NYC Pizza

My roommate and I ordered delivery from here through the beyond menu app. The delivery took 2 hours, and they called us twice, both calls 45 mins apart, because they needed more information about our order. They were unapologetic. I ordered an Italian sub and it was serious pathetic. Would not order from here again.

Been here a few times, haven’t had a bad experience. I would recomend this place too everybody who likes some good pizza. The staff is great people with good vibes will be back next time I want some delicious pizza.

Ordered online and they said 45 – 60 mins, it came in maybe 25! Cannoli was delicious! Pizza was good, as a native New Yorker I am hard to please but I would order again. The thing that confused me was I ordered a baked ziti and it wasn’t ziti noodles but spaghetti, the taste was still okay though! Great garlic knots. Will order from there again.

We ordered delivery and the man on the phone said it would be 30 – 45 mins it took maybe 30 mins to get the pizza if that. That’s faster then any chain pizza would be. The pizza was delicious! Super friendly staff

Better pizza better prices good food exelen attencion good wings oh 2 slice pepperoni pizza &dink $ 4.99 exelent we Delivery free slice for ladies affter 11: pm good good :)

I love the pizza here. But just the other day I decided to try a special they have. An extra extra large pizza with 2 toppings 18 wings 6 garlic knots and a 2 liter drink. Not only was it super affordable less then $ 30 for all of that. But it was absolutely the best pizza wings and garlic knots i have ever had in my life!!! And that is not an exaggeration. If you have never tried the food here I highly recommend it. You will not be disappointed.

I tried this place twice, the second time only to give them another shot because the first time they were late delivering and the food was cold. The second time was worse. Super cheap ingredients, bad food.

Do not bother going there in person. I was almost turned off by my first experience. They sometimes are out of things too which can be pretty damn annoying.
However, I give them the four star rating for their gyros and Philly cheesesteaks. I cannot comment on their pizza as I do not like pizza much in general these days. (Ordered way too many where they’re all starting to taste the same to me. Grad school lol)
The gyro meat is thick and juicy with a good sear. Not that skimpy boxed thin sliced junk. And for me, their tzatziki sauce is probably oneo of f the best in the area. Mediterranean Gyros near by is too minty, and Hallal Gyros further down on Colonial is too oily. And 5.99 is not a bad price.
The odd kicker is, the Philly cheesesteak. I like philly’s and I like them on philly bread, toasted with good seasoned steak and melted whiz or white american depending on my preference that day. They don’t have either of those cheese, or at least that’s not what comes with it. To be honest, it’s more of a steak and cheese hoagie as it comes with lettuce tomato onion and mayo, but I’m not one to be a label whore. Either way, my «Philly“was both tasty, well seasoned but not overpoweringly so, and the cheese I’m guessing is what they top their pizzas with, mozzarella. ((Weird. But worked))
I gave 4 stars for these two sandwiches. 1 star off for their parking at the restaurant and delivery times.

Their business card has I love NY Pizza, another restaurant that was in Orlando for a few years. So looks like a new name.
Anyway its the seedy part of fifty across the street from the park in an auto repair strip mall. Not the nicest building, and the surrounding area is questionable.
When you walk in they have some specials on real sized pizzas, like an 18 inch, up to 28 inches gotta love that. The prices are good as well. $ 10.99−11.99 for 18 inch one topping. The pizza I would say is average, the crust is a little thinner then I like and had a different texture then I am used to, but good enough. Calzone had no taste but the pizza sauce that comes with it was very good.
Now the bad the interior is run down so dont eat in, the service was pretty slow as well. I dont think they could handle a rush even takeout. The atmosphere is run down, dingy and the customers appeared to be low income, not so friendly folks. Kind of reminded me of some parts of NY.
The people running the place were nice enough, I dont live near it and would rather go to another shop in the future, just gave it a try because it was new.

I would give this place 0 stars if I could. Waited an hour and a half for my pizza (was given a 45 min wait time). Called to see where my pizza was and was told I never placed an order. Then they magically found my order and decided it was indeed a mistake on their end. Then was offered 50% off and then that got changed to «sorry I can’t do that but I can give you a free 2 liter of soda instead». I told them that no I needed either a free pizza or 50% off and they came back and told me «never mind we just refunded your card, have a nice night». Pathetic. Don’t waste your time. Also, the inside is sketchville.

It’s pretty good, a step above little cesars or hungry howie’s and the slices are big, generous amounts of cheese and the crust itself was excellent. They’re located where the old lechonera latina use to be so you already know parking will probably be an issue. They deliver but I have heard that delivery time is never under 45 min whereas if you pick up, you only wait about 15 minutes. They offer other things like Jamaican patties, wings, garlic knots and even gyros, but since I didn’t see a spit with rotating gyro meat, it’s a pretty safe bet that it’s a frozen product. Apparently the jamaican patties are house made though and they’re popullar so I’ll have to try that at some point.
It was a bit off putting however that the guy holding up the sign advertising their XXL pepperoni pizza for 10.99 was cursing worse than a sailor, for a minute I thought it was at me as I was driving up because he was extremely loud, shouting, and when I stepped out of the car I noticed he was arguing over the phone. I still wont stop me from returning but being greeted by a slew of curse words isn’t exactly welcoming in my mind.
I may do an update once I try other things on their menu.