Pepperoni Grill

I must say the wait is HORRIBLE. I’ve been there multiple times and every time the wait was hours.
However the food is amazing! There pizza is to die for. It’s the best pizza I’ve ever eaten in my life! It’s fantastic. Their food is pretty obviously homemade and fresh non store bought crap. It is amazing but the wait and staff aren’t all that great. If the food weren’t so redeeming I would have given one star.

Let me just say I have eaten here several times before, and enjoyed it. Always slow, but I can live with that. But I will not be back. After referring this restaurant to others, I guess I owe them an apology. My last trip, me and a friend stopped in for a pizza. There were 4 tables seated. Not exactly rush hour. We ordered a 12 inch pizza and wings. After 50 minutes our waiter arrived with a small mini pizza. I explained it was not what we ordered, and had no interest in waiting another hour. I just wanted to pay for our beers and go. The waiter apologized and said the food would be gratis. I chalked it up to a bad experience and would have been back. After a few minutes, a girl about 18 who apparently was the manager came over and said she would deduct 10% from our bill. I again said no thanks it wasnt what we ordered. She then had the audacity to tell me to just take the food, they were just gonna throw it in the garbage, as if it was my fault the whole experience sucked. Needless to say I didnt take the food and told her to throw it in the garbage. I have never been so insulted. I just wanted to eat a pizza, not be offered garbage scraps when I refused to be extorted for 90% of a meal I didnt order. She also insinuated it was the waiter who got it wrong, as if that resolved the issue and should just shut up and the two of us just eat the 5 inch pizza, no big deal right? Maybe if she spent more time overseeing the kitchen instead of flashing sonogram pictures all over the dining area while average wait on food on a slow night was 50 minutes, maybe our order would have been right. Sonograms and pizza… yum. if you like hour waits on food, several excuses when your food is wrong, and to be insulted and treated like trash when you have the nerve to refuse food you didnt order, then this is your place. If you want good service, food in a timely order, and want to be appreciated for deciding to spend your money in a restaurant, I suggest you avoid this place.

Horrible greasy food, staff was friendly but it looked like they just jumped up out of bed and came to work. No uniforms

Don’t judge a book by its cover
This place is way worse than it looks
Ordered a meatball hero took forever and cheese wasn’t even melted came with cold shredded cheese
The two patty melts came out and may have been okay they brought us a squeeze bottle of ketchup
Unfortunately it was filled with marinara which went over our burger and french fries
This was old marinara had not been refrigerated. My family became sick after eating
The woman manager, owner offered only to take two dollars off each patty melt
We stated that did not seem fair since the marinara ruined our meal.
She justified the four dollar discount because she had not charged us for fountain waters
When we initially brought the marinara and the squeeze bottle to her attention she said oh that’s my bad I grabbed the marinara instead of the ketchup. I will comp both your meals then only took off four dollars off.
For a Italian restaurant to put marinara into a squeeze bottle is shameful in the first place.
The Decour look like it was all bought at random at a garage sale or flea market
To use the restroom you must go outside and if it’s pouring rain. Oh we’ll you have to go around the building pass the to go window into the kitchen and use the employee restroom which is worse than a bathroom you may find at a slum lord building.
Also they have Coke advertisement all over the restaurant but only serve Pepsi
I suggest only going here if you need a sweet tea to go because the sweet tea was great.
I will continue to write more of a review however I have a bad case of diarrhea from eating at this restaurant. I must go!

This place was an entertaining find! It seems to be a favorite with the locals. I have family in the area, and enjoy exploring places that even they haven’t yet found. The day after Christmas was tricky; most places were closed. Pepperoni Grill wasn’t our first choice but it was open, and we were glad we came.
The décor is dark and rustic cozy; most of the surfaces are rough-​hewn wood, brickwork and stone. The architecture suggests that long ago it was once a smithy, general store loading dock or even a livery. It’s pretty small, but manages an 8×8 karaōke stage and about a dozen tables.
The sandwiches and wings were perfectly on point and will likely be the reason for return visits. The beef cheesesteaks and chicken cheesesteaks were loaded and delicious. The wings are available in several varieties and you can mix/​match. Our favorite wing was the mild, which is a hot sauce and ranch mix. Least favorite was the teriyaki — much too sweet (a garlic teriyaki could work, though). The thin-​crust pizza was only average; the thicker crust is probably much better.
Our server was very friendly and knowledgeable, eager to help us enjoy our visit.
There are things that have to improve for this place to get my four– or five-​star rating. A few small things, like the ugly menus and the tacky soda/​beer distributor swag hanging from the walls, are easily updateable. Parking is a problem, but not too serious. But those bathrooms — good lord. They are not accessible from the dining room; you have to go outside and around past the to-​go window and the kitchen entrance. I’ve seen nicer restrooms in the «employees only» area at tire stores. Even if I gave them a pass on cleanliness, the plumbing cannot possibly be up to code.
The good, however, far outweighs the bad. The food, décor, and service — but especially the sandwiches — were all reasons we were glad we came and why we will be back.