My Belly’s Playlist

The only good thing about this «meal» was the delivery was on time.
GROSS. gross. and more of the same gross, disgusting, and at last, inedible.
Ordered the buttermilk mac n cheese. Regular elbow mac, not the kind described in the menu, and it was very spicy– also not described that way in the menu. Burnt my mouth up. Hated it.
Doppelgänger — DIS GUS TING Like, a giant pile of gross, greasy, like-​grilled-​on-​the-​edges or burnt or something turkey with a sliver of tasteless pepperoni and bland cheese between two slices of soggy burnt-​grill tasting pieces of bread with like, a little tiny droplet of horseradish cream, maybe?
I’m still gagging.
STAY. A WAY

I ordered in while at work for the 1^st time. I ordered the Keen wha… It was soo good! I’m glad I didn’t order meat bc it wasn’t even needed! They even gave me a chocolate chip cookie, which I don’t need but ate anyway! Great healthy and good food!

Lunch ordered! Hour & 10 minute delivery after 45 min stated… Breath in, roll with the punches.
Doppleganger sandwich, excellent combination of flavors. Arrived soggy. Breath in, roll with the punches…
Tomato soup. More like marinara sauce. Breath in, roll with the punches…
Will I be back for round II? Do they deserve another chance at the champ’s title belt? Tune in next time for a (maybe) updated review. Same belly order, same belly Unilocal

My Belly’s Playlist consistently delivers a great sandwich or wrap. They have a pretty innovative take on sandwiches and quality is never a concern. Every sandwich also comes with a cookie and some relishy/​mustard thing that compliments their sandwiches well.
While I’ve never been disappointed with my sandwich selection and have tried nearly everything there, their prices are a little steep in my book. On the lower end it’s around $ 9-​$ 10 and on the higher end around $ 15-​$ 16. It is definitely a quality sandwich, but if their prices were a little cheaper it would be a no brainer for me more often.
As for recommendations, I like the buffalo chicken with blue cheese dressing, the BLT, and the Mane lobster rolls. Their bacon is always really crispy and fresh tasting.

I was in the mood for Mac and cheese and Seamless searched for it. My Belly’s Playlist came up. Having no idea what I was in for I ordered their mac and cheese and a guero wrap.
Everything was delivered about 20 minutes later in a neat little stamped brown bag. The packaging was labeled ‘Eat Me’ (don’t mind if I do) and everything was still piping hot. But wait, what’s this? There was an extra box in my bag. Upon opening it up I saw concert tickets and a cookie! What silly chef accidentally dropped two tickets to The Soft Parade at BB King Blues Club & Grill and cookies into my lunch? There is no accident here, some lucky orders of My Belly’s Playlist include two tickets to venues such as BB King Blues Club, The Blue Note and Highline Ball Room! I guess it was my lucky day!
Even luckier, upon biting into my wrap with grilled chicken, avocado, cilantro, sauteed peppers, jalapenos, onion, and provolone on a warm tortilla with iceberg lettuce and crema I was immediately satiated but, ate the entire thing anyway since it tasted like pure sunshine.
I cannot WAIT to order from here again. I can’t believe this delivery only joint (the Tribeca location has a physical location but, not this one) such a little known secret. Actually, I shouldn’t even be telling you this since it will decrease my odds at getting tickets to more shows but, I can’t help it!