Pisano’s Pizza

I’ve been eating here since I was a kid. I’ve since moved to live in Los Angeles & then to the Bay Area, but I sure haven’t found any calzones as delicious as here. The perfect mix of cheese & meats, with a crispy crust. It’s cheap, too! $ 7.50 for the buffet is unheard of, so amazingly affordable! Pizzas are NY style, very cheesy and good.

I wish Pisano’s was in every city!
If you are in Muskogee, DON’T waste your money with commercial deliver/​Dominos /​pizza hut etc. Pisano’s is the way to go. Fresh and full of flavor. Perfect dough which is great tasting and has that elastic good feel that great pizza has.
Toppings were fresh and about the best i’ve had, no blandness here.
I travel throughout Oklahoma and tried Pisano’s lunch buffet as a last minute decision and glad I made the decision.
In one word MEMORABLE!

I enjoy eating at Pisano’s for the excellent pizza, pasta, calzone, salad bar, lunch buffet. Since they have begun delivering locally I have been ordering their excellent alpine pizzas regularly. Live in Tulsa, work in Muskogee — Pisano’s is definitely on the short list of best places to eat in Muskogee.

We stopped here when we were in Muskogee for the Bare Bones Film Festival. We didn’t know anything about restaurants in the area and picked this place because it was close to the theater.
We were pleasantly surprised, just because it was a smallish restaurant in a smallish town! There was a fair amount of variety and the pizza was super tasty. They had about 6 – 8 different pizzas. The supreme was really good and the white cheese pizza (I think what others are calling alpine, but I’ve never heard it called that) was one of the best pizzas we’ve had.
I didn’t have a chance to try the calzone because as soon as it was put out, people ran up to get some — so I’m assuming it’s good!
The salad bar was pretty decent. I was disappointed there weren’t any black olives and the only lettuce was iceberg, but aside from that, they had a lot of different topping and dressings. They also had a few items like cottage cheese and Jello salad.
We went on a Saturday night. The buffet was 7.99 each, which was a great deal, and the fountain drinks were 1.50, which is much cheaper than most places, especially buffets.
The lady at the register was very friendly and stopped by our table to make sure we had everything we needed and enjoyed everything.
I think this would be a great place to take small groups but I would call ahead for anything very large, just to make sure there is enough seating.

Great calzone. Alpine pizza is good if you like Alpine pizza. Decent salad bar usually.

Small selection, but the alpine pizza and calzone are all you need. Great place to eat, I’ve been coming here since I was little.

Went to eat their buffet with a friend. They don’t offer a pizza-​only buffet; you have to buy the whole package, which is $ 6.99. Not too bad. Drinks come separately and are like $ 1.50 each, as would be expected.
They only had two pizzas out on the buffet, and there was apparently some confusion when I asked if they could put out an italian sausage or pork sausage pizza, whichever they had. The cooks had no idea what I was talking about when the frontgirl relayed the message. Kind of embarrassing for them.
Their calzone tasted like ravioli to me. there was no garlic butter to be found on either the pizza or calzone.
They also had spaghetti out, but it looked like it’d been there for a while, which I’d believe as we were the only ones in there. I tried the spaghetti anyway and it was very stale.
Their salad bar wasn’t much to look at. The lettuce mix only had iceberg lettuce. No cabbage, carrots, spinach leaves, ect. They didn’t have much of a selection at all either, so I opted to skip the salad completely.