Pie Pie Pizza

Awesome pizza, fast delivery. I would definitely recommend them. I ordered from seamless and it was fast and worked well. Friendly staff!

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever ate. definitely THE best pizza in the neighborhood!
Fresh ingredients, super friendly staff and fast delivery!
Did I mention very affordable?!
Would highly recommend!!!

Best pizza in Washington Heights. I’ve been living in WH for years– and although there’s a great number of pizza joints… most are greasy, heavy, and totally flavorless. These guys are the exception: every time I go, the pizza is fresh and delicious. Great prices.
My only wish is that they had more slice variety… but they’re branching out with soups and crepes!
UPDATED REVIEW: I posted the above review three months ago… AND PIE PIE listened! Now, they’ve got an amazing variety of pies, sandwiches, soups, crepes and even italian ices! Huge selection!
Got the spinach ricotta slice… couldn’t be more delicious. Love that the owner takes his business seriously, and listens to customers. Best joint in the neighborhood, hands down.

I really like this place. The staff is friendly, the food is great, and the price of their special can’t be beat! The only complaint I’d have is it was a little on the dirty side.

During the Spring of this year, the pizza tasted delicious, was a generous size and price was $ 1 for small slice and $ 2 for regular slice. 4 months later, the $ 1 pizza is $ 1.50 which is ok, but the size is smaller than what it used to be, the dough taste like pita bread and hardly any cheese topping. The $ 2 regular slice is now $ 2.25, and been skimpy on the cheese or sauce. All it is a slice of undercooked pizza with hardly any flavor or topping, since it barely has cheese or sauce on it.
When I asked what happened to the quality and prices, the pizza guy ignored me and afterwards blasted his little radio. A few weeks ago, I overheard the pizza guy talking to whom I guess was the owner, discussing revenue and profits, soon after this pizza shop tanked in food quality and quantity.
I really enjoy getting a decent slice for a buck, but when the $ 1 increased to $ 1.50 per slice as its portion decreases to a miniature offer, that is outrageous! I mean, this is low-​income Washington Heights where they are selling pizza at a higher price for smaller size than downtown where you get a dollar pizza that is a large slice with adequate amount of cheese and a dough that taste great for what a pizza cost on special for $ 2.00 or less.
I like that they have seating booths bistro style floor length open windows. I have been thinking about buying pizza elsewhere and just ordering a can of soda at their pizza establishment, then sit down and eat the better quality and quantity pizza just to protest their toddler size $ 1.50 slice.
I really hope that Pie Pie returns to it practice of making and serving good pizza that the neighborhood patrons will appreciate and buy. Especially, since there is another pizza shop just a block away that is stiff competition, but many preferred Pie Pie due what used to be a good value deal, has seating, and a bistro style atmosphere. Listen to your customer’s concern or begin to see loss of profits as your business dwindles down.