Coley’s Pizza

I will never stop giving this place 5 stars. Amazing chicken wings, signature pizzas, and subs.

Came across this pizza place on my way to Publix and wanted to grab a quick lunch. Although I ordered a Greek salad at a Pizza place, the salad was really fresh. However, I sat down to eat and could not help but noticed how grimy and sticky this place was. The windows were smeared, the tables were not clean, the floor was gross and I even saw a couple of dead bugs. I still finished my food, but I did want to get the heck out of there as quickly as I could.
I think some time spent cleaning, this place can actually be a really cute spot to come grab some food. I saw a sign that they offer cooking classes for kids on Saturdays, I love that, but they should get some cleaning done.

Coley’s always has hot and delicious food! The staff is friendly and efficient. The kids love it too! It’s nice to have a neighborhood pizza place that never disappoints.

This low rating is not for the food quality which is actually decent. Do not order delivery from here, every time I have ordered thy took over 2 hours and always end up giving some excuse like the delivery driver got lost or your address was wrong in the computer. On top of that they don’t even give refund for being 2 HOURS LATE! Avoid avoid Avoid at all costs !!!

Best pizza place in town! This is our «go to» pizza joint. Pizza’s are always fresh and made to order. Prices are reasonable. They also have weekly specials and now the convenience of ordering online so all you have to do is say your name when you get there and pick up your pizza or have it delivered. In addition, they host these adorable pizza cooking classes on Saturday’s for the kids that I’ve been meaning to go to but haven’t made it yet. My friends that have gone say it’s really cute and the kids thoroughly enjoy it. It also feels good to support a local business owner who happens to be a very hard working and dedicated female!

Excellent pizza! Very flavorful but sometimes a little bit greasy. Service has always been great and delivery times have been very fair for busy nights. Definitely give them a try!

Coley’s is Always the first pizza spot choice for my husband and I! Usually we get the delicious pizzas but today for lunch we got pasta. The Penne A La Vodka and Alfredo was amazing!!!

I order delivery from Coley’s pretty frequently. The pizza is always delicious and still hot by the time they get to my house.
When I order, they are always so polite when they take the order. I really enjoy ordering from Coley’s!
I usually order a medium with sausage, bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, and green peppers –comes to about $ 19 + a couple of bucks for the drivers tip!

I have had coleys at least 20 times with a year span. I ordered pickup and asked for 24 Dali-​lama wings which I’ve had every time I had been to coleys. When I got home I got the wrong wings they kindly offered to deliver the «correct» wings. Once I opened the box of wings they were wrong AGAIN, I called not to get new wings but to explain this wasn’t what I ordered, and they said «the cook said that is how they are made.» I find that hard to believe when the color itself is completely off, they look more like chipotle flavored wings. Again I did not ask them to fix their SECOND mistake I just wanted to make them aware and they failed to acknowledge their mistake. To add this was the first night I did not see the owner their, the staff is not representing well.

I love eating Coley’s pizza. Great food. Great service. Awesome prices. Fast delivery. I met the owner Coley one day I was picking up one of my orders, she’s very nice and has an inspiring story behind how she started the restaurant. The only thing I’d say they need work on is more tables, maybe putting some outside, due to the little space they have inside. Besides that they still deserve 5 stars.

Omg! Coley’s you have my tastebuds ecstatic! First off lets start with fresh, and the sauce! Did I mention the dipping sauce that comes with the calzones?! It is the

Crazy delicious pizza. As a displaced NYer, I do not endorse pizza restaurants often in FL. This is a rare treat. There is nearly no seating, so prepare to pick up and order and extra pie for breakfast tomorrow!

Its been months since my last visit here and I was craving for some delicious pizza. So I decided to give them another chance and hopefully they redeem their services.
I ordered the same thing as last: large cheese pizza with lemon pepper wings. I purposely went to pick up the pizza 10 – 15 mins late than their 30 mins promised time. Upon arrival, I was surprised that there was no line on a Friday night (around 8:30−9pm.) This time the cashier was a bit more attentive and greeted me as soon as I walked up to the cash register. After I paid, she said the wings are ready but the pizza should be ready in about 5 mins. This time, the wait wasn’t ridiculous like last. The pizza was ready and as promised. I dropped a buck tip from the change and left.
The pizza itself was nice and hot and I love it cheesy. Perhaps, my favor is their lemon pepper wings. It’s got that strong zesty lemon flavored taste and crispy skin. Once you bite through the skin, the meat is soft, a little chewy and comes right off the bone. Very delicious! I always wanna take a pic before I eat it but it’s usually done before I remember wanting to take the pic lol.
I don’t wanna say that they’re completely back to my good grace but I do wanna say that their service was tremendously better this time. I know what I’m getting when it comes to their food; I’m uncertain what type of service I’ll get so I’ll just treat it as per basis. You can expect good food, just don’t expect you get great service every time.

Let me start by saying that my coworkers and I order often from Coleys and there is ALWAYS an issue.
Coley’s will not include utensils in their delivery orders even to businesses unless specified. (How unrealistic is that?!?)
So if you order pasta or anything that needs utensils don’t expect for them to use common sense by adding it –_​–
Today we ordered and we specified «utensils please» and long behold no utensils. Called the business and spoke with «Isabella» who advised the delivery driver would come back out (he literally just left less than 1 minute ago) but I would have to wait.
Completely unacceptable!
The work place has ordered less and less due to other mishaps with food orders.
Wings have come in the wrong flavor, wrong toppings on pizza etc
Now with more delivery places in the area we barely order anymore.

GARLIC ROLLS ARE PERFECT!!! Just enough garlic not too oily, not overcooked where the top of the roll is hard & have to open it to get to center where its soft but then… theres no flavor if I’m gonna eat carbs it better be well worth it and Cooleys ROLLS ARE CARB WORTHY!
Unofficial Garlic Bread Expert

Really good Pizza and garlic roles. I wish they would have an GF pizza option so that I could eat it more often. But overall the best pizza place in the area.
Would highly recommend it.

I truly love the pizza and wings, it’s great stuff.
Customer service is a big deal to me and if it weren’t for the food I would give them one star.
The people who work here are almost enough to make me never want to order from them but I crave the damn pie and wings. I’ve been inside the business and would think they would be a little friendly or charismatic given the vibe but they aren’t friendly at all and one of the people who takes orders over the phone is incredibly painful to talk to. Whomp.

When fiancé asks for pizza, fiancé gets pizza. So we wandered over to Coley’s since I noticed they offer both Chicago and NY style. We opted for the Chicago style with pepperoni and waited there for about 20 minutes for our order. It’s a pretty large pizza, but wasn’t the Chicago style I was thinking. I was hoping for deep dish, but it wasn’t. I would have liked more pepperoni, but it was still a tasty pizza.
My second taste of Coley’s actually made me want to bump a 3 star review to a 3.5 (rounded to 4). This time fiancé ordered a hardy party or something like that, but basically meat lovers. THAT was really good. It solved my original complaint of wanting more toppings. So I would suggest to order more than one so as to cover the pie.

I feel like I’m missing out. There are so many rave reviews here on Unilocal AND this is the only local pizza place my parents will order from. Maybe I just consistently order the wrong things but I’ve just never been wowed by Coley’s. I think it’s, ya know, «fine» but my family seems to absolutely love it. Despite our disagreement on the food, we can all agree on one thing — Coley’s has gotten weird.
I remember coming here with a ton of my friends after class ended during high school. We usually came at least once a week and we always looked forward to it. This was at least 4 – 5 years ago — when Coley’s first opened. I remember enjoying it more back then and thinking that the staff was really friendly and cool.
In the more recent past (as well as when I went to pick up my family’s order last night), I’ve walked in and was basically ignored for a few minutes. They have probably six or seven people behind the counter who are clearly meant to be doing different tasks. I could understand if the staff was busy or doing something else (and you’d be able to tell — they have a totally open kitchen) but most of the time I’ve seen them playing around or texting and then finally realizing a customer is at the cash register. This doesn’t necessarily kill the experience for me but I can understand why it would bother some. As far as I’m concerned, I just want to get my order and go.
Unfortunately, sometimes it’s kind of hard to «get your order and go» here. There have been countless times when I’ve shown up — a half hour after placing my order — to have to wait another 20 – 30 minutes. I’m not sure if this is a testament to how busy these guys are or how inefficient it is to tell people «it’ll be 30 minutes» when it’s really much longer.
The food itself definitely isn’t bad, which accounts for all three stars on giving here. If you’ve got the patience, I think it’s worth it. The prices are reasonable and they definitely are very giving when it comes to toppings. I don’t think it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had but I don’t think there’s anywhere else nearby that blows it out of the water. So, for now, I’ll appease my family’s desire to keep ordering from here, but I’m definitely on the look out for something more.

So Coleys is a pizza spot I wanted to try after antonios in pines closed
We ordered two pizzas (margarita and a Chicago style with meats) along with two orders or garlic rolls.
Let’s start with the good, Chicago style deep dish pizza with meat. It was a damn good deep dish that was tasty and not greasy. I could eat this pizza all day. A few of these slices (it only comes in a medium pie) and ur good (at least I was as I was on my third Amber beer by the second piece.)
Now the not so good– the margarita pizza verde a little sauce to add some taste to it.
The bad– the young lady behind the counter took out our second helping of garlic tools from the oven and moved the rolls from the paddle (large spatchula that they pull the pizza from the oven with) to the tim foil with her bare hands– after she just got done running the register and taking my money… Not good. Besides– the garlic rolls need a lot more garlic anyway as we still are the other batch– hope that wasn’t the same and I didn’t see those prepared… Let’s hope. Lol
I will still be on the hunt for the best pizzeria in south Florida– let the Unilocaling continue!
If you know of the best pizzeria– please reach out to me! Thanks! Patrick