Also try the Wild Berry Ice Tea. The Spuds stuffed with Roast Beef were gigantic as was the Chef Salad. The Potato could use a little more with ti like some natural beef juice or perhaps some gravy. The Waitress was very friendly and professional. Definitely worth the 4 Stars.

The newest McAlister’s in the region seems to have captured all of the chain’s successful formula and taken it to another level. Great food as usual, modern design, LCD menus and an iced tea bar and separate pickle bar gives it extra nice touches. In our 3 visits since opening the service has been exceptional. Keep it up McAlister’s and welcome to Muncie.

Sunday, high noon, Father’s Day. Yes, it was busy.
Line to the door had me concerned, shouldn’t have been. It went quickly due to 4 registers open. Love the extra registers here!
Our party of 3 had 2 familiar with McAlisters at other locations, and 1 newbie [Father’s Day — Hey, he requested!] but all first timers here.
I mentioned that my Pops has been ranking this place high in his book and making regular visits and he really liked the stuffed potatoes. That had us all thinking on that — and we all ordered versions of the spud — grilled chicken, the mixup (think supreme meat), and a cheese w/​ranch dressing (which I then added garlic tabasco sauce to make buffalo style — my own little hack) — coupled with carrot cakes all around.
The baked potatoes were very good and as expected. The standout though was the carrot cake (which THANKFULLY they no longer serve on unappetizing little black plates). We ordered the carrot cakes at the same time we ordered the spuds letting them come closer to room temp.
AWESOME, excellent carrot cake — killer bang for the buck on this dessert.
Wanted a cup of joe to go with it — but can you go to McAlister’s and NOT get the besst sweet tea north of the Mason-​Dixon line?
I wish they had the Tea Bar in all of the McAlister’s. Great form and function.

Good food. A little expensive for the portion size. New menu has higher prices for even smaller portions. Get the salad for the most food for your money.

Great addition to the «UpScale» DELI restaurants. Walk right it, place an order at the counter, have a seat. «You will be served, and not on paper plates. The atmosphere is great, with large screens with NEWS, SPORTS, & MENU ideas. The staff was very helpful, courteous, appreciative, & CLEAN. We will be back here.

It was our first time trying McAllisters. They just built a new restaurant here and we were all really hungry after church.
There was a long line at the door just to place our order at the registers. The wait didn’t take longer than 10 minutes and the staff were very friendly when we placed our order.
The food was really good and everyone enjoyed what they had ordered. I’m always on the lookout for a good Reuben and this one didn’t disappoint. The soup was very flavorful. It wasn’t watered down or dried out, which always seems to happen everywhere else I go.
I only gave it a 4 star because of the portion size in relation to the price. It’s reasonably priced if you’re used to eating at Panera Bread. I left just a bit less full than I had hoped.
Overall, great deli with all the trimmings. I would definitely recommend to others.

McAlister’s is one of the many new places in town and it’s in a great location. Unfortunately, you can tell the place has only been open for a month.
The dining area is awesome, and the new video menu is cool because it goes through and shows pictures of each item on the menu.
I wanted to try something different so I ordered the Four Cheese Chili Pasta. Plain, Cold, and salad bar near frozen shredded cheese. If I were craving chili, I’d go somewhere else.
My girlfriend ordered her usual Spud with cheese. «Some bites are good and others are ewwww». In the picture you can kinda see the excessively burnt potato skin.
I’m glad McAlister’s moved in, and I was hoping that after waiting a month things would go a little better but I’m sure everything will get better over time
Very average place