New York Penis Cakes

I wuv your penis. Cakes tasted good, and the fresh white sauce that came out of the cake. You could do better with the details. MAKE IT MORE REALISTIC. I bet you that my penis is bigger than your cake

I’ve had two experiences with them so far and I only have good things to say!
Sarah oversaw our order and she was impeccable about it. Even though I changed my cupcake order to a 3D cake at the last minute, she was accommodating throughout the process and still managed to have it delivered on time. Great customer service is hard to come by in New York, and I’m glad I found it here of all places!
Everyone had a laugh about it too! It will be one of those things that your friends will talk about for years to come — and New York penis cakes does a great deal in ensuring that memory is a good one.
Only gripe is that the phone number provided across all their pages doesn’t work — it just redirects to an automated voice message telling you the number doesn’t exist — so if you have a quick enquiry or an urgent request, email is your only option.

I hosted a bachelorette party for my sister in Manhattan this Labor Day weekend and ordered a cake from NY Penis Cakes the day before the party. It was delivered as promised between 1−5pm (my choice). I was coming in from out of town and staying at a hotel so I requested that it be delivered after 3pm check-​in and it was. The cake was AWESOME! I went with the vanilla flavor and the 3D cake which all the girls thought tasted so delicious. My sister «the bachelorette» told me she had a slice the next morning for breakfast and it was still really good. I also love that it was «discreet» when packaged. Thank you NYP Cakes!!!

Great cupcakes and so much fun to see my friend’s face when she opened the box! they looked and tasted great! I ordered them 48h before and they came in exactly when expected. Sarah (the owner) was very available, and very nice!

I was planning my best friend’s bachelor party (gay wedding!) and when I googled penis cakes and found this place, I knew it would be perfect. The cakes are expensive, but I got everyone who would be in attendance at the bachelor party to chip in $ 20 each so it turned out to be cheap among all of us. The cake was delicious, and it was a hilarious, wonderful conversation piece for the party. Not too gratuitous but racy enough for the atmosphere of a gay bachelor party. So, I’m sure you guys don’t need this endorsement but, these cakes are good for the gays too!!! :)

The cupcakes are huge and delicious!

New York Penis Cakes were awesome! I ordered a penis cake for my friends bachlorette party with no hassles or embarassment thru their website. They were professional, delivered on time and the cake looked/​tasted great. It was great that the penis was completely edible — bachlorette said it was like a giant tootsie roll! Overall, I would totally recommend this company to cater to your bachlorette parties.

These cakes were THE BEST! I was looking for something fun for my friend’s bachelorette party but nothing too tacky — these cakes were perfect. I ordered the cupcakes and not only did they look great but they were delicious! Everybody loved them, they were really fun and cute. Also — Sarah was fantastic about organizing delivery and was flexible with my requirements. 100% recommend.

Our 3D cake was the perfect surprise to my friend’s bachelorette! Not only was it a masterpiece in cake and frosting, but it was totally delicious. We even had some customizations to our cake that the team had no problem accommodating. The cake was delivered to a restaurant which, again, there were no problems with that either. The hostess at the restaurant said the entire staff took photos when it arrived. I highly recommend New York Penis cakes!

New York Penis Cakes is amazing! A place that is catered to bachelorette parties is great and saves you the embarrassment of a calling a local bakery. I got the 3D Penis Cake in the light color they offer and red velvet cake flavoring and it was delicious! The whole party loved it. They said the delivery would be between 1−5pm and it was right on time and was delivered neatly with no problems. I would highly recommend you getting your penis cake from here!

The cake was ordered 3 days be the bachelorette party and it was delivered right on time. The cake was very tasteful and everyone loved it. It was moist and delicious. These people are very professional and communication was on point. If your looking for a company to bake your cake for that special occasion, you will not be disappointed. I most definently will do business with them again.