Rosati’s Pizza of Oconomowoc

Great pizza. Love the double crust. Great bar with good tap beer and consistently friendly service. A regular stop for us. Husband likes the angel hair pasta.

good pizza. my first time in wis and being a new yorker i say i was highly impressed. loved that drowning sauce that they spread on their pizza. good job!!!

we visited this place one night during the summer and they had free pizza out between 4:00 to 6:00 and it was the best, they only do this up to the first week in September, but its worth spending on half price martinis and half price appetizers, its just such good value for money if you cant afford much and an excellent standard. we have eaten in the restaurant too very good and nice staff too, they have a young man behind the Bar who has a terrific voice too he is always singing along with the music, great entertainment, good food.

Had dinner here on Sunday night. This place was busy and yet the waitress was very attentive. We ordered the house salad with Italian and the red pepper dressing on the side. The salad was fresh and the dressings both appeared to be made in house. The thin crust pizza was well cooked with a crunchy crust and a generous amount of cheese.

Holy cow I love this place. Try the Chicago Style Deep Dish with Italian sausage and Spinach. Really nice bar with good customer service. If your in the mood for pizza this is the spot!

After 9+ years of ordering delivery sometimes multiple times a week, generously tipping and spending thousands of dollars, we call for delivery and they won’t drive 7 miles because of the construction. So much for loyalty. Don’t most businesses bend over backwards to retain business. Not the owner or manager Andy. I’ve told all my neighbors and will continue to spread the word of disregard for loyalty. We have other options and will exercise them.
A one star rating because I couldn’t rate it 0.

Absolutely fabulous service (we sat in the bar area) and wonderfully delicious pizza. I had the thick crust one night and the thin another. Both are well prepared and flavorful.
Wednesdays are half off wine which makes dining out even better. Love it and can’t wait to go back next time I am in town.
cheers!

Went here on a last minute decision on Saturday night for pizza and to watch the Badgers play. Had the calamari (not so good) cheesy garlic bread (good) and pizza (good, would recommend). Our waiter could have used some more knowledge of the menu and just a little more polish, which comes with experience. They were super busy, but he still managed to take care of us.

Rosati’s is one of our favorite places to eat. The burgers and the garlic bread they bring on the side with their entrees is excellent. The pasta, the antipasti salad and the lemon-​drop martinis are very good. (They make their own lemoncello). The chicken they serve with the chicken pasta dishes (e.g. chicken piccata) is super tender. The ribs are good. I have never had a poor meal at this restaurant and we’ve been eating there for several years. Service is consistently great and the prices are affordable. The restaurant has a nice, italian atmosphere, and the bar is a great place to eat, albeit a bit noisier but always a fun place to sit and people-​watch, or watch a game. Not a rowdy place — great for families and a good place to take family and friends in from out of town who want an affordable meal, a good selection of foods and a nice place to eat.

We ate in the bar area. Clean and accommodating. Every staff member we talked to was extremely nice and helpful.

After a very long day driving across state we stumbled upon Rosati’s in Oconomowac. Walking in, we see an environment which was clean and well decorated. Not over the top, but with enough character to be inviting. Expecting to pay an arm and a leg, we sat down with out two month old still in his car seat. Our waitress brought a kids seat and like a pro, flipped it over and helped is settle our son in the upside down chair while keeping him fast asleep in his car seat. Our meal was delicious, well timed and to top it all off considerably less than we expected!
We would gladly stop in again should we be in the area and recommend it to all! Our server was great, the bathroom was clean, the restaurant was quiet though still buzzing with clientele, and we could afford it.
5 stars for what turned out to be the calm enjoyable dining experience we had been needing for some time now.

I’ve had Rosati’s pizza in the past — always take out (it’s fantastic). This was my first time eating at an actual Rosati’s. It was a great experience!
The have a huge, nice bar area. Great to grab a drink. Several high top tables that comfortably seat 5 people. And their food is good. I had their philly sandwich. It was good. Honestly, the best thing to get their is their pizza (take out or eat in!).
Would definitely go back. Good spot for a date or family dinner.

Rosati’s in Oconomowoc is our «go to» place for pizza in Oconomowoc. My family has had delivery from here I’m guessing at least three dozen times in the past few years. (guessing from how many times I’ve redeemed the coupons from the boxes of «save 12 get the next pizza at 50% off»!) We also enjoy going there for dine-​in as a family. The service and quality of the food has been very consistant in all of those visits.

Food is OK but not exceptional. Ambiance is what it is for a strip mall restaurant. Service is inexperienced. Specials are reasonably priced but pizzas are quite expensive.

Excellent dinner. Service was great as well as the food. Friday night fish special was very good. As well as the pizza.

Had carryout last night and it was fantastic! Love the thin crust. In-​laws thought it was the best they’ve ever had.
Keep it up!

Everything on the menu is amazing. The waitresses and bartenders are incredible? And Scott? Ask to say hello to Scott! He makes the ranch… Scott’s Ranch. It will change your world! So say hello to Scott for me would you?

Every meal we’ve had at Rosati’s has been tasty. Once, on a Friday night, we had to wait just under an hour for a table, and the apologetic hostess comped us each a drink. The stuffed pizza is good, but it’s a LOT of food. I prefer the hand-​tossed pizza. The deep friend eggplant is surprisingly delicious; not soggy at all.
If you come on a Friday night, be prepared to wait.

What an experience! We were driving to Dells and took a random exit for lunch. This place was a great find. The waitress was very nice and took good care of us. I had the Stromboli which was fantastic. Crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside with fresh ingredients.
Loved it!

Really, really good food and service.
I didn’t have huge expectations out here during our military seminar at the Olympic. We didn’t want to do the stock lunch, so we ran out to try Rosati’s based on the Unilocal feedback.
Pricing is very kind, and when you compare it to the portions, it’s ridiculous.
We ordered a round of apps (mozzarella sticks, breadsticks, garlic bread and wings) and were blown away by how much food came out. Everything tasted great and there wasn’t too much of a delay considering it was a busier Saturday lunch.
We all ate different sandwiches, and they were huge. I had the Italian beef & sausage combo with pasta salad (in vin rather than a mayo cream), and the others had the regular Italian beef, the cheef (beef with melted cheese) and a calzone. My combo was spicy from the sausage, well made, not at all dry, and also had the au jus to dip.
The portion sizes are really big, which is awesome to see given what most places put out. My sammie, for $ 7, ended up with half in a box with the leftover salad to snack on later.
I don’t think we really finished anything on the table for the sheer volume of food in front of us. It was pretty awesome. I highly recommend trying Rosati’s.