Jersey Mike’s Subs

I went in and ordered a #15, #13, and a pickle just now. I looked for a name tag and she didn’t have one. She was a much larger girl with very curly long hair. She greets me as I walked in (nice), then I gave her my order of which she stood there and told the manager to make. The manager told her she needed to make the sandwich at least 4 times back and forth and she literally just stood there laughing which forced her manager to make it. Was VERY unprofessional and she was lazy and to me should be FIRED. I would never allow an employee to talk to me that way as a manager. It offended me as a customer of which I almost said something to her. Which is the opposite of what I would normally do. Plus my sandwich was completely squished as they cut it. Can see the finger lines on my bread.
Horrible. If I walk in and she’s there I will literally walk out. I’m afraid to eat my food because who knows how sanitary everything was since she was even complaining as she put lettuce on my sandwich (the 1 extra condiment I asked for).

I called to see if I could order some subs in a box for the same day. It was just 4 giants in a box. The person on the phone told me they couldn’t do it. «It’s not what we do» to be exact. He told me they didn’t have enough to make them. Apparently they don’t have enough time to put 4 giant subs and put them in a box. I called the location on 75^th street and they were able to help me out perfectly! I Will never go eat at this location anymore!

This may be my new favorite sub shop. None in the Madison area yet: the closest is in MKE, apparently. Here’s the thing: THE MEAT IS FRESH-​CUT TO ORDER, right in front of you. Despite that, the sandwiches are cranked out FAST. Ordering a sandwich «Mike’s way» results in an herbed, oil & vinegar-​dressed sandwich, loaded with veggies. I also love the tangy cherry pepper relish, which I get instead of the O&V or mayo. I have now tried the Club Sub and The Original Italian (the latter was my fave).
I do hope we get a few Jersey Mike’s in Madison in the near future: they make Subway look silly.

I’ve seen this place around my local Jewel for a few months now and I decided to give it a shot! Many thanks to Angela P. whose review I read prior to placing my online order. My 2 sandwiches were about $ 15 together.
The turkey & provolone was hands down 5 stars! I customized it without the oils/​vinegar and got pickles, banana peppers and cherry pepper relish instead. If you’ve never had cherry pepper relish and a fan of peppers, GET IT! You won’t regret it! I hadn’t heard of them until last year, and now I am obsessed. No wonder they say the turkey is their best sellers– it’s one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had.
The other sandwich we got was the chicken parmesan. Ooooo… the sub itself was warm and toasted, the cheese was gooey, but you can tell that the chicken was kind of cold (and reheated). I threw the chicken in the microwave for a minute to warm it more. Meh.
When it comes to the store, I was surprised to see how big it was for the small store front. Lots of tables, the space was very clean, plenty of hands at the front making sandwiches at 1:30, and many people were eating there. I’ll definitely be back to eat in!

I was having a particularly bad day, and sometimes I need to get a bite outside of the office — some place far enough away from the office that I have enough time to drive there, eat, and drive back, but won’t run into co-​workers. We all have our days that we just want to be left alone. Jersey Mike’s fit the bill!
My go-​to at Jersey Mike’s is the Turkey & Provolone, but recently I tried the Chicken Parmesan, which I really liked. The sandwich was slightly on the messy side, but I wasn’t looking to romance anyone. Come to think of it, you shouldn’t try to romance anyone at Jersey Mike’s.
I like to come here for a filling lunch that won’t break the bank.

Love this place! Food is fresh and you get a huge amount for only $ 7. To top it off, the staff and manager are wonderful. Would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

JMs offers a generous variety of cold cut sub sandwiches made with fresh deli meats cut on site. The portion sizes are giant and trump other local sandwich places.
Aside from menu options, the staff is incredibly helpful and personable.
My only issue was that I felt full and slightly ill after eating here (on two separate occasions). It could be my stomach, but regardless be prepared for their giant portions.
Overall JMs is a solid New York style sandwich joint with an expansive menu and large portion sizes.

Tasty sammidges. Check it.