Tony’s New York Pizza

Amazing pizza. Delivered before the time given by the website. Hot and fresh. Tasty dessert too. I’d never had anything from there before and felt lazy tonight so I thought I’d give it a try. This will be my regular Pizza place from now on!

Nothing special about the pizza. It’s a little garlicky. Mozzarella sticks were good. French fries were SUPER salty, and they charged us for ranch we never received. Probably won’t get again. But it was alright!

Very happy with this choice. There’s a lot of local pizza joints and Tony’s did a great job. All of the employees were very friendly and we’re having a good time. The pizza was excellent. I highly recommend.

Ok… so this is plain ordinary pizza. Ot’s not great and it’s not horrible either. I had a personal pizza with chicken, light onions and tomatoes… it really seemed flavorless. HOWEVER, the service was so great. The server was alone and she was even preparing the pies. She was literally running and on top of things. Everybody’s orders came quickly, she checked in with me twice and was polite and patient. I am guessing that if she hadn’t been alone, pizza would have probably had more love and flavor into it… But I really can’t complain. I am a sucker for good customer service… plus the lunch special was very inexpensive. A 10 inch personal pizza, with 3 toppings and with a fountain drink for $ 6.39, including tax?! Great price!

My new spot for pizza in Orange City! Had come in a few months ago and it sucked! My kids wanted Pizza on a Sunday morning and they were the only one opened at 10am! Come to find out they have a new owner! Pizza came to our table straight out of the oven! Very nice people! The pepperonie pizza looked like a picture! And they dough was on point! Overall definitely coming back for more!

Service was quick and the pizza was great. If you want a beer and a pie then this is a great choice. Especially on a Monday. Can’t beat that for starting the week.

They are Under New Ownership. Very good food and very good service. I would definitely come back.

The cheese on the pizza is extremely thick that the cheese comes right off when they bring you the pie and there bathrooms in the resturant are disgusting

Don’t go here if you actually want to eat. Service is abominable. We ended up leaving after waiting forever just for drinks. The restaurant was almost empty, they had 2 waitresses but 1 waitress did nothing except take care of her little kids that were sitting at a table.
It’s a shame, the place used to be great. My understanding is, the original owners sold it, and since then it slid downhill. If they only want be a take out and delivery place, they should just stop the sit down service, not drive it away with poor service.

Tried calling around 8:45pm on a Friday night to order a pizza but the phone just rang and rang and rang. So we decided to head there and order one instead. We arrived at the door at exactly 8:53pm and they were locked up tighter then a drum. We knocked on the door and watched the employees ignore us lol!!!
If you’re going to close at 9:00pm, then close at 9:00pm.
Never going back or recommending for my friends to either.

My friend and I stopped here for lunch. It was very quite and the lights were low. We were the only ones there for our entire lunch experience. I liked the calm atmosphere; it was very relaxing.
Service: we were immediately greeted from across the room by what I am assuming was the owner. Our server was a young man (Probably the owner’s son). He was a bit awkward and unsure of himself but he did his best to make jokes and be pleasant. I liked him.
Food: we each ordered 3 slices and a drink (we were very hungry). The slices were a decent size and filled me up after eating 2.5. The pizza had a nice crunch to it. My only complaint (and I know this will sound strange) is that there was too much cheese. They definitely don’t mind putting cheese on the pizza but in this case it was too much. Also, the cheese was a lower quality cheese.
Price: inexpensive! $ 2 per slice is a steal. For 6 slices and 2 drinks we only paid $ 17
Overall: the pizza was good, atmosphere was relaxing, and the service was great. Tony’s gets my recommendation.

Very good pizza and fried ravioli, quick service and friendly. The cannoli is very good and the pizza is very well made… I go to the gym next door and its a pain in the butt when I go to avoid this place with all the good aroma in the air

We got our appetizers 15 minutes after we got our pizza slices: no customer service whatsoever, server was more concerned with tending to to-​go customers than the restaurant guests. Did not ask how any of the meal was at any point in time. Did not ask if we needed anything. Bruschetta was made with soggy tomatoes. Will not be coming back to this place!

OK — I would go to Tony’s just for the crust. Chewy and crisp on the outside — not too thick! Had a Margherita Pizza — just the right blend of cheese/​sauce/​basil. Will be back to try other menu items. Wait staff was pleasant and helpful.

We just moved to the area and decided to check this place out with our two kids. When we walked in we were impressed with the décor, much nicer than we expected for a pizza place in a plaza.
We sat ourselves and waited quite awhile to be greeted, even though there were only two other tables in the place. When the server came she was kinda rude, explained that they didn’t have most of the menu and when we did order got our order completely incorrect.
BUT I don’t always judge a restaurant based on the service, however the food was just okay… The garlic knots were good once you scrapped off some of the absurd amounts of chunky fresh garlic (too spicy for the little ones) and the pizza had an absurd amount of cheese as well. (Don’t get me wrong, we love cheese, but this was way way way too much). Over all we left as a family of four spending $ 40+ tip. I just think that $ 50 for two adults and two children under the age 4 was too much for subpar food and poor service. We won’t be back, which is a shame since it’s so close by.

Tastes like typical fast food pizza. Yes it looks amazing but it doesn’t taste amazing. Nice people /​clean restaurant. I hope they can tweak the recipe and get it tasting as good as it looks!

I was in a rush and had a desire for pizza so I looked up this restaurant and called in my order with plenty of advance notice so I did not have to wait. The lady said it will only take a few minutes and I said perfect. When I got there they had not even put my order in yet so I end up waiting about five minutes which I did not have. The pizza was average to below average for me, an original New Yorker. Dough was too thick, sauce was way too salty and too much cheese. Will not be back again.

Great pizza, never been disappointed yet. My only complaint is the the prices are high.

Once again, typical Fl these days, no mention of Tony himself, or anyone else who works there’. Amazing the egocentric behavior of most of Central Florida these days.
Not even a description of Tony. Its called Egocentric and its sad but most of Central Fl is this way now.
Albeit, Not Tony in the least!
I am a loyal fan from Way back– he knows me as a great customer. and my thought toward him Prior to Unilocal.Assuredly. even before my Unilocalin’ days– and if only by sight. He knows me.
Did any of you even saying anything descriptive about the place– not really. Like I tried… more then a pizza, He makes Great Stromboli– authentic enough to come from Stromboli itself. Poor me, all e I have done is stayed– not just visited. Naples. And A hint, I am not talking Florida folks, that would be too egocentric for me.
Tony you are so worth– my 5 Star Rating! on many dishes.
MY 5 stars are based on, worthiness of that palace in that, particular area.
I am guessing, That everyone, knows there is much open debate about Stromboli in the US States as to its origin. Its Newer Folks. And does NOT originate from lil’ Italy — although it is very good in NY.

Like one of the other reviewers, I am at a loss for words. As I was eating it, I could not BELIEVE how good my pizza was. Just out-​of-​this-​world terrific!
For the record, I ordered a Marinara with toppings: peppers (they came sliced super-​thin!), onions and mushrooms. The veggies were SO FRESH! And the crust — to die for!