This place sucks i gave them 2 chances and wont give them a 3rd the crust tazte like cardboard.
Jason D.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Cumming, GA
This area is lucky to have #1 New York Pizza. I enjoyed carry-out dinner and dine-in lunch the next say. Even the eggplant Parmesan to-go was good and that’s saying something. The Stromboli with a side of sauce for lunch was so good, I threw in a slice with sausage. I wish we had a place like this at home where I live.
Mary S.
I’m from New York, I know pizza and I admit I’m a bit of a pizza snob. I’m sorry. We stopped here simply due to the name and were astonished we found the #1 New York Pizza!!! Say what? On the back road of some Podunk Florida road we found the best NY pizza. I was skeptical but open to try it cause I enjoy pizza and trying other people attempts at NY style. Went inside to find a nice clean pizza place. Impressed that the pizza looked great sitting behind the glass on the counter. Ordered 2 slices and waited patiently. Pizza came out and I was actually impressed and ready to try it. First bite was just ok. Good amount of cheese, crust looked pretty good and the size was nice. After the first bite, it was evident that the sauce is not a big priority down here to this pizza joint. It was bland and tasteless. It seemed like the lack of good pizza sauce was more covered up by cheese. I added some spices and tried to fix it up, but good pizza needs some good sauce and STOPOVERDOINGTHECHEESE. Moderate cheese with good sauce. Cmon people. I’d try this place again and just be sure to say easy on the cheese and add a little more sauce.