Gagster’s

Needed a place to grab a bite on the way back from Niagara Falls ON and Gagsters came up on Unilocal with good reviews. When we pulled up we weren’t sure if were going to stay, the area is a little tough, but I’m so glad we did. Wings were good, pizza turnover was AMAZING! We sat next to a couple that’s been going there for 25 years. They had the stuffed hot pepper pizza, which looked so good that I can’t wait to go back.

Beer, Pizza and Wings. how can this get any better! We were visiting Niagara Falls and were told to go into Buffalo to have the wings, but family recommended this little hole in the wall just 15 minutes from where we were staying across the bridge. First off we had a very large group (10 people mix of adults and kids) and the waitress was fantastic. She was on cue, always checking in on us and getting drinks, and a constant supply of water. The beer list was typical east coast dive bar so we ordered a bucket of Rolling Rock and the mildness of this beer goes perfect with the flavors of the wings, made me glad there wasnt a craft beer on tap… but maybe that’s just my nostalgia talking! Now on to the wings, make sure you order them extra crispy, I am gonna try asking for this on the west coast and see what they say. maybe its just a NY thing? Either way, they were awesome! Big drumsticks and wings covered in a delicious buffalo sauce. We ordered the traditional Hot and Medium and they had the proper amount of heat and tanginess. Then we got adventurous and ordered the garlic parmesan and honey ginger. The honey ginger was just ok, not bad but I prefer that flavor with my noodles vs wings, but the garlic parmesan knocked my socks off! I never order the dry rubs but I would order this flavor over and over again! So make sure you grab a couple on your next visit. Now onto the pizza. We ordered a large traditional cheese and pepperoni and it came square cut with a nice thick homemade crust. It was so yummy and made me long to live closer to a place like this! You guys in Niagara Falls NY are a lucky bunch!

Service was great! The waitress was awesome and running around checking on all her tables. We had wings, which were SO good, and a large pie. The pizza was amazing! We did find it odd they didnt have green peppers, but we are from out of town so maybe thats the thing here? All in all it was a great experience. Would definitely come back!

My husband and I have been eating low carb for a while and decided to fulfill a craving and order pizza and wings from Gangsters after reading many high rated reviews.
We ordered a half tray cheese pizza, 30 crisp wings done in three different sauces; medium, barbecue and honey garlic, cheesy garlic bread and beans and greens soup.
The pizza was just OK. Thick crust, slightly sweet sauce and plenty of cheese. The crust was slightly under done. There was no golden brown color on the bottom, and it was slightly doughy.
The wings were horrible. We always order our wings crisp, and they were nothing near that. Although the wings were cooked through the skin was soggy. And the sauces, yuck!
Medium sauce taste more like butter and heat. No real flavor.
Barbecue was a cheap quality barbecue sauce. Not saucy at all.
And lastly, the honey garlic had absolutely no garlic flavor. All we could taste was sweet, sticky honey.
The best, was the cheesy garlic bread. Plenty of buttery garlic flavor and cheese on nicely toasted Italian bread.
We didn’t even try the soup. With disliking most of the meal, we didn’t even want to chance it.
We definitely will not be going back.

Best Pizza in the World: End of Story.
Get the steak sub pizza– it will change your life. Also some of the best wings you’ll ever have. The staff = awesome.

I love this place the salad is my favorite their dressing is amazing! The pizza is home made dough and fresh toppings. Wings are always crispy and great sauces I would recommend the Mr. C pizza with greens truly the best

Best place for authentic Buffalo wings hands down. I have been going for years and have never been disappointed. Pizza especially white Mr. C’s is also delicious and we always order a ice cold bucket of Rolling Rock splits. Perfect with the wings!
Price is good and portions are huge!

Not too many beers on tap and they are only open for dinner!
Neighborhood pub… the bartenders recognizes all the people in the area.
HONEY GARLIC WINGS WERE SO YUM. THEIR SPICY WINGS and PIZZA TURNOVER ARE ALSO GOOD.
This is a go to spot now given that Duff’s now has franchises and the quality is not the same!

Gagsters used to be my favourite wing and pizza place in Niagara Falls, NY. The pizza and wings are still great but the staff, well that part of the experience unfortunately doesn’t equal the food experience.
First off. You are greeted… sometimes by two grouchy women. They must be the owners’ wife and mother. My guess. They always sit on their butts and sometimes watch what is happening in the restaurant. Most of the time they are just sitting playing on their iPads.
The next thing is the staff. Some of them are gems, if you get the right one. The remainder are just lazy. There seems to be 1 server for every two tables. Many of them just stand around outside the restaurant waiting for their orders and people to come in.
Gagsters used to be busy every Friday and Saturday. The last few times it has been very quiet. Looks like the Canadians who used to consume the parking spots are not coming over.
The experience of the restaurant starts with the support staff. They just seem to take their lead from the two women sitting on their iPads.
We won’t be going back to Gagsters for quite some time. Time to check out some other pizza and wing places in the area.

Had dinner here after participating in their 22^nd Annual Golf Tournament. They have a large outdoor special event dining area that is covered and lighted which is great for large groups. As for the restaurants menu I am unable to comment on since my meal was part of our groups «family style» menu but if the quality of food is anything like that of which we had it must be excellent.

I love this place! Excellent service and the best wings and other food in the town! Highly recommended!

I was searching for Buffalo Wings in Niagara Falls. I saw a few reviews on this place and decided to check it.
I was surprised that I had driven by this place many times and never really noticed it. It actually sit off of Pine Street on East Market, but is more identifiable as across from the McDonalds in the parking lot.
I expected the inside too be much larger than what it was. There is a bar upon entering and an «small» dining area.
I decided to do takeout. The menu had some decent items and it took me a few minutes to choose, as I stood at the bar. The staff was helpful and attentive and helped me and making a selection. They were very friendly as well.
I ultimately decided on the Medium Buffalo Wings and a Personal Pan. As I waited I watched the Sabres game on the television. Several people left there table and watched the game as well.
Many complimented the food that they had and told me I would enjoy mine.
They were right! I found the wings too be some of the best that I have had in Niagara Falls. They were well done and seasoned right. My wife enjoyed them as well, giving them thumbs up.
The person pizza was fillling and with the wings, we shared are were aptly full. The pizza had the right amount of sauce, cheese and pepperonis. We were surprised at the quality of the personal pizza since it is a relativel inexpensive item on the menu.
Overall it was a great experience.

What a great place. Cold beer, awesome wings, friendly staff. All of their friends and family are drawn as these ridiculous charicatures and plastered all over the walls. A good tip; if you are thinking of going hotter, go for it. Mild is basically a plain (crispy, tasty, perfect) wing.

great pizza! great prices. fun atmosphere. friendly service.