Slice Custom Cakes

Stopped in last night, been looking to try since my daughter really wanted a cupcake. It took awhile to be greeted even though I was the only customer and the employees were all right behind the counter. The girl who helped me was very nice, we decided to get 4 cupcakes including my favorite red velvet… honestly there was nothing special about them, and I felt they were a little too dry for my taste, I didn’t even finish mine as the cake was too dry, too much way to sweet frosting for me as well. I wouldn’t go out of my way to try them again.

Slice is a little bakery that recently moved to Muskego from their previous location in Waterford WI. It’s a mother and daughter team who are as cool as can be. Always friendly and inviting and willing to help pick out something delicious. The location is convenient and easy to access from Janesville Road. It’s in the Lincoln Point shopping center near Anita’s Dance Studio.
I stopped in to pick up cupcakes. There were several flavors to choose from and two different sizes. I bought a half dozen of their jumbo cupcakes. The jumbo are definitely larger, but not to the extreme that the name implies. I noticed a table display of cookies that looked yummy and a display case full of colorful «cake balls». There was yet another case with slices of the cake «flavor of the day. You better believe that didn’t stick to my shopping list when I saw cake slices!
Prices were reasonable for a small custom bakery. I believe it was around $ 17 for six jumbo cupcakes and a single slice. The flavors I picked out were standard chocolate and funfetti. The desserts were good, not too sweet. They were also cooked well so as not to be too dry or overly moist. I cannot speak for their custom cakes but I saw photos of a few and instantly felt bad about my own decorating skills.
There are only a couple things that keep me from offering five stars. I wish the hours were more convenient for me (I have to work late) but also I don’t think that their baked goods are spectacular but they are beautiful and delicious. There are also far more flavors listed on their website that I would love to try but are not all readily available at the location daily.