Red’s Catering

Best pizza in Oshkosh. Great broasted chicken. Unfortunately the buffet is way too expensive.

Red’s pizza was not the best pizza experience that I have had in Oshkosh. I called and placed a pick up order for a pizza and garlic bread. The order was to take 20 minutes and when I arrived it was ready. The pizza itself was very large but the price was higher than you would find at some of the larger pizza chains, which is fine if the quality is there. Unfortunately for me the pizza just didn’t seem that great to me. The sauce itself was pretty good but there was not a lot of sauce to be had on the pizza itself. It was somewhat imbalanced with really the only pizza sauce I got being around the crust, none really in the middle portion of the slice. The crust also seemed a bit burnt on the bottom and had more the consistency of a cracker than a pizza crust in my opinion on the bottom. The garlic bread also didn’t impress as it was okay only. They did mention they had mozza bread which may have been better but we didn’t opt for it on our order. The toppings were good and were the one compliment that I can pay to the pizza. Overall I don’t think I’ll be returning for this particular pizza

Red’s Pizza is the best in the world. I have been to Sicily, Chicago, and New York City, but Oshkosh and Red’s Pizza still reigns supreme. I had my bachelor party at Red’s Pizza, that is how good it is. The sauce is sweet and spicy and the crust is thin and crisp. i recommend mushrooms and Italian sausage. Red’s rocked since as long as I can remember.

Once upon a time this was my favorite Pizza in Oshkosh. The last 3 times I have ordered pizza from them the crust was burnt, the sauce was nasty and the toppings were skimpy. I’ve had better pizzas that were bought frozen from the supermarket.