The Dylan

NYC is definitely the most expensive place in the US to live. I’ve lived in LA, SF, DC and NYC seriously ranks up there. Here’s how I’d break it down:
PROS:
+floor to ceiling windows for great lighting (corner unit)
+very responsive staff — fixes get done on the daily
+small /​boutique feel
+very nice roof top lounge (indoor /​outdoor — outdoor has grills) — great views of city
+24 hr gym + basketball court
+easy package notification
+super clean
+newly built lux building (2 – 3 yrs old)
+allows for break leases
+rent stabilized
+in unit washer/​dryers
+3 blks to 6 or 34^th street metro + path lines + empire state blg (good in summer but not in winter.:o)
+no pet fee
+close to flatiron /​chelesa — silicon alley
+full gas stove
CONS:
+EXTREMELY EXPENSIVE (new+washer/dryer+boutique)
+layout doesn’t use its space well
+very basic bathroom
+cabinets are not self closing
+thin walls. you can hear everything happening in the hallways
+small closets
+nearby construction
+very busy area
+not very close to groceries — you have to head over to chelsea for trader joe’s + whole foods
+gym is extra $ 40/​month … although some people are nice to just let you in
+no parking garage
+heater has clanking noises that never fully resolved
+doors and cabinets are really really high (high ceilings) — making it difficult to get things w/​o a chair
+not a lot of diversity of eats around the immediate area unless you mostly want korean or indian food
+for me, it was so minimalistic that it was hard to feel homey.
Overall, the staff is great and unfortunately this is the going price for a place with these amenities. But personally, I was just not in love with it… and in terms of bang for the buck — keep cost a little lower by heading to kip’s bay/hell’s kitchen /​upper west or east side.

I lived at The Dylan for almost 2 years (first resident in my unit) and could not recommend it more. The management (Amy and Jose) is top notch, extremely responsive, and strives to keep the residents happy. The Midtown location is convenient, the amenities are great (beautiful rooftop deck, lounge, basketball court, gym), the apartments are well-​appointed, and the online services for paying rent, requesting services, reserving the facilities, etc. are all very useful. Additionally, the other residents, doormen, and porters are extremely pleasant.
There was an intermittent issue with rogue smokers in this non-​smoking building, but management has been working hard to clamp down on these delinquent offenders. That is my only negative feedback on the building, though I can’t offer any constructive advice to management on how else to solve for bad resident behavior. I encountered these cockroach-​like smoker types (knowingly dropping ashes on people’s patio furniture) in another non-​smoking NYC luxury apartment building, so it’s certainly not unique to The Dylan.

I only lived here for 3 months but I have to say the staff was wonderful, friendly and helpful and I can’t say enough for Amy and Jose in the leasing office, they were great!
The building is well maintained and feels more like living in a boutique hotel

I’ve lived here for a year and a half and really have enjoyed this experience. The staff have been very friendly and professional. The building goes above and beyond by providing numerous free services like breakfast in the lobby and several parties throughout the year. In addition the views are phenomenal and the amenities are A+.
I live in an A-​line apartment that a couple of the reviews have mentioned and I dealt with the clanking issue last year. The building was very helpful and sent numerous techs to look at the problem and ultimately fix it. I have not heard any clanking noise in over a year from my heating unit. I don’t know why other apartments are having trouble as the building communicated with me clearly and concisely and did their best efforts to fix the problem. I look forward to staying at this building.

I’ve been here now for 5 months and I absolutely love it.
I was completely surprised at how great this building was, when I stumbled in looking at apartments in the nomad area. All things considered, it’s a pretty low key building tucked away off of 5^th.
I’ve lived in a few DM/​lux buildings in the city and what sets these guys apart from the rest is the team. The staff is A+. Can’t find a better group of folks to onboard you, welcome you on a daily basis and help fix any issue that comes up. They do it with a smile and that’s hard to do when you’re in the service industry.
The 24hr Gym is a huge plus and the rooftop BBQ grills are a huge plus. Windows are double pane and do a great job of sealing noises too.
My last point: There’s no such thing as a perfect building. Things happen, fridge’s leak, heat/​ac units need a tweak here and there — but that happens everywhere. It’s all about how the building responds to this stuff and these guys do great.
Last tip: 9^th and 27^th floor have almost 12 ft ceilings. Makes a huge difference.

Perfect spot for a party. Attended a birthday here and the rooftop view was incredible! Everything was tastefully decorated and maintained. After viewing a unit there, I was already planning on when I could feasibly move in! Would recommend for anyone needing a luxury space to live to a breathtaking party space on the rooftop.

Have lived here for about a year and four months and have nothing but the best things to say about the building and staff. Have had such a positive experience since the day we moved in. The apartments are beautiful, brand new everything, floor to ceiling windows, great views of the city. Washer dryers in every apt! The staff is beyond friendly and helpful. Work orders are taken care of immediately and the building is kept in perfect condition. Not your average NYC management company!

The front desk staff is helpful and the apartment itself is nice, but the building has a serious smoking problem. Management has been notified multiple times of residents violating the non-​smoking rule, but they have not done anything other than send out several emails reminding residents that the building is non-​smoking. The smoke comes through vents in the bathrooms and heating units. Residents in the apartments with patios have also complained numerous times about lit cigarette butts being thrown out the windows and landing on the patio.
Another major issue with the building is the wait time for elevators. Even when both elevators are functioning, the wait time is quite long. However, one of the elevators is often out of use during high traffic times. I have personally experienced wait times over ten minutes.
Lastly, my neighbors and I have complained about loud clanking noises made by the brand new heaters. Management has acknowledged that this is an issue across the building. I have not received any information indicating that they have fixed the issues or will be doing so.

I’ve lived here for about 5 months and can’t say enough positive things about the building. It’s brand new and the apartments are spacious, beautiful and comfortable. I love the floor to ceiling windows and the roof top views are amazing.
Having lived in luxury apartments in NYC previously, the staff is what sets this building apart from the rest. Each and every person you meet is so nice and helpful, and they go the extra mile to make you feel right at home. Definitely check out this building if you’re looking for a nice place in midtown.