Gil’s Pizzeria

Had a cheese, pepperoni, mushroom pizza and a single order of wings. Medium, saucey. Wings were excellent. The flavor was right on. Puzza was really good with the pepperoni a little charred on the edges. Ordered it with the semi — sauce. Flavor was good but needed more sauce. Just a touch dry. I would definitely order my pizza saucey too.

Great pizza and excellent wings… Love the options for the pizza, crust, sauce and pepperoni options. The service is good as well. Very reasonable prices.

My boyfriend and I decided to order pizza from here after seeing a special offered online: mention facebook and get free fried dough and a 2 liter of pop.
We got a cheese and mushroom pizza and wings as well. You have the choice between sweet and traditional sauce and we went with sweet which was solid but now I’m curious how the traditional tastes. The pizza was very good but more mushrooms would have made it perfect! The crust was chewy and enjoyable dipped in bleu cheese.
The fried dough was dripping with grease… definitely ok as a freebie but I would never go there for it. They wrote «fried dizough» on the box which we found hilarious!
I cannot comment on the wings as a vegetarian I did not try them. My man loved them though.
Delivery was prompt and the deliverer was friendly. I will order from here again if in the area.
Support local business!!!

We moved to North Tonawanda 2 years ago, and in that time I haven’t found too many pizzas that I was impressed with AT ALL in the area. But, someone turned me on to Gil’s this week, so when my kids asked for pizza for dinner, I gave it a whirl. Ordered a large pizza with their sweet sauce (I guess they have sweet, semi-​sweet, and traditional) & 20 wings. Pizza was great!!! The wings could have been hotter, as I ordered them hot, but they were tasty! And the blue cheese was homemade (I am assuming) and was just how I like it. Definitely found my pizzeria after a long quest.

Had a few good meals here.
Also had some bad meals here.
It works when I’m in a pinch and they have a couple good specials that they run weekly.
With all the great pizza places nearby it’s tough to justify ordering from here.

We found this place because it was late at night and we couldn’t find another pizza delivery. We ordered a pepperoni and a Canadian bacon with pineapple pizza. Both were phenomenal. The pepperoni may have been the best I have ever had.

We were sad when Supreme Subs (used to be here) changed owners and lost their amazing quality. Now, years later, we were in the neighbourhood and decided to give it one last try.
We were glad we went! Amazing all around.
Hospitality was amazing for such a small place.
The food was exceptional! Reminded me of those good olé’ Supreme days!
Will be going back there for sure!
Keep it up guys!

I started out wondering why in the world the pizza was taking so long to arrive, but I now know why. If every advancement in human history was to engender this pizza into existence I would be perfectly content. This pizza must have been passed down as a family recipe through the generations; though the original recipe was most likely created by god himself. This pizza made my Niagara Falls experience fantastic, but enough about the mediocre waterfalls and more about this pizza. In fact, quality pizza such as this is more rare than the beautiful group of waterfalls that can be found here. I may dedicate my life and all the fruits of my labors to ensure all mankind can experience quality and heaven within the circumference of 18 inches. After more consideration Gil may be God himself. Thank you Gil, you are truly an inspiration and I will follow you blindly.