Pizza Plus

Not worth the time or money spent here. The service is terrible. The girl behind the counter was unpleasant and seemed annoyed that we were there. She mumbled everything and seemed exasperated when asked to repeat what she said. Then she disappeared right as we were about to order. Then 10 min after we ordered two gyros she informed us that we could only get one of them and that we’d have to order something else that was the same price as a gyro… then minutes later asked if we still wanted two gyros. The food itself was dry but OK. It came cut in half after being wrapped in foil so there were chunks of foil throughout the sandwich. Will not be returning.

From the chicken to the pizza to the pasta dinners the food is always great. Sam the owner works hard and takes good care of his customers. I’m here almost every other day and never a bad meal. Give it a try, you won’t be dissapointed!

24 tenders and a large order of spuds with cheese were ordered. The tenders were very big and there might have been more than 24. The atomic and nuclear sauces were on half. The atomic was solid as well as the nuclear. The nuclear sauce was hotter than usual, which I was not a fan of, but they were still very good.
The spuds were good. The cheese was on the side. The fries had a nice crisp to them and there were plenty as well.

We love the chicken tenders from here and come here often for those. Pizza is just average though.

I’m not a fanboy if this place, the prices are a bit higher than expected and not much room to sit.
But
And there’s a big but.
By far, consistently, unimaginably the best halal chicken wings I’ve ever had.
Who thought this hole in the wall could produce such magnificence?
Don’t dine out, eat in, you get more sauce and wings are crispy and tender at the same time.
I go with nuclear, and even their pizza is surprisingly good, don’t know why people don’t talk about that.
I don’t go with sandwiches, I’ve tried them — I wouldn’t recommend them, you should go to the front, get a coupon for a pizza and wings combo and do that. They have fried chicken now too which is pretty good too, but the wings.
The but is the wings.

Nuclear traditional wings and bbq buffalo wings here are really good, sauced well but heat level could be higher… heard these are the best in town, maybe we’ll dine in instead of taking them home and they’ll taste better, more fresh and more crispy rather than soggy. Flavor was on point though.

I’ve never been here in person but I have ordered from here a couple of times and will never order from here again.
Menu wise it is about the same as any other mediocre at best pizzerias in the area. Pizza, wings, mozzarella sticks, etc.
First the pizza: it is okay, at best. One of the problems is that it is very inconsistent. It can be fairly good one time and terrible the next. One thing it is consistent with is that it is greasy, very greasy. The sauce is often too sweet and the crust doesn’t have the crunch that you would want from a good pizza. When you deliver it often arrives cold as well, maybe it is our distance from the restaurant but that is not acceptable.
Wings: Greasy, tough and the sauce is okay. I was disappointed with the wings, the sauce doesn’t have the right amount of flavor or spice and most of it is grease.
Everything else: The corn nuggets are great, get them.
Delivery: It is often the same person that delivers and he is rude. We forgot to put our building number in a couple of times and he scolded me for it even though he had been to our place a couple of times. He acted as though he was doing us a favor delivering our food.
Overall: There are better, but not great, places that you can order from instead so do that.

Pizza Plus … What? A side order of gross?
When we first moved here in 2009, we found a flyer and ordered delivery fried chicken — pretty good. Delivery is a different experience from visiting the place … Hygiene is sketchy at best.
The pizza is borderline, bland, and lifeless. They serve it in huge wedges in a vain attempt to make up for the lack of flavor.
Fries are greasy and soggy.
The worst part, is that on the chicken front, there has been a huge drop in quality over the past couple of years. As another reviewer stated, it’s as if they are pre-​cooking and re-​heating wings for delivery — they are tough, greasy, and taste incredibly over-​salted.
WARNING! They advertise «Cluck U» chicken — but it’s not. They merely apply a dab of Cluck U sauce to their own, disappointing, chicken offerings.

First time we got pizza here it was just excellent. Next time it was a little underdone… not uncooked, but not as toasty and melty as it should be. It is very inexpensive. Good sauce. And the staff is just so friendly, unlike most pizza places around here. Third time we got a veggie pizza. Lots of toppings, very hot fresh and tasty, but needed more sauce.
A really interesting feature is the range of sizes. Bar/​personal, medium, large (typical for take out pizza) for only $ 10.99, and FAMILY SIZE (24″ diameter… more than double the area of a large pizza) for $ 19.99. I don’t think we’ll be getting that too often unless we have company, but it is a great option to have instead of buying two pizzas. The veggie large was about $ 17 but worth it… all fresh except jarred mushrooms (and canned black olives of course).
One downside is the very tiny and very busy «parking lot» (two spaces and a side driveway) off a very heavily travelled street.

The pizza was okay — nothing amazing — but good enough. The crust was pretty floury which I don’t mind eating, but it’s annoying to feel on my hands. However, the onion rings were awful. Very soft and rubbery texture, as if they were microwaved out of a freezer bag shipped from a food supply warehouse. I’m not sure if I would order from here again, but the meal wasn’t all that bad!

The buffalo wings used to be very good however it appears they are precooking them and the meat is black inside. Wings are very hard. Pizza is still very good.
My girlfriends office ordered and had the same experience with the wings. Hope the change back to making them fresh to order.

The pizza quite frankly is not very good here. I had an awful experience with the delivery on two occasions as well. One of their delivery men is rude beyond believe. For some reason where I live they never seem to want to go to the front door always to the garage door so they always call ahead of time. On this occasion I happen to be outside on my cell phone smoking a cigarette, the guy did not even get out of his car with the food simply handed the food right out of his car window causing me to juggle the food. I should have not even bothered tipping. On another occasion I ordered a small salad with dressing on the side, a pink lemonade, and the fried flounder. The food arrives and I find out the dressing is not on the side it is placed on the salad, they apparently did not have the pink lemonade so they placed instead a Snapple Fruit Punch, and the piece of flounder was so small it was not worth the money it cost. I called to complain and they said they would send a new salad with dressing on the side and a different drink. The guy was rather nasty and even said I would have to send back the salad with the dressing on it along with the drink even though it was there mistake. He said sorry but did nothing to keep my business at all. It took me half an hour to get the new salad and the driver demanded I give him the drink and salad back which you know they can not resell the salad. I will never be ordering from them again. There are far better pizza places closer.

I’ve lived around here for a very long time and I’ve had pizza from pretty much everywhere in the immediate area, and this place is definitely the best. The pizza is consistent. The texture is perfect each time. It’s not oily and disgusting, and it never falls apart when you pick it up. I wouldn’t say it’s ¹⁰⁄₁₀ perfect, but it’s damn good, and consistently so.
Also, this place serves more than just pizza; it serves Cluck-​U Chicken, great fries, chicken parm, and other things. Everything I’ve had so far is good. It’s a pizza place, yes, but you should give their other food a shot.
They also serve subs, but I’ve never had their subs, so I can’t comment on them.
I’m not sure how Nino’s gets so much love and how this place is virtually ignored. Maybe I just talk to too many people from the other side of North Brunswick. Everyone who knows about this place agrees that it’s the best pizza in the area.