Steve’s Ice Cream

Never tried any high end ice cream before so I thought I would give Steve’s a try. I try and eat organic and use healthy ingredients when possible so I’m willing to pay a little more to get what I want. I also live in the city where anything like steves would be triple the price.
The ice cream here just tastes fresh. They encourage you to sample so after a few tasters I went with the Caramel. Customer service was also on point so all in all I will definitely be coming back.

This was the worst bourbon vanilla I’ve ever experienced. At $ 6.99 a pint I expected it to taste amazing, but all the so called natural flavor taste artificial. Total waste of money.

I bought the Steve’s Salty Carmel chocolate flavor:) It has a great taste with a smooth even temperature not too strong but just right:) For the price being on the higher end the ingredients are better quality and richer! The Carmel was spectacular as for the ice cream was good and has a unique flavor a wholesome organic taste:) Their other flavors I want to try!

I really wanted to like this ice cream.
I was craving salted caramel, so I splurged ($ 6.99) because I thought it would be amazing (and they were out of Hagen Das’ dulce de leche).
Opened it and it looks majestic, but the grittiness is too much. I wonder if it’s just this batch, but I’m pretty sure ice cream shouldn’t be this gritty. Especially coming from a «ultra high-​end» ice creamery.
The salted Carmel swirl is amazing tho!
Not sure if I’ll make the same splurge again :(

So I tried the Mexican Chilli Chocolate at the insistence of a good friend of mine. Being the foodie that I am I obliged her. First I wasn’t that happy about the fact that once I removed the lid the ice cream was exposed. I thought that after removing the lid I should have been met by some protective film… I am highly paranoid and have seen people opening containers and returning goods after.
The ice cream had a nice rich chocolate flavour the texture was smooth. I tasted he chocolate and then the chilli flavour came in. The chilli made me want to have another spoonful so that I could reacquaint my taste buds with the sweet chocolate which I did. This pattern became cyclical, the more I ate the more I could taste the kick in the pepper which in turn led to me wanting to eat more ice cream to cool my mouth.
It is definitely a must try. I haven’t finished the tub yet hence verdict is out as to whether I would buy again. This may just be one of those foodie things I try once, appreciate and then move on to the next new thing.

Not an ice cream store. Came here and got harassed by the security guards before they let me know it’s just their office. This shouldn’t have a Unilocal page.

Winner of the overall best artisanal ice cream shop in Brooklyn.
We served the Mexican Chili Chocolate at the ice cream bar during our 2013 Brooklyn wedding reception (I am anti wedding cake — it is NEVER good) and we *still* hear from our guests regarding that flavor!
My favorites:
Mexican Chili Chocolate
NOLA Iced Coffee and Donuts (surprised that it was so good)

Best ice cream I’ve ever had, and it was made with coconut cream, not dairy, which was a nice surprise. Ate the whole tub in one sitting because delicious.
Oh, and it was delivered to me for free by postmates, so even better.

Extremely disappointed in this company. My package came damaged, the lids were all off and half of the icecream was melted. Customer service is non existent… took several calls and facebook posting to get a response. One of their people got back to me offering a full refund and a replacement shipment on them. However, the replacement never came and honestly I didn’t care about their product at that point so I didn’t bother pursing it. Much better icecream out there in my opinion and i’d rather give my money to a company appreciative of it.

This is actually their corporate office but they still have a retail section they sell pints out of. All I can say is omg. So. Good.
We got the Blackout and the Banana Pudding and the flavors were amazing. Definitely will repurchase.

When I was a little girl, we lived in a very small town in NC and I loved black cherry ice cream. In the evenings after work, my dad would stop by the corner store and bring a cup home to me. It was one of the most memorable nostalgic times of my youth. Yesterday, I was in Whole Foods and a girl was sampling some of the ice creams. I don’t do dairy so I asked if she had any of that sort. She handed me the blackberry honey and I was blown away by the flavor. It tasted just like that delicious homemade black cherry ice cream my dad use to bring home to me. It really made me smile. My dad committed suicide 15 years ago so this is very sentimental to me. I immediately bought a container and spent the afternoon eating it reminiscing about my dad and the good times we shared. Not to sound cliché, but these products really are making people smile.

I have finally found my new favorite ice cream! Steve, I don’t know who you are but you are the man! This stuff is so creamy and delicious. The flavors are incredible! My personal favorite is the BKLYN Blackout which is milk chocolate ice cream swirled with chocolate stout cake pieces and dark chocolate pudding… like, are you kidding me!!! INSANE! If you see this stuff in your supermarket, pick it up, iit’s literally to die for!

I want so badly to give this place a better review because my first experience (Salty Caramel) was so very delicious, but, unfortunately, my more recent experience with Bourbon Pecan Pie was quite terrible. I really don’t know how to describe what was wrong with the ice cream, but it seemed to be lacking all sense of creaminess. Someone please tell me that this was just a one-​off.

I’m a total dessert fiend and I absolutely love any of Steve’s flavors.
My favorite right now is the Bourbon Vanilla.
The contrast of boozy and sweet reminds me of my grandmother’s bread pudding with whiskey sauce.