Godfathers Pizza

I’ve always heard about this place and have seen them on many a popular exit sign.
They’re pizza is okay and the price isn’t always worth it. Pizza wise, I personally don’t like the thick style they offer and have yet to try their thin crust. It was greasy, had weird texture, and overall wasn’t as tasty as I expected.
BUT THE HUSHPUPPY PIE WAS PHENOM THOUGH. I dream about its buttery sweet goodness at times. That thing is genius. Probably not the healthiest, but so worth…

I grew up eating at Godfathers in Kansas — a weekly Friday treat. We moved to Arizona and was happy to find out they had a few here. Then around 2008 they closed all the locations in Phoenix and it hurt my heart. So whenever we visit Omaha we hit up the lunch buffet.
This location is pretty new and still clean. They have a Coke Freestyle –super awesome! We requested a veggie pizza and they brought us the pizza before it got picked over on the buffet line. Everything was good and fresh. The pizza itself is a tad expensive but the lunch buffet is definitely worth it!
The even have a godfathers table all decorated to theme! :P

Horrible delivery service. Very disrespectful, rude, unprofessional. Two thumbs down.

It was okay for extremely over priced pizza. Not sure how fresh their ingredients are but it was a little to much like Chicago style pizza, so if you like that kind you might like this place

Excellent experience! Great food and great people. The manager truly cares that you have a great experience and it shows. We showed up toward the end of the lunch buffet and he kept the pizzas coming so that we could enjoy. Awesome guy!

Pizza was cold. In not sure what happen to the original recipes but this place is not how I remember Godfathers pizza.

We got a Hawaiian pizza and breadsticks delivered to our hotel room. We ordered through Unilocal and the whole order took less than 5 minutes. The price was awesome and the pizza was terrific. They delivered in under 45 minutes. Totally impressed and wishing we had a Godfather’s Pizza back home!

Bad pizza choice, brown lettuce and no ranch dressing? At 12:40pm? Terrible experience. And only two types of «allowable» pozza with the slice and salad lunch deal. Just terrible.

Cleanliness 4
Service 4
Food 4
Likelihood 4
OVERALL SCORE 4.0
I was hungry for piping hot pizza. I am a firm believer that Godfathers Pizza is best experienced right out of the oven. I just think it looses a couple of points with me via delivery. Tonight’s visit re-​confirmed that, for me.
The counter order taker was nice, a little heard to hear and understand, she didn’t make a lot of eye contact, and was talking down to the register instead of up with me.
I LOVE the new single spout Coke Soda machines with multi-​choice flavor options. The pop quality is SO much better.
Pizza arrived quickly and it was piping hot fresh and tasty. They brought our dessert dish out several minutes later, again piping hot fresh and tasty.
Place was clean, well dusted, vacuumed, only one light bulb out. We will return.

Called to see how we could get 40 pieces of pizza and what was the cheapest /​easiest way of getting it. I figured we would have to go with a few Jumbos but the employee helped us out a great deal. She suggested that we go with 4 large pizzas since they were having a special (1 topping $ 9.99). That saved us a ton of money and also got us to the 40 slices that we needed. Great pizza at a great price.

I had a large sausage pizza with Motza crust and it was awesome. The entire pizza was perfect and made with love and care! I have been going to Godfathers since it opened in Omaha. This pizza was so good that it reminded me of the old Godfather days. I asked for the cooks name. My compliments to Robbi the pizza chef.

The pizza is good not great. Seems fresh and is tasty. I am very picky on pizza but I would eat here again after trying some other places. I ordered the super combo and cheese bread.

Godfathers pizza used to be a staple in Omaha for the best pizza. I have not had it for several years 2005 or so. I ordered a combo pizza. Mushrooms, black olives, pepperoni and cheese. Good pizza, not as fresh as an independent pizza joint, but it works.