Pizza Stop

Horrible customer service, didn’t even make our pizza and I called prior to ask when it was being sent out and they said they left and sent it out, again nothing. We call again and they said it was never made. Hire better people, please.

I have never written a review before, but I finally found a place that warranted setting up a profile. This is by far the worst food I have had in a very, very long time. I ordered a grandma’s pizza with garlic and a cheeseteak sub. The pizza was supposed to be thin crust — it was not. In fact, it was thicker than any other regular pie you would get anywhere else. In addition to this, the sauce was disgusting and there was no garlic. The cheesesteak was another soggy, disgusting mess. I have no idea who is writing the reviews for this place, but I can only assume it is the owners. ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!!!

The best thing here is the grandma slice. I’ve tried the backed ziti and the chicken parm but it’s just not that good. The grandma slice is number 1, then bacon ranch pizza, then buffalo chicken pizza. Don’t bother with the other things on the menu.

Pizza was ‘ok’
but service was just about the most ghetto I’ve seen in a long time… not a nice experience!

Grandma pizza was good and the delivery was rather quick. Will order again.

The pizza stop is a great spot! Charlie and Lenny are great people. The pizza’s and patties were great. When I get back to Harlem I’m headed there.

Pizza comes hot and fresh. Pretty greasy, but pretty tasty. Solid neighborhood pizza spot.

I’ve decided to update this review one more time. To summarize, Pizza Stop has been, and continues to be, our go to Harlem pizza delivery location. It’s certainly not the best pizza in the city, but it’s the best pizza around. We order from them probably twice a month on average.
The reason I’m updating and removing a star is that recently we have been having a lot of issues with our orders. I’m unsure if something is different on their end, or if this is just a coincidence, but we never had such problems until the last few months.
It seems almost every time we order there is either something missing, or the wrong item was included. Usually it’s little things — we pay the little bit for extra dipping sauce for a calzone but don’t receive it (or the free one it’s supposed to come with); we select garlic knots as the complimentary item when ordering a pasta dish, but just get plain Italian bread; a salad goes missing from the order; etc. I’m certainly not going to ask them to redeliver an order of free garlic knots or missing sauce, but the frustration does add up.

Since moving to Harlem from NJ, Pizza Stop has been my go to for good pizza. Can’t go wrong with a grandma pie, Chicago style buffalo chicken slice or a chicken Stromboli.

Good fresh pizza ! Very loaded and delicious hawaiian pizza. Worth the $ 4! IDC ! Its loaaaaded

My cant-​go-​wrong, go-​to pizza place. Very good and fast pizza, friendly staff. $ 5 for 2 cheese slices and a can o soda.
You wont find a better deal this tasty in NYC.

I love Pizza Stop. I’ve lived in Harlem for 8 years, and after trying every pizza shop in my vicinity, I always come back to Pizza Stop. That grandma pie is insanely good — by far my favorite. Delivery is always painless and quick. Always satisfied!

We ordered from here on grubhub after waiting for an ultimately failed attempt at Harlem Shake. We got fried calamari, BBQ chicken pizza slice and a chicken parm sandwich.
The delivery was relatively normal, time wise. The delivery guy was friendly enough and everything was correct with the order. The chicken parm sandwich was the best of the meal with a hearty bread, zesty tomato sauce and well seasoned chicken. The calamari was a bit over fried and the breading was a bit heavy, more like a mozzarella stick than calamari. I am always too afraid to say «well fried» or «lightly fried» to places since if it’s too fried its not great and if it’s under fried it’s too squidy for me.
The pizza slice was just average. It wasn’t under cooked but for something so saucy like BBQ and then heavy like chicken chunks it needed to be a bit more cooked or a stiffer dough to hold everything up. The flavor was also lacking and the chicken wasn’t very hot. Somehow the pizza was though.
I was just visiting Harlem so I couldn’t order again but if I did live here I would likely just keep browsing different pizza shops. This is fine enough, nothing great to keep me loyal to just them. The pricing is pretty okay though.

Bad pizza. I was completely misled by the 4-​star rating on Unilocal.
The pizza that I ordered (Pepperoni & Mushroom) tasted like the dough portion had been baked/​ovened prior to the toppings. It was like my pizza was a party that my toppings weren’t invited to until it was halfway over. The dough portion was nearly rock hard while the toppings were undercooked. It was like the dough portion and topping portion were on two different time zones.
However, I’m a reasonable man so I gave Pizza Stop Eating Here (yes, this IS the full name of this place) a second chance… same results, nearly identical to my first experience!
The best part of this pizza was the end of it. I’m not talking about the crust, but the experience being over.
My recommendation would be Victorio’s Pizza on 145^th, which deserves this 4 star rating much more than this establishment.

Pizza is pretty ok. Just don’t get deep dish. Those were tasteless. The regular pies are pretty good. Nice lunch special for the pizza, not sure why the other things on the menu are under a lunch special: they take forever to prepare and are pretty expensive.
Staff isn’t the most friendly if they don’t know U, they make it pretty known they want your $ and aren’t too concerned with being friendly. But whatever, it’s a pizza place.
Worth the pizza.

This is the pizza place we order from when we are with family in Harlem. The delivery service is fast and reliable. The food always arrives on time and piping hot. Pizza is standard but still tasty and fresh. Pizza Stop is perfect for a quick slice on the go as well.

Damn! This pizza is GOOD! And I’m a bit of a pizza snob.
I am fortunate to live only a few blocks away and pass it every time I walk to/​from the train. I eat at least one slice a week. When friends come over, we always order a pie. Just freaking delicious.
I’ve also had their garlic knots, which are good, and their mozzarella sticks, which are generic (basically just frozen and fried).
The guys who work there are funny and nice. They eventually get to know you if you come by regularly.
But, really, you come here for the PIZZA!

I always got delicious pizza from here but omg I tried the pasta and is absolute divine. I’m literally hooked on the flavor and freshness they offer here. The service is quick and the guys are mega friendly especially Lenny and Chris… Tell them I sent you …Best pizza and pasta in Harlem!

This is one of the best options this side of Harlem has to offer when it comes to a basic slice of pizza. Their grandma pies are their best offering and I’ve tried almost all of their pizza pie configurations.
Once was told that their pasta dishes arent made from house made pasta and that was quite disappointing. I can count on them to deliver a consistently good pie without worry, until I find a place that can serve better I’ll keep ordering from here.
The kiddos love it and I cant blame them! Delivery is prompt and quick without a hitch!

Some of the best pizza I’ve had in the city in terms of price and quality. Always a delicious option to grab a slice to go. Ordered delivery once and they were a little slow, but it was still good.
Love having this spot two blocks away.