Amish Country Store

Nice little store. They had some baked goods, things in jars, cheeses, snacks, jerky and a restaurant. They had lots of samples, but they were out of our favorite. The pies looked good. Bought a loaf of sourdough bread, but it was very soft and dense and didn’t really taste like sourdough.

This place is sitting right on a highway and I felt like their prices on their food and products was raised to take advantage of the traveler. I ordered the «famous» drip beef sandwich and there wasn’t enough beef on it to fill one half of the sandwich, I also ordered the Amish fries, thinking these were French fries. I was wrong. They were some sort of fried sliced potatoes with the clump of potatoes in the middle left uncooked. They were so full of grease I ate one bite and that was all I could eat. Overall I spent $ 15 for a lunch that wasn’t editable.

Great food and good prices. We went in to eat brunch and ended up buying a bunch in the country store as well. If you’re in the area, check it out.

When we visit the Muskogee area, this is a «must stop» every time. We load up on fresh produce in the summer, and always find a new jam or jelly that makes the «must have next time» list. That list gets longer and longer! Wonderful produce, products and most of all wonderful people!

Service was very poor and food portions were in tiny side dish saucers. I ordered chicken and dumplings and so did my wife. I had three pieces of chicken lil bigger than a half dollar and three dumplings. The green beans are cooked with bacon and were delicious. The fried okra was nothing special. They serve homemade yeast rolls which are also delicious. It is not an actual Amish ran restaurant or store. There is just products for sale with Amish labels from mass produced Amish companies. I had to give one star due to the lack of attention and friendliness of workers. They all seem preoccupied. We asked for jelly 3 times which are on most tables in bottles. Finally I just grabbed one of an empty table. The waitress saw that and said oh yeah we r out of the flavor u wanted. I also have to one star it for the lack of food portion and for thinking we were getting authentic Amish cooking. Not impressed and sorry but no pictures

Oh what fun! The chicken fry was large and delicious. Everything tasted like you were eating at mom’s house. The rolls were incredible but the highlight for me was the amish butter!!! Wow!!!
They have incredible fried pies and any dessert you can imagine on the store side. We left with bags of homemade candy and fudge. The only downside was that very little made it home after the long drive!
YUM!!!

Service was fairly good, food was really good and they do have authentic Amish food (regardless of whether or not an Amish person made it or waited on you etc.) They don’t make all the products, but most come from an Amish mfr. (check the labels).
We will be a repeat customer.

The homemade roll & their green beans were great, everything else not so much! I had chicken fried chicken and it was very chewy and such a small piece that the waitress brought it out and told me she took $ 1.50 off bc of how tiny it was. I don’t think I will go back… It didn’t seem very sanitary either.

I wanted to love the food but it was just OK. Waitress was awesome and let me sample several things including delicious Lebanon bologna. Meat loaf was good, Amish casserole disappointing, bread and desserts yummy. The store is very nice

cold food, gravy was soured, meat had a pepper overload, wait staff was totally clueless
when we voiced our complaint to the staff on duty, we were laughed at, contacted management via email and was told they would mail us a gift certificate to use at another time, been 2 months and have not got anything from them!!!

Went here twice with family while on vacation in Oklahoma and they surely filled us all up with great food! Their Momma’s French toast is the best I think.
But I just hope that they could be more consistent with their toast that comes with their Buggy breakfast, but overall — great customer service, cute place with all wall decors and an inside Amish store with a lot of great goods you’ll have a hard time choosing what to buy!

I really enjoyed stopping at this place. It was full of all kinds of Amish made foods. I got several flavors of fudge. I got red velvet, pecan, jalapeño, German chocolate, and lemon. I didn’t care for the lemon. The rest tasted good. Red velvet was my favorite. I also got a candle that smelled really good and some smoked cheese. Definitely worth the stop if you happen to find yourself in Muskogee.

Pretty good food and a comfortable atmosphere. The store had a ton of free samples and some pretty good snacks/​treats to purchase. The rolls that came with our meal were good and I ended up having the country fried steak, which was a tad greasy, but ain’t that how it’s supposed to be?

This small chain has an Amish theme. But the waitresses all wore tie-​dyed T-​shirts in neon colors, with «Kiss My Grits» stenciled on the back. Must refer to a different order of Amish than the ones I know.
They sell a lot of baked goods, snack food and candy to go. That’s probably their strong suit. Ordering a meal was not as good, a weak but not bad value for the money. Service was indifferent; waitress forgot one of meals and disappeared for a while.
Just one unisex bathroom for a pretty big place.

Their fudge and other food, like the fried pies, is fantastic. However, if you want to buy a meal to sit down and eat, the service sucks. The server asked us from across the room what we wanted to drink, and when my friend asked about biscuits, she flatly told him they were out of them without suggesting an alternative. C’mon, people. I’ve worked in a restaurant. It’s not hard to act like you care. When we finally got our food, though, it was great.

Not really an Amish store to begin with. We didn’t sit down but just got a few snacks. They were out of fried pies which would probably be the only reason I would go back. Besides the fudge and pies everything else seemed to be manufactured. If you are staying on HWY 69, there is a way better authentic Amish store on the north side of Pryor, OK.

I’ve never been to an Amish Store/​Restaurant before. Their fudge is amazing tried 3 diff flavors all to die for. The licorice is excellent. Definitely try the Watermelon & the Peach soooo good. The staff was just really sweet people. Will go there again if given the opportunity.