Goodfellas

Veggie pizza was good, but service was slow and the female who was delivering the take out pizza’a was so angry. Glad I didn’t have delivery that day.

Good food, especially their pastas, however good food cannot make up for poor service.

Love their pizza!!! Monday night specials are great. Not much room in the dining room so we usually take to go.

Bad service, bad sauce, good thin crust, and fantastic double crust pizza. Definitely a mixed review.
I’ve been here one time so keep that in mind, I am not trying to nitpick, just trying to accurately recount our experience. Maybe it was a bad night, maybe people were sick, maybe the party downstairs was really really big but for whatever reason we received very poor service. We were told to seat ourselves and sat for a good 10 minutes before we saw anyone, then another wait for our drinks to come back, then a long wait for our appetizers to arrive then what seemed like an eternity for the pizza after we had to order for ourselves at the bar. Drinks are empty, it’s been a really long time, this = me walking to the bar and standing there with 4 empty cups, smiling and trying to exude patience while hoping to make eye contact with the server, this happened twice. I also got to stand at the bar to put in our pizza order as we hadn’t seen anyone in a long time, our kids had been waiting for a half hour already and there was still no sign of our garlic bread. The dirty look I got each time I had to stand at the bar was just icing on the cake. The waiting was really no big deal in the grand scheme of things and having to fetch your own drinks and put in your own order isn’t going to kill anyone either but I really could have done without the looks of annoyance from the staff when they left us sitting in the corner with no service. The third time the bartender actually said in a loud voice to some of the other customers «excuse me, I’ll have to take his order before I can get your drinks» Nice touch, she must have known that the other server wouldn’t be back anytime soon. It was over an hour and a half from the time we walked in until we got my credit card back. Had it been just my wife and I or if it were not a school night I would have just waited at our table but Dads have responsibilities and those kids need their sleep.
The garlic bread was OK, not bad but I wouldn’t order it again as it was kind of dry and the sauce was really bitter and acidic tasting; seemed to be just canned tomato sauce with some dried oregano added. The kids had a cheese pizza, it was cooked perfectly and had just the right amount of cheese on a delicious thin crust. Thankfully the lackluster sauce wasn’t noticeable, it didn’t help but it didn’t ruin the pizza either. My wife had a combination pizza, again really good toppings, cooked perfectly, yummy crust, bad sauce. Overall the regular thin crust pizzas were pretty good. I had the double crust pizza (think stuffed crust) and WOW, I could eat this every day of the week. There is almost no sauce in the pizza, they serve it on the side so you can safely ignore it. What’s not to love, two delicious crusts and 4 of your favorite toppings. I had sausage, pepperoni, onion, and provolone. It was oozing cheese and was absolutely GREAT.
I doubt the family will be back because Romano’s pizza is all around better but I would definitely make it back on a guy’s night out for another double crust or a calzone.

Great pizza in a small town – fair prices with great service to boot!
And Mondays $ 5 one topping. special is a. steal! Good selection of cold beverages is a plus!

I grew up in NYC, and lived in Chicago for 4 years. So I know good Italian food. Goodfella’s has amazingly good Calzones, pizza and sandwhiches. I just had a Calzone and a salad. The salad had any 5 ingredients I wanted and was $ 3.95. I had chicken, tomatoes, pepperocinos, mushrooms and green olives on a tossed salad. Add 2 Sierra Nevada Pale Ales, I’m in Heaven. Staff treats you like family. Mangia!