Two Cousins Pizza Paradise

The two stars is for their customer service. We have been loyal customers for 2 years. Usually very friendly. This time, o ordered 12 wings with buffalo ranch sauce. I got the wings and they were plain. A little seasoning but not saucy at all. I called and a nice guy answered, apologized and said they would bring me new ones. I get a new call back from a lady saying she saw him put sauce on the wings herself and that the sauce probably dried up and next time I order to tell them extra sauce. I’ve never asked for extra sauce. Ever. So, after offering a new order. I was then called back and was basically called a liar.

The staff was nice and quick to take and deliver my order. The food was good the pizza could of had a little more cheese and the cheese steak a little more meat but both were still very good, I will be ordering from them again.

Decent hotel delivery fare. Had a large sausage pizza and wings delivered. Came quickly and was good.

ORDER THE GARLIC KNOTS!!! When the smorgasbords get old or you can’t get a table there, head to Two Cousins for a very satisfying meal minus the crazy tourist crowds. The spinach rav is something special too and fried broccoli which are actually broccoli bites are done to perfection. Definitely a sure thing for dinner!

Quantity for price was very reasonable but the quality was little left to be desired.

Great pizza and great chicken wings! The restaurant is very clean. People there are kind and friendly. Definitely going back if we revisit Lancaster.

We trusted the Unilocal reviews and are glad we did. Had a wonderful supreme pizza. We ordered to go and they were even nice enough to offer paper plates. The restaurant was nicely decorated and clean. We visit Lancaster once or twice a year and will definitely be back for another great pizza next time.

The wife and I ate here while visiting lancaster let me tell you they know how to make a great tasting pizza there was something with the cheese that I have never tasted with other pizza joints it is delicious

Just ate where and let me tell you — DO NOT PASS THIS PLACE UP. Great pizza and service. Calzones was awesome as well! Glad we stopped and so will you!

Update!
The quality has continued! I especially like the wings and the meat boli. The wings are crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside. They use a liberal amount of sauce and its tangy and spicy just the way it is supposed to be.
My wife ate here for the first time a few weeks ago, after the last place she was very skeptical. She ordered the Italian sub, after the first few bites she said… that is a dang good sandwich. Keep up the good work! Paradise finally has a good pizza place!

Drove up to visit Dutch Wonderland twice in three months and visited Two Cousins for dinner both times. Never realized that they were a chain, but no matter, the pizza (large sausage and mushroom) is good! Extremely nice and fresh ingredients generously spread out on the pie. The crust was thin and fantastic. Not gooey with the cheese and not oversauced. This is good pizza! Skip the garlic knots, they were small, too oily, and actually rather bland. Stick with the pizza and your stomach will thank you. Service was fantastic as well, had the same waitress (Amber) both times and she was nothing short of awesome. Friendly and attentive. A real asset to the store. Thanks Unilocal for sending us to Two Cousins. We will definitely be visiting every time we visit Dutch Wonderland with the kiddies!

When this pizzeria was Paradise Pizza I rarely ate there. The food was gross. When they closed and Two Cousins took over, was very excited… and I haven’t been disappointed. I order from here all the time now. Good food.

Pizza done right. Extended hours, friendly service, drive through, carry out, delivery or eat in, and clean and tidy!
Ok, you are in an area where most places are serving local food, and it’s all good… and you also have a bunch of chains a few minutes away, but. Sometimes you want a familiar food that doesn’t taste like mass produced, processed crap.
That’s where two cousins comes in. F-​R-​E-​S-​H baked goodness. Their menu is just varied enough to give you plenty of options and not get you lost in a huge maze of variations that serve no purpose. All the ingredients are fresh, plentiful and well paired together. But above all, I must emphasize their cheese. It has got to be one of the best ones I’ve ever had on a pizza.
I would say their large pie is big enough for three adults (I’m lean but I sure eat a lot), add extra cheese if you want the ultimate experience. Size in this case does matter because you might think its pricey, but once you eat it (or don’t eat it completely because it is filling!) you will realize the price is just right.
I would recommend it and will surely return next time I’m in town.

We were in town for vacation and wanted to order pizza to appease some hungry kids. Our first attempt was from a place recommended by the front desk staff at the Revere Best Western. After an hour and a half we cancelled the order. A few days later we stumbled across Two Cousins. It was a little over a block from the hotel. The owner and staff were friendly. The pizza was made at the time of order and tasted great. Prices were reasonable. Would definitely visit Two Cousins again!