Lefty’s Restaurant and Pizzeria

The best local Italian Restaurant around. Friendly quick service and great portion size meals! Must try! My bf and I are regulars!

Absolutely love this place! I don’t even think twice about where to order from when I’m hungry. The wraps are my absolute favorite, along with the buffalo chicken pizza. Not only is their food amazing but the service as well. I usually order for delivery and the call is always answered by a cheery, welcoming voice. They give you a delivery time that is met, I usually get my order either before or within the time, never late. Glad they are also located so close to me! Thanks for great food and excellent service :)!

HORRIBLE time management and customer service. As someone who works close by and has a short lunch break, I make sure to call well in advance so I can just pick up my food and go. All other popular restaurants can handle this, but Leftys does not seem to have this critical portion of owning a restaurant mastered — as I waited AN HOUR AND 10 MINUTES FOR MY FOOD.
I was told my food would be ready in a half hour. I come 35 mins after I place my order and was told it would be ready soon. 15 mins after waiting I ask a waitress, who is just standing behind the register about my food and she says «we’re busy» and rolls her eyes. Keeping my cool, I sit back down. 20 mins after that, I tell a man, who I guess was the manager, that I want to cancel my order. All of a sudden my food is being packed up and is ready. After an HOUR AND TEN MINUTES OF WAITING, I’m just disgusted at their lack consideration for customer’s time (as I was not the only one asking about the wait time) as well as the atrocious attitude of their staff. To display such an attitude for subpar service and quality of food, it’s no wonder majority of people dine at the excellent wize guys, across the street & 2 blocks down.

The. Pizzas that were just delivered to us in less than half an hour, are delicious. They have just the right amount of delicious sauce and toppings. The crust is not too hard or soft, it’s just right. The pizza sauce is my from fresh tomatoes, I could see and taste it. I do not understand the bad reviews here, I guess they have many competitors around them, who make their friends write bad reviews. They deliver all the way to elmwoodpark from Paterson. Next we will try their pastas and subs. Thank you.

This pizza is absolute garbage. A reason why I had to stay in the hospital for 5 days due to eating their pizza and getting food poisoning.

Great customer service! Great pizza! Best sandwiches I’ve had. The hot shrimp sub is perfect every time! I live about 2 mins away from this place and it is a weekly stop for me and friends for lunch! They never disappoint and the food is always amazing! Ive made it a goal to try every hot sub on their menu!

The service was excellent food was ready quickly. The place is very clean. Their pizza is great. I always order it with fries because they are really good too. Not a big dessert fan but took a pumpkin cheesecake for my girlfriend she loved it. I had like 2 bites and it was phenomenal. excellent establishment if you get a chance to go definately go.

I was craving pasta so I found Leftys which I was a little nervous about trying a new place especially since I was extremely hungry. But I must say it was very good! I ordered the cheese tortollini with alfredo sauce which was delicious. There lasagna was very good as well. Normally pizzarias give regular bread with pasta dishes but Leftys gives free garlic bread which is a thumbs up! I will definitely get food from here again!

Love this place awesome atmosphere and even better food! Pizza, salads, subs and pastas are great

These guys are always doing it RIGHT!!! I must say been here a few times now. It is always very clean, food that is done very well, and welcoming when you walk in the door. They may attention to detail with the food. We had eggplant rollatini, mussels in a spicy red sauce, a antipasto salad, and a slice :) very simple traditional dishes yet really done right.
I have also picked up food to go. It is always packed right. Simple things that other place seem to not care about. Lefty’s is a small place and keeping the FOOD on point. I will be back.

First Thing Met The Owner Cause He Greeted Us With A Nice Welcome & The service Was Great Also The Food Was Very Awesome For The Price I would Recommend It To EveryOne.