Fitzgerald’s Pub

If you’ve never experienced racism before and you feel like taking a whiff of it… then this is your place to go. The owner (a white old man) was rude and disrespectful to us, we were celebrating 2 birthdays and visited on Friday, June 17^th at approximately 6pm with about 10 – 12 people (professional «minorities») during happy hour. No one was drunk, we were only there for about an hour. As we were wishing our friends a Happy Birthday and we cheered for them, this man approached us and told us to be quiet (not in a nice way). He then proceeded to drown us out with very loud music. Then about 3 of us got up to play darts and this man goes and take the darts from my friends and said it was too busy to play darts! There was about 23 people in this bar in total. Needless to say we paid our bill (he’s lucky we did) and left. PLEASE DO NOT SUPPORT THIS ESTABLISHMENT!

Do not go there. With a group of twelve and the owner asked us to «keep it down.» But, we were a group of people of color and probably just too fun for him. Even other folks left after they saw how the owner treated us. It was not fun and certainly felt terrible to be treated so poorly. Please stay away.

Zero if I could. The owner told us to be quiet at 6pm on Friday during their happy hour cause we were celebrating 2 birthdays and too loud. Then we asked to play darts, and he said that the bar was too busy. There were 23 people in the bar. This guys is rude, disrespectful, racist, and argued that we were out of order. Never go here

DO NOT SUPPORT THIS ESTABLISHMENT. It’s Friday night at 6pm and our party of 10 – 12 is celebrating 2 birthdays. We toast and are excited, and the bar owner comes up to us to tell us to be quiet. 3 of us go to play darts a few minutes later, bar owner grabs darts out of one person’s hand and tells them darts is off limits because the bar is «too crowded.» There are 23 people in the bar. Maximum capacity probably would be at least 100 people. Did I mention the bar owner is an old white man and we were the only people of color (and the biggest party) in the spot? Even if you wanted to check it, this spot is gonna close down soon anyway because IT IS NOT POPPIN AND NO ONE WANTS TO COME AT HAPPY HOUR. #racist #youaintgonmakeit

This is an ok bar, I had an interesting convo with the bartender and we came in at 3am so there wasn’t much option on bars to go to. Drinks are moderately priced; $ 7 each, $ 6 beers. Not a bad spot for a late night out.

We were visiting a couple friends in the city (coming from jersey). We had some time to kill before the train arrived and wanted to catch the okc-​gsw game. Great spot to watch the game, shots of Jamison were $ 5„ the bartender had some wicked cool sports stories. Casual, solid spot

Great local pub with a very friendly and attentive staff. It’s a no frills kinda place, but in a really good way. It’s a great local establishment that has been there for many years. College students frequent this place (given that Baruch is around the corner), but it also has a good local crowd who live and work in the area.
Good selection of beers and whiskeys. They also have happy hour specials. Food is your standard pub fare (burgers, sandwiches, apps). Nothing fancy, but delicious and executed well.
It can get crowded some nights, but it’s mostly a relaxed atmosphere. It’s a place you can go alone to have a beer and watch a game, or with a group.

Was in there on a Thursday around 1pm and was told I couldn’t sit at the bar and have a water while my friend had a beer. Keep in mind the place was empty. Ridiculous.

Pretty chill college bar, been here loads of times. The older bartender can be a bit rude if you’re not drinking, but the younger dudes are chill. They sometimes chase you out of the tables if you’re not eating. Pretty clean venue, and never had a problem with the bouncer.

Stopped by for happy hour. Not too shabby and $ 4 drafts. The atmosphere was very mic like a sports bar. The bartender was friendly and very laid back.
Probably not a place I’d go out of my way to get to, but I’d definitely stop by if I were in the area. Only downside is that there is a $ 15 on cards!

Was in on a Friday night around 9pm and it was pretty dead. Darn it.
I liked the venue though. lots of bar space and seating elsewhere away from the bar. Not very loud so you can meet and chat with others. Decent drinks and bartender. Friendly enough staff.

Nice traditional Irish bar. Good happy hour and a dart board! When in after work for a quick drink. Bartender was very courteous and quick

Fitzgerald’s Pub is a pub I frequent for the sake of distance — it’s just a few steps away from Baruch. The service here has been going downhill, and I’m ready to call it quits on this one. Surprisingly, there used to be a FRIENDLY Irish man working here, but now the current staff is very disgruntled and extremely sassy. From the moment you sit down, you’re instantly hounded by a rude waiter who has no regard for time. If you need a few minutes to decide, you’re already in trouble. Why would you not give me some breathing room to decide what to order? I’m often met with dirty looks just for this reason. Weird. The drinks on their happy hour menu are often watered-​down. Ordered Cabernet, a Cosmo, and a Long Island Iced Tea from this place, all watered-​down. The Blue Long Island is probably the only drink that tasted acceptable. The staff also mutters insults under their breath if they don’t like a customer. So beware.
An old friend of mine and I met up for shots a few weeks ago. Spent around $ 200 and were kicked out after a while. Didn’t feel like arguing and killing my buzz, but getting kicked out is normal here.
Another instance, my friend and I (after paying for our drinks) got kicked out for having a conversation for too long. Since when is 20 minutes a long time? Sounds pretty standard to me. Reason being was that they wanted to make more room for a nonexistent party of INVISIBLE. So we left, but checked the place out again to see our table, and it was empty, just as we left it.
Don’t bother complaining about customer service to anyone, especially the older guys. They are very set in their ways in that they won’t listen to a differing opinion. The moment I expressed my opinion on an incident that happened the last time I was at Fitz, which was a couple of months ago, I was told to «move on and get over it». Awesome, I’ll take my service elsewhere.

Went here on a Wednesday night roughly around 11 and stayed until 3 am. When we came in there were a few men at the bar. We found a table and ordered drinks at the bar. Through the night we had 4 drinks each (there were 4 of us) and no complaints. The drinks ranged from a jack and coke to shots of whiskey and beer. A Cosmo was a bit too sweet, but it was my first time trying one so it could just be like that. Sometimes I like to get a blue Hawaiian and was surprised the bartender made it just right.
The man at the bar was probably the owner and had good vibes.
Chill place, but probably packed weekend nights since it’s close to a campus.
I also hear the food is really good, but didn’t try it this night.

It’s a great place to spend time with your friends. The drinks are good too, however, it’s sometimes hard to get the bartenders attention and the wait can be long. Other than that the place is not bad.

On a day when class is not in session, Fitz is not a bad bar to go to.
However, on the days there are class, good luck squeezing through the copious amounts of college students that frequent this place. It’s so crowded that you can barely move from one spot to another without pushing and shoving. On any other day when the crowd and noise level is moderate, it’s a nice place to catch up with friends.
Because so many college students come here, naturally the bar would overprice its alcohol. So far, this place has one of the more expensive happy hour deals in the area. $ 7 special for well drinks? Come on! I can go one block over and get the same drink for $ 4.
I will give credit to the bartenders and say that they’re sweet people and they even make your drinks strong! 1 Blue Long Island is is almost always enough to get me to tipsy heaven.

I like it here. It is a college crowd (considering there is a college right around the corner), but also a lot of the Flat Iron corporate crowd.
I came here for the first time on St. Patricks day, and being that Fitzgeralds is an Irish pub, it was packed. But no lie, the bartenders handled it really really well.
There are tables to sit and eat– I can’t necessarily vouch for the meal food, but it looks like it could be comfortable to sit and eat here. As for the bar food– it’s greasy and salty. The buffalo wings are very spicy– but it’s just typical bar food. It’s pretty expensive– for a basket of fries and wings– total almost $ 20.
There’s lots of TV, showing news or games.
Good selection of alcohol. Beer– there’s just your basics. Shots and beer are both $ 7, it’s standard bar prices.
I would come back for a drink here, the bartenders know what they’re doing. Just be careful– there’s a $ 20 minimum for card charges.

It’s an okay pub. Went randomly on a Monday night and it was just the bartender running the place, meaning cleaning up tables and serving. The selections of beers is minimal. The crowd is def a college crowd. Bathroom is clean for a pub. All in all probably won’t be returning as there isn’t anything special to this place at least in my opinion.

Great little Irish pub without too many wannabes, hipsters, or douches. The bartenders are friendly and it is a great hangout. Lots of fun to shoot darts and drink beer, especially at 1pm!

Decent place for a quick pint and a grilled cheese sandwich.
They do Irish breakfast (didn’t have it) so I’m not sure if they have black puddings (among my favorite).