Four Corners Pizza

I am lucky to say I’ve grown up eating this pizza since I was a little kinderlux. It’s the best pizza around, enough said.

Been coming here forever! This place could easily be on a top 20 list for best pizzas in the country. If you find yourself wandering the suburban streets of westchester you have to check out this pizza. Forget Pelham Pizza, that place is nasty, the food makes you sick & the staff is the worst of it all. Four Corners Pizza all day!

When I want pizza, I buy it here! I also enjoy their Italian ice.

In my humble opinion, it’s the best pizza around. Love their sicilians and regular slices. Pizza is always fresh and consistently great. I’ve been going there for over 20 years and it’s still as good as always. They just changed ownership but the pizza is the same and the same guys are there. Only downside is that the place is small and seating is limited so take it to go or go after the lunch rush! This review got me hungry and I think I’m heading to Four Corners now for 2 corner sicillians!

4 Corners: Get ready for the NY style pizza you have been waiting for.
I LOVE this pizzeria. From the kind staff to the family feel it is your spot for pizza if your in the Bronx-​Westchester area. Let me start with the flaws. Now if this was a sheer review about food this pizza would be close to a ⁵⁄₅ BUT it is about the entire restaurant so I must add some flaws. It is located along a busy road it’s a B-​I-​T-​C-​H to pull into (Still worth it;)) and it is quite small. If it had a larger space with maybe a better system of pay it would be a ⁵⁄₅ in my eyes. Now to the positives; The Food! This place is simply amazing. Although not many slices to chose from they cook each to perfection whether it be a spinach, Chicken, white, or simply regular. (If your looking for a pizzeria with fancy shamncy pizza your in the wrong place pal). Biting into a slice is like delving into pizza heaven. Along with delicious Italian ice to top off your meal. So if your looking for Bronx/​NY style pizza stop by 4 Corners to fulfill your needs.
La Felle

Heard about this place from a woman on the plane into Newark. We are driving back to Boston from a week in Belize. This place has great roni and the owner is authentic sicilian. If you are in the neighborhood, give it a try!

One of the best pizza’s in Westchester County area… I know the guys running the place for many years, they are some of the best people around… I sometimes go out of the way just to eat there or buy some pies… There Sicilians are excellent as well and worth trying…
Prices are good and the food is great especially when it comes out fresh from the oven.

I grew up going to Prospect Hill and eating 1 slice and a drink for $ 1.25. Awesome back in the late 70’s and early 80’s and is still awesome now. I went back last night for the first time since 1984, and Joe was still running the place, but without hair… Sadly his father passed away, but now his son runs the joint. I almost started crying when I ate a slice. Memories.

The best pizza anywhere! I don’t care if you agree or not just try it and judge for yourself.
These guys have been cranking out fantastic pizza forever.
Slice of ‘roni? White pizza? White with dollops of red sauce? Sicilian? Whole pies made to order with any toppings. They do it all, with a smile and an excellent demeanor.
(I fell in love here… slice with extra cheese, pepperoni and broccoli. Cannot beat it.)
I could wax poetic about my long, LONG nights hanging at 4 corners as a youth; tearing it up always every night, mischief night etc. Suffice to say I have been around and this is the place for pizza.
No where is pizza made with more tradition and care than this tiny slice of four corners.

Damn good pizza. No frills. $ 2.50 for a slice is still a good value for a very well made, good size slice. As one can tell from the reviews, these guys probably do not care about reviews. They’ve been there forever doing it the same way. Cash only. No delivery. You don’t like it, don’t go there. I do like it and I will continue to go there.

When we get pizza in town, we always go here. It is quick, and the pizza is very good. There is not much seating indoors, but you can always take out. In the summer they have ices, and those are always very tasty. Overall, this is a great pizza place for a great price.

I have been going here since it opened. Simply the best pizza. Nothing but pizza. I would recommend take out only.

This place has been a Pelham Manor staple for more then 40 years. The pizza is great. There is no need for gimmicky food here. Come on by and grab a slice. In the summer the Italian ice will hit the spot.

One of the best slices you can get in ny. The same group of guys have been working there since I was a kid. Go for a pepperoni slice, Sicilian or a slice with fresh tomato’s, They don’t deliver which kind of makes them even more of a gem.

Amazing pizza! My family started going there when they opened 40+ years ago. We now live in CT and still make the trip to have a great pie. CT pizza will never compare to New York. Joe and tony are great guys

This is not the place to go if you want a grand menu filled with a multitude of Italian dishes. But if you want a really solid slice of NY pizza, Four Corners is the way to go. Brian commented specifically on the delicious simplicity of the sauce. It’s cash only and there are only three booths, so I might suggest taking it to go.

When I was a child, the regular slices I could compare to a slice of heaven. They kind of lost their spark over the years.
…Butttt, it’s still more amazing than most village pizza joints around that area! I definitely recommend you check it out if your in the area and if your gf or wife isn’t in the mood you have NO.1 Chinese right next store if she’s in a «My Cousin Vinny» mood and hassling you about what to feed her in a small village suburb of NYC. I can honestly say the pizza in this town can top most of what Manhattan can offer you as well! So stop in and have a slice and forgedaboud-​it. :P

Nice guys here but really the Sicilian looked too dried out so we didn’t order it. The regular was nothing great and too oily. Maybe it was an off night but don’t think I would return to give it another try.

Good old fashion pizza here. Loved it reminded me when I was a little kid and my mom would give me a dollar to go to a old fashion Italian pizzeria pizza tasted the same. The new pizza shops now can’t compare.

I was in town staying the night at my sister’s. No time for a big dinner, so how about some pizza? I asked my nephew for a recommendation. and this was the joint. Not bad Pizza, but when I went into order it they suggested I take the pie that they put out for selling slices. It was near the end of the day and they were probably thinking that their pie was going to waste. They warmed it up for me, but I think, in retrospect, I should have held out for a fresh pie. We ate a few slices, put it away, and in the morning discovered my nephew and his friend had demolished the rest!