Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

Poorly run. Very busy not enough help. Waitresses would rather flirt with a guy at the bar than wait on patrons. My order is done sitting in the window for 10 minutes and still can’t get a server to pack it up to go. The food is ok here but not worth the wait or noise level unless your a guy just coming to drink and flirt with the staff. Got my food home which is 5 minutes away and the wings are barely warm and the appetizer is greasy. Won’t be back!

This is not a rating on Johnny’s Pizza as a whole since I know they are franchised. This particular location is hit or miss. I have had decent food and then I have had times where I got a Cesar with slimy brown lettuce or burned pizza. The owner is very, VERY rude. Too many pizza places in the area to support this kind of establishment.

One of my favorite places to go in Newnan and definitely my favorite pizza shop in town. Picking up or dining in you can’t go wrong. It’s great for both a single meal or feeding a group of people. Ordering by the slice is great, whatever topping you want on it they load it up and the slices themselves are huge, it’s great for the price. Other than pizza they have good salads, appetizers, calzones, and stromboli. Some of my favorites here are the veggie deluxe, the garlic knots, fried pickles, and jalapeño poppers. It’s a great and affordable place
Food: ⁴⁄₅
Atmosphere: ⁴⁄₅
Service: ⁴⁄₅
Cleanliness: ⁴⁄₅

Great food. Pizza with artichokes and sundried tomatoes was fabulous! Our waitress was a little ditzy and slow but nice. Great spinach salad too.

Best pizza place in town — hands down. The place is always exceptionally clean. The food is delicious. My favorite pizza from there is one with all the meats plus mushrooms and black olives.

Hubby and I were on the way back from a meeting and thought we would grab a quick slice and Greek salad.
The food was awesome!
We just got cheese pizza to keep it light but it was tasty.
And I love that they give you a NY style size slice.
We got a small salad which came in the standard size Styrofoam which was pretty good.
Salad was just what you would expect a greek salad to be.
Im glad there are some decent pizza places in the area. Being from Duluth ga by way of New york I def am a pizza snob.
Satisfied customer keep it up!

One of the best franchise locations of the Johnny’s Pizza chain.
Crust is always done just right with the right amount of crisp on the outside but still with the chew on the inside.
Toppings are always top quality. They don’t skimp on the cheese and the orders always come out timely.
I would recommend to anyone.

Pizza was ok.
Salads are big and fresh.
Calzone is freaking huge and delicious.

I ordered wings tonight thinking they would be decent considering this is a pretty we’ll know place. We’ll once they were delivered I was very disappointed. The chicken was tough, low quality meat. The hot sauce had no flavor. I was only able to eat two just to see it it was only the first wing. So I called the restaurant back to ask for a pizza replacement and all they could offer is a credit for 20 wings. When I asked to use this credit to order a pizza for delivery they said they are done delivering tonight, 5 minutes before the delivery cut off. This is really sorry customer service and food quality. I will never order from these guys again. We’ll except for my credit, but definitely never wings again!

The food is great. The atmosphere is fine. The service when you get in is decent. More than once I have been put on permanent hold by the people who work there when trying to place an order.

Great pizza — staff is friendly. In town for business and found this place and decided to check it out. If I’m back I will definitely come back.

Have been several times in the last two months. Food is always cooked to order and very good. Staff is friendly and attentive. Great neighborhood restaurant and bar. Keep it up.

Great food, love the music, nice date place or dine along.

I understand that these restaurants are franchised, so let me first say I love Johnny’s Pizza.
This location gets 1 star because of terrible customer service and rudeness. My husband walked in one evening — 7:30/8:00 — for a slice and a glass of wine. He seats himself in a booth. One of the staff asks him to move to the other side of the restaurant because that section was closed. So he moves to a booth on the other side. After that, 10 minutes went by with no one stopping to take a drink order, say hello — nothing. The restaurant was empty and two waitresses were behind the counter talking. At that point he got up and left.
Don’t waste your money here; its worth driving to the Peachtree City location for a pleasant experience and a decent slice!