Little Sicilian Pizza

Nice staff but the food was mediocre. Meat balls were on the stale side, pizza was plain Jane nothing special. Fries were actually really good but the cannoli was frozen and flavorless

Yesterday I decided I would order pizza for one of my vendors in Naperville Illinois. My company is in Louisiana and I was a little reluctant, however I gave it a try. My vendor received the pizzas, and had never tried Little Sicilian, however they did assure me that they would be trying them out again. So thank you for a great experience!

Disappointing… Again. I can look past it being 15 minutes late, as long as it’s still hot & fresh! Not sure how long it was in the drivers car, but it was barely lukewarm, the cheese was hard and it looks like it had been sliding around. We had ordered it well done, which it was not. The crust was pretty wet — almost soggy. With multiple negative experiences, I think it may be time to move on…

Ordered 15 pizzas for a training event. They arrived exactly on time with everything ready and the order was correct. The pizza was just okay. Nothing to write home about. And it was a little overpriced.

Been here a few times. Great food and prices are fair. Nice staff as well.

We ordered a half cheese and half veggie pizza along with a Caesar’s salad for a meeting. I appreciated how easy the online ordering was. I followed up with a phone call with directions. I was greeted politely and professionally.
A few minutes later, I received a text with the approximate arrival time of the delivery. The food arrived a few minutes early. The delivery person was very nice and helpful.
The salads were large. The pizza was delicious. We were very happy with our order and will be ordering again.
Also loved the follow-​up email with the order again button in case we would like to re-​order the same thing in the future. This was a nice touch.
It was refreshing to not have to wait for a window of delivery, like most other Naperville pizza delivery restaurants.

Whatever happened to this place is not good. They need to go back to what they were before the temporary shut down. Drove by and saw they re opened so decided to order a pizza being that I remembered their pizza being excellent. Unfortunately this time around it was not good. Like at all. For $ 35 I was very unhappy. Hopefully they get back on the right track bc I honestly remember their pizza being great hence my previous review.

Perhaps the best Italian beef I’ve had in the suburbs. Order it with mozzarella and hot peppers. Comes with delicious crispy fries. I prefer the sandwich to the pizza, though there’s nothing wrong with that. This is a hole in the wall, mostly a carry out or delivery place, though they do have one indoor seat and some outside tables.

Not impressed. The crust was doughy. Red sauce was decent enough otherwise the rating would be lower. I guess I am just spoiled with New Haven CT, NYC metro and Chicago. Hey, we live in the. Chicago area, right?

So glad they reopened after a hiatus. Legit pizza. Friendly staff. They have middle weight Chi style pizza down. We always pick up but they do deliver and I remember in the summer the delivery drivers would bike deliveries to Cress Creek. Great pizza, they don’t skip on ingredients and everything is really fresh so 5 stars it is. There are tables outside for eating out in warm weather but this is not a sit down restie.
To the Unilocalers complaining about their pizza slices I don’t think you can judge a pizza place by their slices. You need to have a whole pie to enjoy it. Come on, those slices are sitting there for hours. Get real or go to Speedway a mile west and enjoy a pizza slice.

I got a slice and a pop from here a few weeks ago. Quality of the pizza was similar to the pizza 90’s kids got served for hot lunch in elementary school. I forget how much I paid but it was way much seeing that I threw the pizza out after 3 bites.

Went here a few days ago and they were out of hot dogs, so ordered a beef sandwich and waited almost 20 minutes for it. Beef was decent and fries were good, so went back today for a beef hoping it would be a little quicker. Well they have no bread or fries today, basically a greasy slice of pizza is the only option. I reluctantly order a slice which comes out to $ 4.02 and she gives me a «free» drink cup for the inconvenience (i don’t even drink pop but I thought it was a nice gesture), I pay with a $ 10 bill and she hands me a $ 5 back and smiles and walks away… wtf??? I don’t think I’ll be going back. Oh and the pizza slice was not very good.

Stopped in when I was back in the area a couple weeks ago. I ordered the meat amore thin crust. It was cooked perfectly and super delicious. The Italian beef on it is a great twist on your classic meat lovers pizza. Can’t wait till I’m in town again to try some of the other menu items the cannoli look so good :)

Okay — now I’m really confused after reading these positive reviews… The pizza I received had absolutely, positively, without a doubt the worst crust I have had anywhere in my entire life. Shockingly bad. So bad, I almost want to order it again to see if it could possibly always be that inedible. Tasted like they pre-​burned a stale disk of dough, waited a few days to top it, then burned it some more. Could not even bite through it because it was so hard. Never in my life had to throw away pizza — but there is apparently a first time for everything… But hey, maybe I just caught them on a bad day?

New ownership, same shit recipes, higher prices.
I saw they were open again after the health dept shut them down with new ownership. I figured they might have changed for the better. They wanted $ 4.05 for a «jumbo» slice of pizza, which turns out to be slightly smaller than the average slice you would expect from any given pizza place, and had clearly been made hours and hours ago.
Stick with Braconi’s or Rosati’s. This restaurant is not long for this world.

Their pizza is absolutely amazing! We orders from here a dozen times before it closed for a few months. Just opened back up and it’s still frickin delicious! Soooo excited it’s back!

I feel a little like Goldilocks as I write this…
I ordered 2 pizzas. One «primavera», which didn’t taste *just* like real Italian pizza, BUT tasted enough like it that my kids (who’ve been all over Italy) really liked it. We had it with olive oil instead of sauce. It came with fresh tomatoes, chunks of mozzarella and fresh basil. That one was the overall favorite with everybody. If I had any complaint at all, it would be that it seemed slightly undercooked. I would have preferred it baked just a few minutes longer but I would definitely order that again.
With the 2^nd, I decided to go «Chicago» and order the Italian beef with peppers. It was good. Not so good that I rave about it or would necessarily order it again, but also not unenjoyable either. Funny enough, while the primavera seemed slightly undercooked, the Italian Beef was slightly overcooked. «This one is too brown and this was is too light!» ;)
Toasted ravioli was ordered. I didn’t eat them, as I’m not a fan of that type of appetizer. Daughter said they were good but not great. She is a kid, but she has pretty well developed tastes. Her thoughts were that she’d order them again if she were craving toasted ravioli but they weren’t the best she’s had.
Overall, we liked the crust and and all thought the ingredients tasted fresh. We will definitely order again.

Excellent. Excellent pizza. Excellent sides. Excellent staff. That’s all.
Just kidding, seriously though I truly had my reservations about cheating on my go to but I decided what the heck why not, I’d suggest you do the same.
The staff? So first off the girl who answered the phone was awesome, we joked and laughed and got the job done. When I showed up she was super nice and a fellow Cubs fan so really can’t go wrong here.
The pizza? Great. The house crust is legit. Hah, thicka than yo average (thnx Biggie Smalls) but great taste and crispy on the edge, sausage good, cheese good, sauce good. Nothing other worldly but stand up for sure.
The sides? This is where I was sold. The cheesy bread stuffer is soo good! Different and much needed. The wings were great. Also different, can’t quite put my finger on it but good, the breading perhaps?
The only small, very small knock I had was the side of marinara. I am a HUGE fan of fresh marinara and the side was obviously from previous batch because it was cold.
But let clarify a few things 1. I ordered as soon as they opened, don’t think they had enough time to even turn on the oven much less make fresh marinara. (I was salivating) 2. I get the whole waste not thing, I’d rather have cold marinara than to have a bunch wasted everyday.
All in all I love this place! It won’t dethrone my go to (yet) but will be a very close second and a change of pace place for me.

We ordered two pizzas, one cheese and sausage, both on house crust. We made the mistake of asking for well done because their idea of well done is VERY well done. Cheese was almost black and the crust looked dry.
Luckily the pizza tasted pretty good. The sausage needed more on it but otherwise tasted good. I’d like to try the house crust without being well done and then the traditional thin crust.

So, I’ve driven past this place multiple times and never gave them a shot, but I finally did and I loved it. We usually order pizza from Uncle Pete’s, but I think we have some good competition now! We had a 12″ pizza and french fries delivered and it was a lovely meal. The staff member that answered the phone was very helpful and friendly. We had our order delivered and it arrived promptly via a very friendly and personably delivery driver.
I think one of the best parts about the entire experience is that our french fries were still hot when our delivery arrived… I know… WOW. I just knew the fries would be cold and our kids would be like…“Ewww, these are cold!” However, that wasn’t the case. The fries as well as the pizza were both piping hot and the pizza tasted really good. It had the perfect amount of cheese and sauce. The toppings were really fresh as well. So, we’ll def start calling upon Little Sicilian when we need our pizza fix… well…fixed. I recommend you do the same!