J & F Pizzeria

All I’ve had is the Italian sub so far, but it was solid. Just a classic salami, provolone, ham sandwich with cheese and oil and vinegar. It was really large, the bread was fresh, cost around $ 10 for a large one and a drink.

I used to really like J&F Pizza when I was a teenager living in Newburgh over 20 years ago. I went to Newburgh yesterday to spend the day with family and figured I stop in for some pizza and a salad. We stood there waiting 15 minutes for someone to notice us standing at the counter because they were to busy with their to go orders which obviously seemed more important. While standing there the young guy taking the to go orders turned his backside to us and I gasped. His pants were hanging off his backside as a lot of kids wear their pants these days but is totally inappropriate in a place of business. Not that it’s not inappropriate on the street but sheesh what employer would allow their employee to be dressed like that. I wished I had just walked out as I had intended to do after standing there that long. Finally the older gentleman took our order. I ordered a tossed salad for myself and a single slice for my mother to go. Well tossed salad is the exact name for it because after 2 bites I threw it in the trash. The tomatoes were those barely ripe tomatoes that you encounter in the supermarket that you have to ask is that a tomato because it barely resembles one. The italian dressing tasted like rubbing alcohol or what I would imagine it would taste like if I had ever drank it. I mean come on you can go to the supermarket and buy a Good Seasons Cruet with the seasonings to make italian dressing that tastes good for around 3 dollars… My mom said the pizza was ok but that’s her code for I don’t want to complain but I didn’t really care for it. Besides the fact it looked nothing like the J&F Pizza I had growing up. These appeared to be totally new owners because I didn’t recognize any person. Either that or my memory’s going but I’m only 41 so I hope not… lol Needless to say I will never go there again. Its a shame because J&F Pizza used to be a really good pizza place. Also they should really maybe sweep the sidewalk too. If your running a business why would you want customers to step over cigarette butts as they walk in to eat. Disgusting!!! I don’t care who put them there or if you have to sweep 10 times a day. Take pride in your business and what it represents!!!

Their peppers and onion Pizza is delicious! I haven’t had much else from there in years so I will reserve my comments on dinners for a later date.

It’s all about the food here. Old school and consistently good. Pizza sauce is sweet and delicious. Cannot go wrong with any of the subs or entrees here. If you want atmosphere go elsewhere

This is usually our go to place for a great sandwich at even a better price… But today not a good experience at all, maybe even my last… A sandwich ($ 6) 2 soups ($ 7) and 4 mozz sticks ($ 2) came out to 24… Not even bc there is a delivery charge should it be that much…

it’s pizza, not my favorite but not bad. It has a great local reputation but maybe I should have tried a sandwich. We didn’t sit and eat so I have no comment on the location other than it’s convenient to work.

This is one of my favorite places to visit whenever I go back to NY (I moved 13 years ago). On my last visit (in July), they remembered my usual order, even though I hadn’t been there since December. I was impressed by this. The people that work there are usually friendly, which is important for any business.
Their pizza is pretty good. It tends to be a little greasy for my taste, but some people like that. I do love their subs (both hot and cold). The bread is perfect-​not crunchy or burned, or flimsy.
The service is quick. The food is usually brought to the table within a reasonable amount of time (if you dine in) or is ready to be taken out the door as quickly as possible. Of course the speed depends on what you’ve ordered. If you are getting a whole pie or a larger order, you may need to wait a little longer.
The inside of J&F isn’t great. One side has older plastic booths, and the other has nicer tables and chairs and is more of a sit down and enjoy your meal type atmosphere. I think the side with thr booths is more for those picking up a to-​go order, still it would be nice if both sides of the place were updated. It would look more cohesive and updated.

Average pizza, service is okay, and selection is decent. The rest rooms need to be condemned though.