Polly’s Pies Restaurant

They have the best cinnamon rolls I’ve had. Love the breakfast here. The smoked kielbasa and omelettes are my favorite as they come with a bakery item. Their coffee had been slacking though. Customer service is fine but it can get busy.

Pretty cool place. I really liked the A.B.C Omelette definitely try it! They have pretty much every type of breakfast meal you can think of and sell fresh made pies all day. Buy one! They’re all really good!

My wife and I usually go most Saturday mornings and our favorite waiters are Frankie & Johnny. I made the mistake and went on a Sunday morning, the waitress I got was horrible. I had her a few times before and I get the same service from her every time. The next time they try to seat me in her section I will decline. She is not a good waitress for me, others may like her. This is from my visit on Sunday May 14, 2016. I like Polly’s Pies good staff except one waitress.

Pollys drops the ball! After years of loyal Polly’s service I hate to write this. Today we were seated and no one came to take a drink order or even say they’d be right back to take care of us. Each time we have visited this location, the service has been extremely slow and horrible. Today we walked out after waiting more than 10
Minutes to be noticed or talked to. We’re gonna take a break from this location for a while. Thanks for making our 2 year old cry because we had to go somewhere else.

Second time here and on a Tuesday place was not too busy so we were seated right away. Ordered from breakfast menu, food came at a reasonably timely manner. Here again on a Friday seated right away, as usual friendly service and quick enough attention from the server. This is now our favorite brunch restaurant. Food is good and reasonably priced.

After years of near exceptional service, Polly’s drops the ball. We traveled to Polly’s for one of their signature burgers and pies. Requested two burger specials with pie and a side salad. Since I suffer from a compromised immune system I asked for the burgers to be «WELL DONE». The side salad arrived and while eating it I noticed brown lettuce on the bottom. I returned it and chose to wait for my juicy burger. After several bites I noticed pink, undercooked meat. That also was returned. The other burger, also requested well done, was undercooked. The GM game to our table and apologized for the salad and the first burger. At that time he was made aware of the second undercooked burger. I can’t gamble with undercooked beef, considering all the recalls lately and neither should Polly’s. Customer beware.

I had the quiche, bacon and spinach and it was sooo good — don’t see quiche much anymore. Great crust like their pies.
The servers were a little loud but many senior customers and just having fun I guess.

I only have lunch experience here. The food has always been decent. At times the staff can not be a bit more attentive. We have had to flag down a waitress for refills. Besides that, I enjoy eating here.

Polly’s in Orange. Our first time at this restaurant and would also be our last. Clam chowder looks like a paste and taste like it too. Kids pollyburger is too salty and mentioned it to the waitress and all she said was «oh is it too salty for her, I’m sorry «and never offered to get a replacement. Ohh ohh I forgot they’re expertise is more on pies ! Oops!

I’ve known Polly’s for their pies for years, but we went for breakfast, and it was a really great meal. My child’s meal was very inexpensive, and well balanced. They had really good quality bacon and sausage, and then there’s the pie. Yup. Pie.
That said, I’d be happy to go again when in the area. They had great service, were thoughtful about how to provide food to the table based upon how a kid eats (timing wise), and it was just good, well priced, solid food.

Cannot say anything bad about this place! Good grub, service, staff, and location. My only gripe? (Insignificant). Difficult to make a left turn in the parking lot if you are approaching from Southbound Tustin Ave.

We ordered the chicken take out dinner which included one whole chicken, potatoes mashed for four people. Choice of 2 sides, came with cornbread or you can select rolls. Good value for family take out for $ 20 fed four people.
My to go order was ready in approximately 10 minutes. In addition, we got a strawberry pie for dessert which was very fresh and tasty.
This is an old people place so don’t go on a date here!!!
Atmosphere: old fashioned and quiet

Always can rely on calling ahead to see if pies are available. One of the best places to buy pies around town. If you never had a pie from Pollys you must be new school and are missing out. Get one before you they all gone. Pies are sold on the daily and especially after a meal to where it’s hard to come by if you want for some good finishing to a good meal.

The coleslaw had a weird smell & didn’t taste very good. The tuna melt was ok & the peach pie was ok. The vanilla ice cream is very good. I’d come back to try out more pie. They had good customer service.

Good service, we had school fundraising deal so we came here for pie. Texture of the pie was great, I had a banana pie and it tasted so so good. Strawberry pie was fine and apple pie was normal, nothing special.
I may comeback for Banberry pie, it looks great tho!!!

This was a cool little spot.
While looking for a place to eat we came across this place.
We were starving… but…as we entered one of the managers thought it was later then it was and started to put the closed signs up. It was funny to see the look on his face when I told him you still got an hour and he kept telling his workers and us it was closing. But he was really tired… I guess long hours… long day.
The waitress and manager were very cheerful. We got pot pies and they were delicious. The atmosphere was relaxing.
But on a late evening night (not much open) just gotta say… thenks for being open.

So you are running around town with a coworker who has a hankering for some pie… what to do? Well you can always stop at Polly’s and get some pie…
They have a million types of pie and specials on pie day… you know 3.14 errr March 14^th… well when we stopped by to get some togo pie, we ended up with a Lemon Meringue and Dutch Apple. They happened to have them on special when we were there so we got both pies for $ 20.
We talked them into providing us with a pie/​cake server as well. I mean how else are you going to handle cutting and serving two pies up with a bunch of co-​workers?
Overall the pies were pretty good. The togo pie service was acceptable and took very little time. So all things considered, we will go back sometime.

Oh how I’ve missed you Polly’s!!!
When I was a kid, I would go to Polly’s all the time in Cerritos. I don’t know how I let 16years go by without going again! We always passed Polly’s on Tustin ave literally ALLLLL THHHHHEEEEE TIME! I wish my family came to a Polly’s rather than wackass Coco’s and on the decline, Marie callenders. This place outshines both of them! We’ve gone a handful of times and service has always been great except one time and it stood out how much we weren’t feeling this waiter. One his accent is VERY thick, he talks fast, doesn’t ask the right questions to assure you’re going to get your meal the way it should be done to your specifications and he seems bothered when asking for stuff! You need to keep him in the back, I don’t know how these hearing impaired old folks understand him. No joke! Again everyone has been pleasant but this guy!
As for the food. I LOVE IT! I’m addicted to their chicken pie. So much better than Marie callenders chicken pot pie! It’s a slice rather than a whole mini pie. It’s a nice big slice with top and bottom pastry. You get plenty of chicken through out the pie and the chicken gravy that comes with it is CRACK! No kidding I ask for extra on the side and also a side of stuffing, that’s right I can get stuffing here 365! I mash everything together, the pie, the mashed potatoes and stuffing and pour the gravy all over and I make sweet love to my meal. Even have enough to take home! It’s so hard to stray away from this dish even though the menu is quite distracting for me. I’ve only tried two other dishes.
Every month they have specials and in October I did their Oktoberfest menu, breaded porkchops with a side of potato pancakes, sauerkraut, apple sauce and of course my extra side of stuffing! Good seasonal item but I’m stuff on that chicken pie! I’ve done my childhood half chicken dinner and that’s soooooo good. Everything I order has to have a side of dressing! I tastes my sisters BLT and it’s damn good and I would get it but I need my chicken pie! I’m serious, I love it so much, I want one now after writing this review! Oh and their Polly palmer drink is beyond tasty!!!
Overall, I really love Polly’s and my sister and I can go every week! My mom is bored with it but not sis and I!!! Now we just need to get up early enough for breakfast!!! We will keep coming back, just don’t want to sit in señor’s waiting area again LOL

DELICIOUS!
It has been AGES since I’ve been to a Polly’s and it felt sooo good to be reunited! Me and Alexis have been talking about going for awhile but she decided she wanted to come here for her birthday lunch which I’m not complaining since that is exactly the food I like!
We came in after the lunch rush which I’m a stickler about because during busy periods in any establishment you can forget about getting good service or your order right! It was nice and quiet inside, my eyes went straight to the pie counter and everything else they had lol!
We had good service from beginning to end along with a HUGE menu! They had great lunch specials, a menu for October-​fest, and their regular menu with so many choices!
I love that you can pick 2,3 or 4 items for your lunch special for under $ 10!
I forgot how CRACK their rolls were and they came out piping hot fresh with butter and I was in love! Another thing that was crack was their Polly Palmer which is iced tea with strawberry lemonade! I couldn’t get enough of it and took a cup home!
I ordered off the lunch special (half a turkey Sammy with a side of mac & cheese [mac and cheese was baddd! It tasted like the Stouffers frozen mac!] But my bread on my sandwich was sooo fresh and squishy! I enjoyed it!
Mom ordered off the October fest menu and she liked hers as well, 2 bratwursts, sourkraut and German type pancakes. Alexis ordered the Chicken Pie with a side of stuffing, her stuffing was really good and had the consistency of how my mom makes it which is a bonus! My mom and I shared the Pumpkin maple crunch pie and when we got home and tried it the crust was so fresh compared to my Coco’s experience! (See my previous review a few days ago) Everything tasted so homemade no premade pie crust or frozen type fruit. I loved the pie it was delicious!
We want to go back and try breakfast soon! I love you Polly’s! ^_​_​^

I’ve only ever had their pies here, but they are some of the best pies I’ve ever tasted.
All of their pies are so good. Very fresh and flavorful. The fruits are super sweet. My favorite is their strawberry/​banana pie. Yummy.
Not cheap, but it’s definitely worth it.
Very underrated place; I think it’s because pies aren’t that popular of a desert.
Go check it out!