Stacy’s Pizza & Wings

Only ordered a large pizza, it’s alright but it’s almost as if they made a pizza, then opened 3 of those papa johns garlic dipping sauce and poured them all over the pizza. The pizza was literally dripping with a garlic oil, just felt it was far too much to put on one pizza.

For our family, Stacy’s Meat Lover’s Pizza, tops all of our previous favorites (Pizza Hut, Little Ceasar’s, and Papa John’s). The crust is always golden and crispy on the outside and soft buttery goodness on the inside. They have never been stingy with the toppings and always acknowledge my substitution requests; I like that they have never used artificial meat for our toppings. The pizza is always fresh For the last two years we’ve been ordering Stacy’s through
, the customer service is always professional when we need to speak with them or when we call the store directly to order delivery. The driver’s call first and then come to the door. I only had one price issue with Stacy’s and the situation was clarified with a phone call to the store. The only suggestion I’d request is to add a garlic sauce; Little Ceasars Garlic Butter Sauce is good, Papa John’s is the best, but neither of the latter tops Stacy’s Pizza!

Aside from the comedic relief and poetic license I am taking with this review; understand the customer service of this establishment (except for the young lady who answered the phone, she was amazingly polite and understanding) is piss poor and their ignorance, both the driver and the manager, is truly stunning. I do hope that the owner takes heed and incorporates some sensitivity training. A customer with a disability should NEVER be made to feel responsible for a service professionals laziness or lack of willingness to perform their job. Nor should they have to take extreme efforts to receive the same level of service as non-​disabled persons.
This was one of my favorite go-​to places for palatable food and so as I have done for the better part of two years since moving here, I ordered online through my besty @Eat24 for delivery. The «delivery» person called my cell to let me know that the food was outside. I told him to knock on the door and someone would collect the food (a note that is included in the special instructions, btw). The «delivery» person refused because I «wasn’t in the house.»
I figured maybe he needed assurance so I explained that the order was already paid for and that there is someone in the house to collect the food from him, he need only to knock. I only ordered and paid for it as I have done multiple times in the past. He again refused. He said he calls because he «expects you to answer the door while you are on the phone.»
I explained to the «delivery» person that the order was already paid for and it was noted that he would have to knock on the door to «deliver» it to the deaf person inside, not sit outside two houses down and beep the horn. I also explained in this day and age of cell phones and the internet, his expectation was rather… archaic …to say the very least. His response was to leave, refusing to deliver the food until someone was standing in the door to greet him.
So I called the restaurant and explained to the manager that there was a deaf person receiving the order and the «delivery» person needed to knock to alert the service animals who’d in turn alert someone to answer the door… not too complex for a delivery person — based on the fact that «delivering» food is part of his job description and all. I complained to no avail, my daughter had to stand in the doorway waiting for the delivery person to eventually come back. Truly a minor inconvenience in the world today, especially after I contacted Eat24 for help and as usual their amazing customer service made this experience better than it was.
So why am I writing this review with only one star when we really like the food and Eat24’s customer service response wins the day every time?
Because when I called the restaurant to complain to the manager about the «delivery» person refusing to deliver, he pretty much said that it is not his «delivery» person’s responsibility to knock on the door and deliver the food «just because someone is deaf, she should have someone there helping her.» 0_​o?
Well my good man, I can only agree with you that it is not your «delivery» person’s job to take the food to the door… and knock on it… «just because a customer is deaf.» I mean it’s preposterous to think that anyone would make such a demand! –Yet conversely, because he is a «delivery» person isn’t it his job to take the food to the door and knock on it… because that is the actual definition of DELIVERY? And a person in that position can sometimes be required to DELIVER things?
A delivery person delivering something that is just a novel idea, isn’t it?

This place sucks. The service is rude the food is cold and it takes forever. They will mostly likely get your order wrong. Save your money and go somewhere else

Placed $ 5.25 on the counter to pay for my sandwich only to have the angry cashier look at me in disgust and tell me that I was rude for not physically handing her my money. Rude would’ve been throwing money at her, being on my cell phone, etc. Don’t need the attitude, not going back. Ugh.

Good pizza, although the large pie seemed a bit small. Delivery wasn’t super fast, but the pizza itself was delicious! I’ll definitely be ordering again.

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY! This is the first and last time I will order from Stacy’s. When I called the woman who picked up and took my order was rude and impatient. She didn’t clarify my order, or tell me how long it would take she just hung up after she too my order, she didn’t even ask me my method of payment. After an hour and 10 min I called back to find out how much longer my my order would take, the woman was once again arrogant and rude and and blew me off by telling five more minutes. 15 more minutes past and the driver called me and said he needed 5 more minutes to find my place which was strange because during my first call in I gave detailed instructions on where I lived. You would think they woman who took my call would have shared that information with the driver, but I guess that would be asking too much. When my order finally arrived it was cold, the wings were tiny and dried out, and the bag it came in was soaked in wing sauce as though it had be stored on its side or upside-​down. I do not recommend ordering from this place, I know I won’t be again.

Over all I really like this place.. The ONLY issue I have is that it seems like I wait for a long time every time I order. (At lest 15 – 20 min)
BUT w that said the food is always good an hot when I get it.

I ordered the Stacey Special cheese steak it was good, could’ve been better if the roll was toasted

After reading other reviews, of this and the other location, I got the jist that the staff here are ignorant and annoying but that the food was decent. I ordered a stromboli online, and I half expected them to call with an issue because that seems to be a common experience.
In fact they did call with an issue, ten minutes later. The woman called me and said that the price I was given when I ordered FROM THEIR WEBSITE was wrong. I said that it certainly was not, and that I had ordered from their own menu. I then pointed out that I had used a $ 5.00 coupon, one that they advertise both on their website and on the paper menu they left at my home, in BIG BOLD LETTERS. «Sign Up For Our Rewards Points and Get $ 5 Off!»
She said «Oh you had a coupon? It don’t say there here.» Okay then. Your own system doesn’t recognize that I utilized a coupon on your own website with a code that your own website emailed me five minutes ago? This did not bode well for what was to come.
When the delivery guy got nearby he called and asked for the cross street, and then said he was rounding the corner. I put on shoes and was just about to walk out my door to go downstairs when the buzzer for the front door rang. My order specifically said to call, NOT to ring the buzzer. My orders always say this, because I don’t want to bother my housemate who sleeps in the day and works at night. I have NEVER had a problem until today.
I went down to the door and was honestly just devoid of reaction, but I had a very Miranda Priestly moment when I said «I don’t know why you felt the need to press the buzzer when I just told you I was on my way down. I’m sorry I wasn’t able to move at a pace exceeding speeds achievable by human beings.» I’m kind of proud of that.
Anyway the food is disgusting. Firstly this isn’t a stromboli, it’s a calzone. YES, there is a difference. Secondly the very SMELL of it was sour, so you can only imagine the taste. It tastes like rotten dough was wrapped around fetid cheese and meat. I ate one segment and have thrown the rest in the trash.
Ladies and gentlemen, learn from Unilocal reviews. Don’t take a chance.

My wife and try hamburger there
Oh man the price is too high
The place no eat in and charge people too much. It ok just one time, because I am hungry take my son to the doctor at Chop
50^th & Market street.

I was a little hesitant to order from Stacy’s and now I see why.
I believe that the employees of this pizza shop are generally unprofessional. I had issues ordering over the phone which was a new experience for me. I was a little put off by the same employees when I walked over to the restaurant to pick up my food.
The spaghetti and meatballs I ordered were barely edible. Unseasoned, topped with entirely too much cheese and the meatballs were cut up for some reason instead of left whole. I’m assuming they’re not made in house.
I guess it’s hard to mess up a cheese-​steak so if I am forced to eat from this place again I think that might be the only thing I would order.
Otherwise, I would recommend not steering too far away from things of that nature.

The Buffalo-​delphia steak is the best overall steak I have ever had. Their fries are good, and the people who work there have always seemed fine to me. Everyone I’ve ever taken there when my buffa-​jonez kicked in has been happy with the sandwiches they got.
I have never gotten pizza and never gotten delivery.
$ 1.50 off steaks on Mondays!@ That’s the big boh yah.

My concern about the food is Stacy’s is that it is completely unexceptional. It is mediocre, there is nothing here that makes Stacy’s stand apart from the crowd. It isn’t as if it is the only pizza place in the middle of nowhere and it isn’t as if they put some amazing amounts of thought into what they cook.
The appetizers are delicious but it is because they are fried, and fried to a crisp. Everything tastes great when friend, but Stacy’s doesn’t appear to make them from scratch. Or if they do, then they (not surprisingly) freeze it first.
I found the pizza smaller than usual and also greasier than what I prefer.
I don’t want to praise other places in a review for this place, but google pizza in University City or even search on Unilocal and you’ll find better places.
Sorry Stacy’s, but your run-​down look does’t add to a retro appeal in any way.

Just got a spinach and mushroom pizza. And it was SOOO GOOD! The guy behind the counter was visibly worried about how I was planning to bring my pizza home. (It was raining and I was on a scooter)

The bbq wings are quite good but suspiciously different every time I order them
The pizza tastes okay– better than anything else I’ve tried in the area– but they never cut it all the way through. Last time we ordered a pizza it came in three pieces: one tiny sliver, one regular-​sized slice and then the rest of the pie. How is it even possible to get an odd number of even odder sized slices with a pizza cutter? Incredible.
It also takes at least an hour to get your pizza which means that it’s always cold by the time i get it (I live 6 blocks away).
The delivery people also generally refuse to get out of their cars. Recently I’ve been playing games of «Chicken» with the delivery guy to see who will make the first move.
I once had the pleasure of an elderly couple delivering my food. They chastised me for not answering my phone (they had called the wrong number) and wouldn’t let me walk away until they had scoured the order paper to make sure I had left a tip on my card.
Oh, and sometimes the delivery guy will call and tell you he’s outside when he’s actually 10 minutes away.
.but the wings. I really like the wings. Don’t get the mild ones– they’re just soaked in orange grease.

This place is way too close to where I live. And they make respectable pizza, and everything else for that matter.
They’re friendly, cheap, and close-​by. All the things I look for in a pizza place. I’d normally rate them a 3, but they’ve really come through in the clutch for me on late nights.
Here’s to you, Stacy’s!

In many ways it’s easier to identify bad pizza than good pizza. There’s many ways to make a delicious pizza, maybe it’s the extra care into the dough, an amazing sauce, or the perfect cheese and toppings. Making pizza bad can often be done quickly. Stacey’s Pizza comes in huge greasy slices covered with tasteless cheese with very little sauce. Upon examining my pizza it almost looked as if there was a layer of cheese, a thin layer of sauce, and a huge heaping layer of cheese.
All in all, bad pizza, not worth it, too many better choices much closer.

Stacey, honey, I love your fries… I avoid them on purpose… but I still dream about them. *swoon*
My co workers swear by your other foodstuffs, but it’s the fries that I sneak from their desks at lunchtime.

This is a pretty yummy corner pizza shop serving a pie with a thinner crust (not super thing though) and lots of cheese. If you’re a local, call them for your next delivery!