Pizza King

Would appreciate faster service next time. Management was not polite about the speed of service or did they offer an apology, but Waitress was wonderful and sweet. She personally deserves a raise.

I just returned from New Castle, IN for a wedding. Our family ate their after rehearsal one night. The food was very good as well as the service. The lady waiting on us was very nice. We had the pepperoni pizza along with salads. Some had sandwiches, which they said was some of the best they have had. If your ever in New Castle I would recommend you try it.

Consistently good pizza! One of my favorite locations.

I have been going her for a long time, most of my family live here, and this P.K. has been a growing staple of fine pizza in New Castle as the Top Hat. My family and I travel from Martinsville Indiana all the way to this Top Hat Pizza King for some of the best, hottest, cheesiest, pizza ever ! We have tried a few others around where we live, but they are not even close to the sight, smells, and friendly, atmosphere that you get from this family dining establishment.

We went there as a family tradition following my grandmas funeral, as this was her favorite place and they did a wonderful job handling all of us and the pizza was fantastic. Our waitress was also very kind and did very well w the crowd.

Their normally rude and the store is often not clean. The Pizza is subpar at best.

I’m shocked to see there aren’t any reviews of the Pizza King and feel slightly privileged that I’m writing the first one! Pizza King is one of those places that I remember from childhood when we visited my grandparents in New Castle, it hasn’t changed a bit over the years, I was happy to see that they still have the paper bags in which to wrap the to-​go orders and left overs, nothing has changed in all these years. Pizza King is very much a part of New Castle, one of those places that we have to go to when we visit a couple times a year.
The interior isn’t really much to speak of, standard booths and tables, nothing fancy and the décor is pretty bland but who really cares! The pizza is like a combination of cracker crust with a little more dough to give it that perfect crunch with a little more substance, awesome! The toppings are a little different as well, the pepperoni and sausage seems to be almost ground which ensures that they cover a good portion of the pizza as opposed to big slices of pepperoni.
All in all I love Pizza King, I hope they never change! Every time I go it’s like revisiting a slice of my childhood trips to New Castle.